Showing posts with label Arson. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Arson. Show all posts

07 November 2011

Firebugs

My 'Burning with indignation: Arson, law and the 2009 Victorian bushfires' in 15(1) Local Government Law Journal (2009) 35 critiqued the outbreak of security theatre that followed close on the 2009 bushfires.

That outbreak saw politicians rushing to announce significantly stronger penalties for arsonists and media figures indulging in penal populism regarding 'bushfire arson', an offence that was apparently unique and egregious. I suggested that in the rush to judgment people appeared to ignore the reality that -
• some bushfires are 'acts of god' (eg started by lightning rather than by cunning pyromaniacs with beady red eyes and pointy evil ears),
• some may be attributable to poor maintenance of powerlines and other infrastructure (a comment that was later substantiated in official hearings),
• the deaths in 2009 although deeply regrettable might in part be attributable to the vicissitudes of evacuating people from difficult terrain at short notice, and
• some arsonists might lack the capacity we assume in an average Australian adult.
The deterrent value of a mandatory 25 year or life sentence is unclear when dealing with children who play with matches or adults who have fundamental psychological problems.

The last point is significant: it is undesirable as a matter of justice and public policy to impose extraordinary sanctions on people who have cognitive or other deficiencies, particularly if penal populism results in a higher punishment of someone whose action results in death through a bushfire than through a deliberately lit urban fire.

The ABC today reports that prosecutors have dropped all charges against two teenage boys (aged 15 and 16) accused of lighting a fatal bushfire at Bendigo in central Victoria on Black Saturday. That fire destroyed 58 homes, burned 341 hectares and resulted in the death of one man.

The boys were initially charged with arson causing death and intentionally causing a bushfire. In August this year, however, psychologists told the court that the boys are of abnormally low intelligence and incapable of understanding a trial or properly instructing their lawyers.

At that time they were deemed unfit to be tried but were still to face a special hearing to determine their guilt or innocence. The Victorian Supreme Court has today been told that the Director of Public Prosecutions will no longer pursue the case on the basis of insufficient evidence and a recognition that it was not in the public interest to proceed.

03 May 2010

Registering suspected arsonists

In 'Burning With Indignation: Arson, Law and the 2009 Victorian Bushfires', 15(1) Local Government Law Journal (2009 35-45 I expressed concern about the problematical nature of calls for special penalties regarding bushfire arson and the fuzziness of much of the data on which legislators were ostensibly relying in characterisations such as 'the bushfire arsonist'.

It is clear, for example, that much of the suffering in the recent Victorian bushfires was attributable to 'acts of nature' (or inefficiencies in the maintenance of powerlines) and to land use policies (poor decisions about the location of building in fire-prone areas and about the capacity of roads for evacuating people when serious fires occur) rather than 'pyromaniacs'. The latter may not use a calculus of offence, detection and punishment, therefore not being susceptible to deterrence.

Such concerns have not been embraced by the Commonwealth government, which today announced at the second annual National Forum for the Prevention of Bushfire Arson that it would be "establishing a centralised national database of convicted and suspected arsonists". The basis for inclusion on that register (how suspect is 'suspected') and its use (exclusion of suspected arsonists from service with volunteer bushfire brigades? information shared around town? information mandatorily drawn to the attention of local/state government when the suspected offender moves interstate?) is unclear.

The event "demonstrates the ongoing commitment of Commonwealth, State and Territory Governments to work together to prevent and deter arson through a coordinated and nationally agreed framework". The Commonwealth initiatives are similarly promoted as "important and practical initiatives to promote national collaboration in combating bushfire arson". They include "investing in the development of a 'Bushfire Arson Investigation Course' to build the expertise of arson investigators across the country" and "launching a 'Bushfire Arson Prevention Manual', developed by the Australian Institute of Criminology, to help local communities develop strategies to prevent arson". The latter should be interesting, given the AIC's recognition of the need to be cautious in dealing with figures that result in Ministerial claims that "up to half of all bushfires [are] being deliberately lit or starting in suspicious circumstances".

The new offender/suspected offender database is -
A centralised national database of arsonists will provide local authorities with access to up-to-date information on arsonists which may be used to direct intervention strategies at times of high risk.
The scope of that intervention is unclear. 'Lockem up'? Park a patrol car at the front gate in the hope that Pete the Pyro won't scarper over the back fence with his incendiary toolkit? Quarantine the bored schoolkids?

Who will have access to the database? Will 'suspected' arsonists be able to gain a correction if data is faulty, or signal that they contest the accuracy of data, or even be alerted that inclusion on the register has taken place?

17 August 2009

Bushfires

The Victorian Royal Commission on the 2009 Bushfires has released its Interim Report (with a Final Report, including consideration of "methods for prevention, detection and management of arson", to be issued at the end of July next year).

Release of the report follows the March 2009 'National Forum on the Reduction of Deliberate Bushfires in Australia', which resulted in a commitment to explore mechanisms for improved information sharing about bushfire management and "better coordination between police, fire and emergency services to engage in targeted prevention programs and share information in investigating crimes". The Forum echoed hyperbole about "the worst day in Victoria's history", along with expressions by the Prime Minister and other politicians that arsonists are "evil", guilty of "murder on a grand scale", something for which "there is no excuse ... none at all". "What do you say about anyone like that — there are no words to describe it other than mass murder."

Mr Rudd claimed that ""We are left speechless at the thought and the possibility that some of these fires may have been deliberately lit" - a speechlessness that didn't last very long - and indicated that "Something which the nation must now attend to as a matter of grave urgency is the problem of arson ... Let us attend to this unfinished business of the nation and come to grips with this evil thing".

Given that bushfires are not unusual occurrences (and deficiencies in institutional cooperation have been recurrently highlighted, for example in the 2006 Canberra Firestorm coroner's report on the 2003 ACT bushfires) one might wonder why mechanisms haven't been developed in the past and whether the results of the no-doubt heartfelt commitment will be any different to the past.

The National Forum, and associated media releases at the national and state/territory level, gained attention for statements about "drafting model laws for stronger, more consistent arson offences with penalties of up to 25 years for bushfire arson causing death or serious harm". Those statements are an expression of 'security theatre', embodying a politics of demonisation and reassurance that is arguably out of kilter with the realities of who engages in arson and why they did so.

The author's 'Burning With Indignation: Arson, Law and the 2009 Victorian Bushfires' at pp35-45 of 15(1) Local Government Law Journal (July 2009) thus questioned the effectiveness of new laws to double the time in prison for adults convicted of deliberately setting bushfires, given that the psychological problems of some bushfire arsonists mean that deterrence is probably not significant. Spiffy new laws will not, of course, deter 'experiments with fire' involving children.

Much of the attitudinising about stronger penalties is inflamatory. It does not serve to meaningfully inhibit future bushfire arson. We might ask whether there is a need to differentiate between bushfire and non-bushfire arson, and whether existing criminal law is adequate.

We might also want to ask some tougher questions, including whether land management regimes should be changed to, for example, assist more regular burning off around the outskirts of rural towns and facilities (the ACT Coroner's Report noted complaints of smoke pollution - echoed in the current Victorian Royal Commission hearings - and criticism that burning off in the vicinity of Canberra had been deferred because smoke would reduce the delights of the Governor-General's garden party) and ensure better road access to high-risk rural and urban-fringe areas.