17 November 2009

Archives Adieu

Amid hoopla from the national government about major reforms to informational law (including strengthening of access under the Freedom of Information Act and establishment of an Information Commissioner) it is disturbing to encounter reports that the National Archives of Australia (NAA) is planning to close its Adelaide, Darwin and Hobart offices.

The Director-General of the NAA indicates that
In order to make savings of this order, to meet current commitments and move to being a 21st century organisation that can meet future demands, we need to make fundamental changes to the way we operate.
Being a '21st century organisation' (whatever that is ... presumably one that uses the latest management-speak and has lots of high-tech kit with impressive blinking lights) should not involve excising arms and legs.

Meeting 'future demands' should not mean fundamentally restricting demand by restricting access, especially restriction on the part of an organisation that boasts about its provision of "leadership in archives and records management within Australia and internationally".

Restriiction is antithetical to the Government's announceme earlier this year that
In a significant pro-disclosure reform to the Archives Act, it is proposed that the "open access period" be substantially brought forward. The Archives Act is to be amended to bring forward the open access period for most records from 30 years to 20 years, and for Cabinet notebooks from 50 years to 30 years.
In announcing the changes the NAA Director-General notes that
Some of the records may be relocated to our repositories in Sydney or Melbourne, while others may be relocated locally under a memorandum of understanding arrangement with other sympathetic local cultural heritage institutions.
The closure is attributed, correctly or othwerwise, to the Mid-Year Economic & Fiscal Outlook budget cuts. Although details are uncertain, the closures will reportedly 'save' a derisory $4.9m - a reduction of some $700,000 in the current financial year followed by reductions of $1.4m per year over the next 3 years. Real savings may be less once staff redundency payments are factored in, there is payment to the "sympathetic local cultural institutions" (unlikely to be so sympathetic that they will obligingly accept burdens without recompense) and there is recognition of 'hidden' costs such as trans-Australian shipment of files to 'information access offices' provided by other agencies or 'digitisation on demand' for remote access. The cost of relocating files from the regional offices to the remaining offices, referred to by the Director-General, is unclear. One might wonder how long those offices will remain (are Brisbane and Perth next in the queue for 'rightsizing'?) and ask whether the latest iteration of the 'new federalism' should be more than unilateral buck-passing.

$4.9m is less than the cost of sundry military projects of proven unfunctionality (Collins Submarines, anyone) or successive IT projects damned by the Auditor-General as ill-conceived and poorly executed. (The $8m on the DOA site known as GroceryChoice is small change compared to some of the monumentally dysfunctional systems in agencies such as Customs and Defence.) It is also less than the notional cost of various 'government accessibility' and 'government 2.0' public consultation exercises underway at the moment.

Other benchmarks may be more invidious. As a community we are comfortable paying for tangibles - things that we can stroke, photograph, sit on or formally launch - rather than access to information. The latest annual report of the National Capital Authority notes that "RG Menzies Walk reconstruction Stage 1" in Citizenship Place (which "includes a sitting wall on a gravel beach with the citizenship affirmation inscribed in brass lettering and a sign showing the timeline of Australian citizenship") cost $450,000. The NAA annual report notes that "media advertising company hma Blaze was paid $126,280 (including GST) by the Archives in 2007–08".

The NCA also reports that
On 17 March 2008, a custom-made glass panel spontaneously shattered at the Australian Service Nurses National Memorial. The panel incorporated artwork that forms part of the memorial's curving commemorative walls. The Authority undertook a structural audit of the memorial to determine the cause of the breakage and determined that the glass panel could be replaced. Remedial paving works were performed in conjunction with the glass replacement. The memorial was reopened to the public on 27 October 2008. The cost of these works was $109,223 (including GST).
Should memory and memorialisation be restricted to glass panels and bits of photogenic bronze?

The rationale for closure of the NAA's regional presence is unclear. Tensions within the Archives have been apparent over a number of years, with suggestions for example that the organisation simply centralise all access in Canberra (with academics, journalists, students and other members of the public being forced to come to the national capital) or rely on digitisation of the kilometres of records in its repositories across Australia.

Past executives and members of the organisation's Advisory Council have resisted such quick fixes, arguing that there is value for officials and for the public in having a network of Archives regional offices (ie having archival material stored in the region in which those files or other items were created and being able to examine that material in the relevant state/territory capital or retrieve it from that office for official scrutiny). They have criticised the 'cost savings uber alles' ethos, noting that a quite nifty way to save small amounts of money - by federal government standards - would be to turn most archival material into cardboard. Why not get rid of that pesky FOI Act as well ... and some inconvenient courts or administrative law?

The Archives Act 1983 (Cth) does not prohibit the closure. Section 63 of that Act ('Location of material of the Archives') gives the Director-General considerable discretion. It specifies that "material of the Archives shall be kept at such places as the Director-General considers appropriate". If it was cheaper to store records in Nauru, Patagonia or Antactica the Director-General presumably has the authority to authorise such a transfer. Section 63(2) of the Act states that
In considering the places at which material of the Archives should be kept, the Director-General shall take into account:

(a) the convenience of persons who are likely to require access to the material;

(b) the desirability of keeping related material in the same place; and

(c) the appropriateness of keeping in a State or Territory material that relates in particular to that State or Territory or to places in that State or Territory.
Closure is analogous to the National Library closing its reading rooms for four days a week ... readily justifiable on 'cost' grounds (analogous to the Yes Minister model of refusing any patients access to a hospital, because all those sick people get in the way of the floor polishing and people with management consultant clipboards) but contrary to the organisation's raison d'etre.

The closure is a short-sighted and self-defeating measure that should be strongly condemned by anyone with an interest in Australian history and public administration and by anyone who expects the current Government to 'walk the talk' about public access to public information.

13 November 2009

Chatterboxes

Read Arthur Schlesinger Jr's Journals 1952-2000 (Penguin Press, 2007) on the bus back from Sydney on Monday. Not a pleasant experience: too much preening, self-congratulation regarding association with the enlightened or eligible, and infatuation with the Kennedys, dead or alive.

Schlesinger notes a review of his memoirs by Jonathan Yardley that indicts him as "a name dropper, social climber, celebrity hound, Kennedy toady etc etc". That might have been true enough to sting. Maureen Dowd's NY Times review more kindly argued that
It's hard not to like a book that expounds on Marilyn Monroe on one page and the Monroe Doctrine on the next. When Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr. ruminates on the realm of hemispheric affairs, the transition from one Monroe to the other is seamless, as is the slide from Bosnia to Bianca Jagger and from Alexander Hamilton to Angie Dickinson. His diaries are a Tiffany’s window of name-dropping. This is not history so much as historical trail mix.

The old-school, bow-tied liberal and Kennedy courtier had a weakness for cafe society and Century Club martinis served by Arthur the Barbadian drinks waiter. He was just as happy talking about NATO enlargement or celebrity enlargement, fastidiously jotting down when Elizabeth Taylor, Norman Mailer and Robert Bork — and himself, "alas" — looked a bit fat. And heaven help poor John Kenneth Galbraith's wife, Kitty, the night she showed up amid the "notables affably circulating," as our diarist likes to say, "dowdily dressed."
I've noted Isaiah Berlin's 1952 comment to Schlesinger in Enlightening: Letters 1946-1960 (Chatto & Windus, 2009) that
I generally think that everything I do is superficial, worthless, glaringly shallow, and could not take in an idiot child.
Exactamundo.

Having escaped from a seminar with Chinese bureaucrats about value-adding in the processing of agricultural commodities - much eye rolling when I highlighted concerns regarding contamination (the 'melamine milkshake' problem discussed by Marion Nestle in Petfood Politics) - and the Faculty's 'mission statement' meeting I'm now reading The Rule of Law Under Siege: Selected Essays of Franz Neumann & Otto Kirchheimer (University of California Press, 1996), Khaled El-Rouayheb's Before Homosexuality in the Arab-Islamic World, 1500-1800 (University of Chicago Press, 2005) and Vernon Bogdanor's The New British Constitution (Hart, 2009).

The El-Rouayheb is worth sighting just for the delightful picture of nubian goats on the front cover.

12 November 2009

Collingwood's Ghost

I confess to being perplexed by Fred Inglis' History Man: The Life of R G Collingwood (Princeton University Press, 2009), a work that at times strikes me as confused - or perhaps merely eccentric - as Collingwood himself.

Inglis writes that
I am arguing for a view of Collingwood's life that retrieves him, as surely he would have wanted, from the parlour gaming prison-house of philosophy, and resituates him in a history, necessarily a history of private life and its presence in public thinking, a history also of how metaphysics may glow in the light of an ill-kept schooner in the Mediterranean as the gathering storm rolls in, on the face of a tombstone 1,800 years old, in the recollection of a mother's lovely face as she sang to a listening household, in the swift accumulation of pages of handwriting piled up towards a finished book, a set of answers to some sharp and pressing questions.
Collingwood's biographer unfortunately, it seems to me, isn't going to answer some of those questions (why did he skip out on his wife? Did he launch clockwork mice at his tute students in a successful effort to disconcert them, as an effort to thaw the chill of his lecturing or just because he thought it was a fun thing to do and the thing one did when a poker wasn't available?).

Instead, he repeatedly bludgeons the reader with prose such as
However this may be, Collingwood moved perforce to London, rented a room at 69 Kensington Church Street, and every morning walked to work past the splendours of Kensington Palace and into Kensington Gardens. On his right was the bulbous magnificence of the Albert Hall, ahead of him the shining surface of the Serpentine and, as he took the Flower Walk past the Queen's Gate he braced himself daily for the shock to his system rendered by the Albert Memorial, with the great consort seated beneath his spindly, overdecorated, and towering shelter, rather on the lines of the giant candle extinguisher carried by the Ghost of Christmas Past.
Inglis claims that
Finding room for these things in the house of biography is then to limn the outline of the fable. In the case of a philosopher whose first precept directs us to the identity of theory and practice, not only are thought and feeling indissolubly linked, they take both form and content in tension with mere eventuality, transfiguring those events into experience, where that rather blank (but venerable) concept turns out to mean events-that-signify, significance being given by the collusion of our best thoughts and the best feelings that may inform them.
Quite; one can't have too much limning or brightly-coloured blancmange.

Globocop

High profile media specialist Geoffrey Robertson QC has criticised UK 'defamation tourism' in a short speech reported [PDF] by the Guardian.

Robertson claims that
We do not have free speech in Britain, we have expensive speech. Any statement which "lowers a person in the eyes of right thinking members of the community" is defamatory, and is therefore presumed to be false, although it may very well be true. Defending a libel action in Britain is vastly more expensive than in any other European country – lawyers will rack up a million pounds in fees for a short trial and our cash-strapped media is increasingly choosing to settle rather than to fight for its freedom – which, after all, is its reader's freedom to receive information.
He argues for "one simple and necessary reform", ie
to abolish the arcane presumption of falsity and require libel claimants – like claimants in any other branch of the civil law – to prove that the statement was false. Placing the burden of proof on media defendants has produced innumerable miscarriages of justice in libel trials. It is the reason why US courts refuse to enforce English defamation judgments and why US newspapers are now threatening to withdraw from London, known as 'a town called Sue'.
Robertson notes that
the British media is partly the author of its own misfortune. It has never much cared to fight for free speech in recent times, notwithstanding John Wilkes and those courageous book sellers who, two centuries ago, went to prison for publishing Tom Paine. Instead, our media funds the Press Complaints Commission - a confidence trick that has ceased to inspire confidence. Newspapers deceive their readers when they pretend that PCC decisions have any significance. In these days of conditional fee agreements, the Council no longer functions as a 'poor persons libel court'. It has abjectly failed to halt the advance of a vague privacy law, based on incoherent Euro-prosaic concepts and which denies the media the right to jury trial.
Much the same could be said of the Australian Press Council (APC), a body that gives self-involved and indolent tabby cats a bad name.

Robertson also exhorts the UK to
abolish the rule that allows foreigners to come here and to haul their foreign critics into our Courts because of internet downloads from foreign websites. We are not a libel Globo-cop and our plaintiff-friendly law is making Britain an international free speech black spot, the place where the world’s human rights violators come to sue their critics. Only if internet libels are uploaded here or are advertised or directed here should English courts entertain libel actions against their authors.

11 November 2009

Parallel Imports

The Australian Government has announced that it will be retaining restrictions in the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) regarding parallel importation of books. The announcement represents a rejection of recommendations by the Productivity Commission in July this year (perhaps influenced by uncertainty about whether the price of music CDs and computer software fell after the end of restrictions in those markets) and will encourage Australia's fragile book publishing industry. 

 The Innovation Minister's media release argues that
Australian book printing and publishing is under strong competitive pressure from international online booksellers such as Amazon and The Book Depository and the Government has formed the view that that this pressure is likely to intensify. In addition, the technology of electronic books (e-books) like Kindle Books will continue to improve with further innovations and price reductions expected.
The Productivity Commission argued that Parallel Import Restrictions (PIRs) are an inappropriate barrier, noting that
for a title to qualify for protection under the PIRs, the Australian territorial rights holder must release the book in Australia within 30 days of it being published elsewhere in the world, and must maintain a capacity to resupply it within 90 days. There are some exceptions to the restrictions — consumers can purchase books from abroad, for example via the internet and, under the 'single use' provisions, a bookseller can purchase a single copy of a book that would otherwise be PIR-protected, to fill a specific customer order. Under the PIRs, if a particular novel or textbook is published in Australia within the 30 day limit, booksellers cannot import and sell stocks of the same book from, say, the UK, the US or Asia. This enables rights holders to charge prices (or obtain royalties) in the Australian market with the certainty that they cannot be undercut by commercial quantities of imports of the same titles. Assistance from Australia's PIRs is not limited to Australian publishers and authors. The publishers who benefit from territorial protection can be Australian businesses, Australian arms of international companies or international companies operating from other countries. Likewise, the works of both Australian and foreign authors are equally protected from parallel imports into Australia.
It considers that PIRs provide
territorial protection for the publication of many books in Australia, preventing booksellers from sourcing cheaper or better value-for-money editions of those titles from world markets. From the available quantitative and qualitative evidence, the Commission has concluded that the PIRs place upward pressure on book prices and that, at times, the price effect is likely to be substantial. The magnitude of the effect will vary over time and across book genres. Most of the benefits of PIR protection accrue to publishers and authors, with demand for local printing also increased. Most of the costs are met by consumers, who fund these benefits in a nontransparent manner through higher book prices. PIRs are a poor means of promoting culturally significant Australian works. They do not differentiate between books of high and low cultural value. The bulk of the assistance leaks offshore, and some flows to the printing industry.
Given that assessment it is unsurprising that the Commission claimed that
Reform of the current arrangements is necessary, to place downward pressure on book prices, remove constraints on the commercial activities of booksellers and overcome the poor targeting of assistance to the cultural externalities.

Bloodsucking undead fiends

I'm of course talking about the legal profession, rather than academics, in celebration of despatching a co-authored (with legal wizard Bill Orr) conference paper on Bram Stoker's 1897 Dracula as a legal text. (In referring to Mr Orr it is indeed a rarity to find someone who's such a pleasure to work with: analytically rigorous, witty, learned, patient.)

Dracula is a legal novel as much as it is an exposition of horror and virtue triumphant, a drama in which law and lawyers are as prominent as a tale by John Grisham or Dickens' Bleak House. It is permeated by references to law — the laws of man and the law of nature — along with depiction of characters who are either legal practitioners (for example Harker and Van Helsing), who have some familiarity with the law (for example Godalming and Dracula himself) or who deal with practitioners and legal documents.

From a contemporary perspective it features a foreign national who breached migration and phytosanitary law, engaged in theft and poisoning, committed trespass and false imprisonment, stalked and assaulted minors and adults, associated with the equivalent of an outlaw motorcycle gang and blithely ignored the traffic code. A group of vigilantes, uninhibited by their legal training, responded with offences such as unauthorised disinterment and interference with a corpse.

The paper uses characters such as the eponymous vampire and the fearless lawyer Van Helsing as a lens for understanding legal personhood, crime and responsibility in an age where anxieties about 'the alien' are proving to be as timeless as the undead gentleman from Transylvania.

Despite the passage of over 100 years most of the transgressions underlying Stoker's novel remain relevant. Assault, theft, threat and validity of contract are timeless, irrespective of whether there is an antimacassar or iPod in the vicinity. Anxieties about the permeability of borders, unauthorised imports of toxic substances (silver sand, white powder) or gangs (gypsies, Bandidos and Coffin Cheaters) are not new.

Some indeed may have a particular resonance for contemporary readers who have encountered questions about bioterrorism, genetic engineering (transducing genes from one species to another), culpability in the transmission of HIV, the determination of death (Dracula, although UnDead, meets criteria for liveness in for example the Transplantation & Anatomy Act 1979 (Qld)) or the rights of animals.

07 November 2009

Indigenous justice

Yet another 'justice framework' in Australia, with "endorsement" by the Commonwealth, state and territory Governments of the National Indigenous Law and Justice Framework.

The Framework is pitched as tackling (perhaps more accurate as a comitment to tackle) "serious Indigenous law and justice issues" and as representing "the first nationally agreed approach to Indigenous law and justice". The aim is to
reduce the overrepresentation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in the criminal justice system by focusing on community safety and reducing rates of alcohol and substance related crime.
It was developed by the Indigenous Justice Working Group of of the Standing Committee of Attorneys-General (SCAG). The Framework is meant to form the basis of a "long term strategic approach to Indigenous law and justice issues and support work being done to 'close the gap' on Indigenous disadvantage".

Endorsement of the Framework was the centrepiece of the Indigenous Justice Roundtable at which as the Attorneys-General, Indigenous Affairs Ministers, Police Ministers and Police Commissioners
agreed to work together to improve policing, respond to alcohol abuse, strengthen the co-ordination of service delivery, and better support Indigenous victims of crime.
The Ministers agreed that
the right to live free from violence is a fundamental human right. Community safety is also a vital pre-condition to achieve COAG's targets in health, education and housing. It was agreed that if there is not action to address serious problems in this area, it will not be possible to make improvements in other areas.
That agreement was reflected in the policy version of Casablanca ("arrest the usual suspects"), with statements that included
* Building relationships of trust and respect between Indigenous communities and the police could encourage the early reporting of family violence, reduce intimidation and fear, and increase confidence in the justice system.
* Sharing information between police and other key welfare agencies was critical to providing timely and effective support for victims of crime, particularly children. Prompt, effective sharing of information helps welfare agencies intervene early before a situation escalates. It also reduces unnecessary intrusion by multiple agencies into family life.
* It is critical that victims of family violence and sexual assault have access to sustained and responsive services. The National Plan to Reduce Violence Against Women and Children emphasises the importance of a service delivery model based on the philosophy that the "first door must be the right door". This means that a victim's first point of contact with formal services, whether it is police, medical, legal, accommodation, counselling or child protection, must be able to support women and children in a compassionate and professional manner through the recovery process.
What will be the outcome? In the first instance, - strategies, lots of strategies (and presumably each with its own mini-launch). The Ministers agreed to
develop an effective approach for determining law enforcement and support services required in remote and very remote communities, and to recruiting and retaining sworn officers, especially Indigenous officers
A jaundiced observer might argue that the development is hardly radical and shouldn't, in fact, be new. There's a similar sense of 'same old, same old' with announcement that the Ministers will "develop strategies to reduce alcohol induced violence, abuse and crimes in affected Indigenous communities" (surely we haven't just realised that there's a problem, albeit one that's intractable) and will "provide leadership at all levels on the need for information sharing and integrated service delivery, particularly in relation to family violence and child abuse or neglect cases". We might hope that leadership extends beyond photo opportunities.