05 January 2010

History is still over

One of my friends defines chutzpah using the example of the parricide who claims the mercy of the court on the basis that he's an orphan.

I thought of that when reading 'History Is Still Over' [here] by Francis Fukuyama - a dash of Spengler, a dose of Thomas Friedman, a splash of Ayn Rand - in Newsweek. It's an explanation of "how capitalism survived the crisis", reassuring presumably for devotees of the idea that history ended some time in the 1980s. That idea - as silly as many of 'new economy' dogmas that legitimised the dot com bubble - was expounded so much more eloquently by Sellar & Yeatman at the end of 1066 and All That A Memorable History of England, comprising all the parts you can remember, including 103 Good Things, 5 Bad Kings and 2 Genuine Dates.

"In the fourth quarter of 2008, global growth abruptly went into reverse, and the enormous edifice of globalization itself seemed to teeter." Business as usual, say many historians, which would account for "What is striking is how little about the pre-crisis world has changed".

04 January 2010

Social invisibility

Presentations from the 1 December 2009 Castan Centre symposium on Indigenous Birth Registration and Birth Certificates are now online.

They include copies of articles, in particular by Paula Gerber, and ppt slides (notably a set by Joel Orenstein).

Strongly recommended for people with an interest in the mechanics of identity, in Indigenous affairs or in justice.

03 January 2010

Self-invention

Reading Lynette Silver's Marcel Caux: A Life Unravelled (Milton: Wiley 2005), an account of Harold Katte's reinvention of himself as Frenchman Marcel Caux after unpleasantness on active service in the 1914-18 War.

Katte successfully adopted a new identity on return from the Western Front, conning the Veterans Affairs bureaucracy for about eighty years and having his second life 'unravel' at the age of around 100 when he was discovered to be one of the 'last diggers' (and hence appropriated by politicians and the 'repatriation industry'.

Katte/Caux had served in the trenches and is thus unlike impostors who've claimed financial benefits, military honours or merely public esteem to which they were not entitled ... often on an egregiously implausible basis.

One example was 'Major' Reg Newton, former junior vice-president of the 8th Division Association in Australia, who claimed a Military Cross and bar ("awarded ... for heavy action Laos"), service as a secret agent during the Cold War (setting up escape lines in East Germany in 1951, almost killed in Mongolia and wounded in Korea) and decoration by King George VI. Evidence emerged in 2006 that he was never a major, had not been awarded the Military Cross and indeed had never served overseas. Newton reportedly told acquaintances there were no records of his exploits and honours because his work was "top secret". Uh huh.

UK fantasist Alan McIlwraith was more inventive. He claimed to be Captain Sir Alan McIlwraith, CBE, DSO, MC, MiD: war hero, officer in the Parachute Regiment, top of his class at Sandhurst, an advisor to Supreme Allied Commander Europe General Wesley Clark and a terrorism expert who had served in Northern Ireland, the Balkans, Sierra Leone and Afghanistan. On exposure he blamed his fictions on "being hit on the head with a scaffolding pole by a gang of youths in the street". More recently he has been reported as having passed himself off at Strathclyde University as a millionaire property developer and charity worker, supposedly harvesting personal information such as National Insurance numbers from credulous students.

02 January 2010

Blasphemy

Ireland's new 'Blasphemy Law' - a section of the Defamation Act 2009 - came into effect yesterday and has been greeted by street theatre in the form of publication, by the republic's Atheist Society, of 25 'blasphemous' statements from figures such as Frank Zappa, the Rev Ian Paisley, George Carlin, Tom Lehrer, Richard Dawkins and Pope Benedict XVI. They are rather tame statements, unlikely to trigger a successful prosecution (in particular given statutory defences of speech that has literary, artistic, political, scientific or academic merit) but sufficient to attract global media attention.

Carlin's offering, which presumably won't sway the righteous or provoke a prosecution, is -
Think about it. Religion has actually convinced people that there's an invisible man living in the sky who watches everything you do, every minute of every day. And the invisible man has a special list of ten things he does not want you to do. And if you do any of these ten things, he has a special place, full of fire and smoke and burning and torture and anguish, where he will send you to live and suffer and burn and choke and scream and cry forever and ever ’til the end of time! But He loves you. He loves you, and He needs money! He always needs money! He’s all-powerful, all-perfect, all-knowing, and all-wise, somehow just can’t handle money! Religion takes in billions of dollars, they pay no taxes, and they always need a little more.
The Act characterises blasphemy as -
matter that is grossly abusive or insulting in relation to matters held sacred by any religion, thereby causing outrage among a substantial number of the adherents of that religion.
There is an element of intentionality, ie the person who publishes or utters that grossly abusive or insulting matter must intend to cause such outrage among a substantial number of the religion's adherents.

The Act specifies that 'religion' does not include "an organisation or cult" ... "the principal object of which is the making of profit" or that "employs oppressive psychological manipulation" of its followers or for the purpose of gaining new followers, an exclusion that Irish courts might find useful in allowing criticism of the notoriously litigious entity known as Scientology.

The Blasphemy Law was enacted last year, following repeal of Eire's 1961 Defamation Act. It makes blasphemy a crime punishable by a fine of €25,000, a penalty that's a sharp reduction from the €100,000 in the first draft.

The Atheist Society has argued that the new legislation is "both silly and dangerous" -
It is silly because it revives a medieval religious crime in a modern pluralist republic. And it is dangerous because it incentivises religious outrage, by making it the first trigger for defining blasphemy.

The problematic behaviour here is the outrage, not the expression of different beliefs. Instead of incentivising outrage, we should be educating people to respond in a more healthy manner than outrage when somebody expresses a belief that they find insulting.

The law also discriminates against atheist citizens by protecting the fundamental beliefs of religious people only. Why should religious beliefs be protected by law in ways that scientific or political or other secular beliefs are not?
The Irish government announced that it needed to pass a new blasphemy law to avoid leaving "a void" and to respect the Constitution, albeit a void that the Atheist Society noted had been in existence since at least 1999, when the Republic's Supreme Court found in Corway v Independent Newspapers [2001] 1 IRLM 426 that the 1961 law was unenforceable because it did not define blasphemy.

The 1937 Irish Constitution indicates that "the publication or utterance of blasphemous, seditious, or indecent material is an offence which shall be punishable in accordance with law" but contrary to some claims in the blogosphere Ireland has not had specific statute regarding blasphemy (whether in relation to a specific Christian church, more broadly protective of the Christian faith/deity, or of deities per se).

Protection instead has reflected traditional UK law with an offence of 'blasphemous libel' in common law and as part of defamation statutes. A 1991 report by the Law Reform Commission concluded there was no place for an offence of blasphemous libel -
in a society which respects freedom of speech. ... The argument in its favour that the publication of blasphemy causes injury to feelings appeared to us to be a tenuous basis on which to restrict freedom of speech. The argument that freedom to insult religion would threaten the stability of society by impairing the harmony between groups seemed highly questionable in the absence of any prosecutions.
Critics have suggested that -
We should be removing all of the 1930s religious references from the Constitution, not legislating to enforce them.

The preamble to our Constitution states that all authority of the State comes from a specific god called the Most Holy Trinity. It also humbly acknowledges all of the obligations of the people of the State to a specific god called Our Lord Jesus Christ.

Up to a quarter of a million Irish atheists cannot become President or a judge unless they take a religious oath. These religious declarations are contrary to Ireland's obligations under the UN International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.

The Constitution [Article 44] also states that the homage of public worship is due to Almighty God. This is much more than an assertion of the right of citizens to worship this god. It is an assertion of the right of this god to be publicly worshipped by citizens. ...

The Constitution also contains many other references to this god and to religion generally. Our national parliament reflects this by starting each day's business with a prayer explicitly asking the Christian God to direct all of their actions. Under this guidance, they have legislated for many public policies that are heavily influenced by religion.
Others have suggested that concerns regarding violence or public disorder - where the offended take matters into their own hands and smite unbelievers or where blasphemers incite violence through offensive statements - would more effectively be addressed through anti-vilification law. That is consistent with the March 2009 comment by the Irish Minister for Foreign Affairs that -
We believe that the concept of defamation of religion is not consistent with the promotion and protection of human rights. It can be used to justify arbitrary limitations on, or the denial of, freedom of expression. Indeed, Ireland considers that freedom of expression is a key and inherent element in the manifestation of freedom of thought and conscience and as such is complementary to freedom of religion or belief.
Meanwhile there are reports that "a Somali man" (apparently, in fact, a Danish resident) has been shot by Danish police after breaking into the home of cartoonist Kurt Westergaard while wielding an axe, presumably to wreak righteous vengeance on Westergaard for his 2005 Jyllands-Posten caricature of the Prophet Muhammad.

Dog Skin

Colin Dayan in 31(23) LRB (2009) comments that -
Dog involvement in the lives of humans is documented, questioned and defined by law. Legalised violence against dogs and their owners has a brutal history. English common law, reinvigorated in the United States in the 19th century, turned to old legal conceits about dogs in modern judgments on dog stealing. A statute of George III explained that a dog could not be stolen, for a dog was not considered property. A late 19th-century case in South Carolina summarised the statute: 'It was larceny to steal a tame hawk, but not larceny to steal a tame dog, although it was larceny to steal the hide of a dead dog'. It is disturbing to think that the skin of a dead dog is worth more than a dog alive, but perhaps this is not surprising. Dogs were legally considered no different in terms of property from human corpses. Stealing a corpse, as Blackstone wrote, was not a felony, unless 'some of the graveclothes be stolen with it'. There is property in the skin of a dog as there is in a winding sheet. But a living dog, like a cadaver, was res nullius. It belonged to no one; no one had any right in it.
Dayan goes on to conclude that -
The modern conception of dogs as personal property has done very little to advance their position. They remain subject to the same repressive treatment as others targeted for coercion and control. They have taken their place alongside vagrants and criminals. Out of the maimed right of property in dogs has come a familiar deprivation of persons considered either too servile or too poor to count.
Blackstone's Commentaries - I rely on Vol IV ('Of Public Wrongs') in the 1979 University of Chicago Press facsimile of the 1765-69 edition - is less restrictive than might be inferred from Dayan's reading. Blackstone at 236 commented that larceny is applicable in relation to
all valuable domestic animals, [such] as horses, and of all animals domitae naturae, which serve for food, [such] as swine, sheep, poultry and the like ... and also the flesh of such as are ferae naturae, when killed.
Blackstone noted that -
As to those animals, which do not serve for food, and which therefore the law holds to have no intrinsic value, as dogs of all sorts, and other creatures kept for whim and pleasure, though a man may have a base property therein, and maintain a civil action for the loss of them, yet they are not of such estimation as that the crime of stealing them amounts to larceny.

01 January 2010

God's Executioner

The Berlin Review of Books features an extract from Joel Harrington's 'God's Executioner: Meister Frantz Schmidt of Nuremberg'.

Schmidt, as the public executioner of Nuremberg, kept personal journal between 1573 and 1617, "recording and describing each and every execution and corporal punishment he administered" -
torture by various methods, flogging, cutting off of fingers or ears, as well as judicial execution by hanging, beheading, burning, drowning, live burial, or breaking on the wheel.
Accounts include -
1573 - Kloss Renckhart of Feylsdorf, a murderer. Committed three murders with his companion. First, he shot dead another companion. Secondly, a miller's man who helped him to attack and plunder a mill by night. The third instance was again at a mill, called the Fox Mill, on the mountains, which he attacked at night with a companion, shot the miller dead, raped the miller's wife and maid, forced them to fry some eggs in fat and laid these on the dead miller's body, then forced the miller's wife to join in eating them, then kicked the miller's body and said, "Miller, how do you like this morsel?". Also robbed the mill. On this account executed on the wheel at Graytz, in the archbishopric of Bamberg.

February 1584 - Hennsa of Geyselwind, otherwise known as Fatty; Hennsa Palllauf of Hernda; Killian Wurmb of Wirnsbach, otherwise known as Rear End; Hans Schober of Weher, otherwise known as Dusty; and Hennssla Klopffer of Reigelsdorff. Five thieves who ... had to be clothed, for they were naked and bare; some of them knew no prayers and had never been in a church. The eldest were 22, 17, 16, and 15 years old; the youngest 13 years. All five from here. Executed with the rope at Nuremberg.
One cannot hang people without clothes.

Other incidents include -
August 1594 - Christoff Mayer, a weaver of fustian, and Hans Weber, a fruiterer; both citizens of Nuremberg who for three years had practiced sodomy together and were informed against by a hook-maker's apprentice, who caught them both in the act behind a hedge. The fruiterer had practiced this for twenty years, namely with the cook Endress, with Alexander, also with Georg in the army, and with the baker Toothy Chris at Lauf, and otherwise with many other baker servants that he couldn’t name. The weaver was first executed with the sword and then his body was burnt with the fruiterer, who was burnt alive.

November 1617 - Burnt alive here a miller of Manberna, who however was lately engaged as a carrier of wine. Because he and his brother, with the help of others, practiced coining and counterfeiting money and clipping coins fraudulently. He also had a working knowledge of magic ... This miller, who worked in the town mills here three years ago, fell into the town moat on Whitsunday. It would have been better for him if he had been drowned, but it turned out according to the proverb that "What belongs to the gallows cannot drown in water".
Harrington notes Schmidt's -
self-identity as a restorer of social order, a kind of moral accountant, who, in his own words, "did his duty and made things right again". As if making entries in a ledger, Meister Frantz carefully lists all known offenses committed by each individual, including full itemization of all stolen property, and numbers all of his punishments, capital and corporal, providing annual totals of each.

While Schmidt's tone is almost always dispassionate, the relative length of the entries and other clues reveal his implicit hierarchy of social values. Violent crimes, particularly the outrages committed by vicious robber gangs, were clearly the worst and required the most severe punishments to restore justice. Abuses of trust, however, were nearly as grievous in Schmidt's eyes, including treason, the murder of a relative (especially a child), the rape of a young girl, or audacious financial fraud, such as the one-legged "treasure finder" Elizabeth Aurholtin (aka "Scabby"), whose schemes amassed a considerable personal future, or the master forger and con-man Gabriel Wolf, who defrauded nobles across Europe of huge amounts. Crimes against property in general required strict rectification, often including hanging for theft. But most such offenses – except when they directly abused people’s good will or hospitality – did not arouse Schmidt's ire. His complacency was even more evident in a variety of "victimless" sexual offenses (not rape), typified more by exasperation at the defiance of recidivist prostitutes and their pimps than by any evangelical fervour.
He also notes Scmidt's other self-image as -
a healer-priest, likewise evident in his pervasive concern with full accounting of each individual's crimes and sins, no matter how small, and Schmidt's own active role in reconciling the sinner with God. Strikingly, his approach is much less overtly doctrinaire than that of his colleague, prison chaplain Johannes Hagendorn, who also kept a personal journal of criminal cases. Rather, Schmidt seeks to create in the elaborate spectacle of public death a sort of preliminary last judgment that provides the condemned the opportunity to achieve "a good end" or "fine death", and in his journal he comments extensively on his own success or failure in ensuring that they did not part the world "godless"” or "with no hope of salvation". Above all, the journal entries and supplemental legal sources portray a man steeled to the use of torture and other violence on the offenders before him but also consistently attentive to avoid unnecessary cruelty. Schmidt, for example, successfully leads a pioneering campaign to abolish the drowning of female felons and execute them by what he considered the more humane method of decapitation. He also regularly persuades his magisterial colleagues to behead those condemned to die by fire or being drawn and quartered.

31 December 2009

Legal pluralism and cadavers

The ABC, in reporting "Clash of laws over Indigenous autopsy", highlights questions about legal pluralism and cultural diversity in Australia.

Prominent Indigenous artist Banduk Marika has unsuccessfully sought an injunction against the Northern Territory coroner's authorisation of an autopsy on her son, who was run over on 20 December. Marika reportedly argues that an autopsy is inconsistent with traditional law. She had told police after her son's death that she did not want an autopsy. She was told by the coroner during the next day that an autopsy would be carried out in 48 hours.

Marika was one of the participants in the landmark 'Carpets Case' (aka Indofurn Case) - George Milpurrurru, Banduk Marika , Tim Payunka and the Public Trustee of the Northern Territory v Indofurn Pty Ltd, Brian Alexander Bethune, George Raymond King and Robert James Rylands [1994] FCA 1544 - regarding intellectual property.

During the injunction hearing Marika reportedly told the court that her family felt "disfigurement" of her son's body was unnecessary, that the family had not seen any evidence from police to justify it and that when a body is interfered with by a foreign hand the dead person's spirit is prevented from moving forward into the next world.

Disquiet about autopsies (or more broadly about delays in burial/cremation of a body) is not restricted to Indigenous people. Most Australian jurisdictions make some allowance for cultural sensitivities, for example under ss 20 and 28 of the Coroners Act 1997 (ACT) and ss 25, 88 and 96 of the Coroners Act 2009 (NSW). (Note associated sanctions such as those under s 83 of the ACT Act.)

Coronial powers to order autopsies reflect the authority of the state (and rationales such as serving justice through fact-based criminal investigation and protecting public health through research in disease or injury). They also reflect the notion - articulated for example in Doodeward v Spence [1908] HCA 45; (1908) 6 CLR 406 and Leeburn v Derndorfer [2004] VSC 172 - that there are typically no property rights in a cadaver or - as noted in R v Sharpe (1856-57) Dears & Bell 160; 169 ER 959 - comprehensive rights of possession.

Your survivors thus do not own your bones and other "stuff". Once you are dead you are no longer in a position to claim torts of assault, false imprisonment, defamation and so forth. (In circumstances where a coroner is not involved you might, however, have made an 'advance direction' under for example s 25 of the Human Tissue & Transplant Act 1982 (WA) that your body may be 'anatomised' after death and provision is made in Australian jurisdictions, through for example s 22(5) of the Transplantation & Anatomy Act 1978 (Qld), for authorisation of post-mortem organ harvesting.)

The record of Australian courts in approving or rejecting applications to prevent autopsies or simply order that a deceased person be buried, burned or exposed for transmutation by vultures is mixed.

Riley J in Wuridjal v Hand [2001] NTSC 99 thus rejected an application by members of the Yolngu community. Coroners' decisions have been overturned in for example Green v Johnstone [1995] 2VR 176, Re Death of Simon Unchango (Jnr); ex parte Simon Unchango (Snr) (1997) 95 A Crim R 65 and Abernethy v Deitz (1996) 39 NSWLR 701.