14 January 2011

Global Village Idiot

From Nicholas Carr's TNR review of Marshall McLuhan: You Know Nothing of My Work! (Atlas, 2010) by Douglas Coupland -
a Canadian television show in 1968 featur[ed] a debate between Norman Mailer and Marshall McLuhan. The two men, both heroes of the '60s, could hardly be more different. Leaning forward in his chair, Mailer is pugnacious, animated, engaged. McLuhan, abstracted and smiling wanly, seems to be on autopilot. He speaks in canned riddles. "The planet is no longer nature", he declares, to Mailer's uncomprehending stare; "it's now the content of an art work".

Watching McLuhan, you can't quite decide whether he was a genius or just had a screw loose. Both impressions, it turns out, are valid. As Douglas Coupland argues in his pithy new biography, McLuhan's mind was probably situated at the mild end of the autism spectrum. He also suffered from a couple of major cerebral traumas. In 1960, he had a stroke so severe that he was given his last rites. In 1967, just a few months before the Mailer debate, surgeons removed a tumor the size of an apple from the base of his brain. ...

McLuhan was a scholar of literature, with a doctorate from Cambridge, and his interpretation of the intellectual and social effects of media was richly allusive and erudite. But what particularly galvanized the public was the weirdness of his prose. Perhaps because of his unusual mind, he had a knack for writing sentences that sounded at once clinical and mystical. His books read like accounts of acid trips written by a bureaucrat. That kaleidoscopic, almost psychedelic style made him a darling of the counterculture — the bearded and the Birkenstocked embraced him as a guru — but it alienated him from his colleagues in academia. To them, McLuhan was a celebrity-seeking charlatan.
Perhaps he was, instead, the global idiot savant.

I'm reminded of William Melody's acerbic review in Information, Communication & Society of Marshall McLuhan: The Medium and the Messenger (MIT Press, 1998) by Philip Marchand -
Now that McLuhan has been dead for nearly twenty years and cannot divert us with his dazzling elliptical metaphors and bad puns, his work can be examined without raising the passions the deliberately provocative oral communicator managed to inflame in his prime. Adopting a stance of arrogant superiority, he considered clarifying his ideas an unworthy menial task for intellectual plodders, and dismissed challenging questions with comments like, 'You don't like those ideas. I got other ones', and the infamous, 'You think my fallacy is all wrong?' He paid scant attention to facts and never conceded a point. His ultimate put down was a benign explanation that the question revealed the person was locked into the uni-dimensional visual bias of the age of print and could not really be expected to understand.

Content regulation

National Attorney-General Robert McClelland and Minister for Home Affairs Brendan O'Connor have tasked the Australian Law Reform Commission with a review (to be completed by 9 December) of content classification "in light of changes in technology, media convergence and the global availability of media content".

The review will update the ALRC inquiry of 1991. In that report the ALRC recommended -
• There should be a national legislative scheme to deal with censorship issues. A federal Act should establish the administrative bodies and set out the procedures for classifying films and publications.
• A non-legislative code should contain the criteria for classification.
• The States and Territories should adopt classifications determined under the code and provide enforcement proceedings.
Implementation of the recommendations saw -
enactment of the Classification (Publications, Films and Computer Games) Act 1995 (Cth), providing for the classification of publications, films and computer games for the Australian Capital Territory and, through complementary State and Territory legislation, the basis of a national classification scheme.

The Broadcasting Services Act 1992 (Cth) was amended by the Broadcasting Services (Online Services) Amendment Act 1999 (Cth) to provide for censorship and classification of internet material and online services. Under that statute complaints regarding content can be made to the Australian Communications & Media Authority (ACMA), which can ask the Classification Board to classify the content consistent with the Classification (Publications, Films and Computer Games) Act 1995 (Cth) and the National Classification Code (2005). ACMA can require a host or service provider to stop or restrict access to certain content, depending on the classification it attracts.
In announcing the current review the Minister for Home Affairs commented that -
When the National Classification Scheme began, classifiable content and the way it was delivered to consumers was relatively static.

Today, films can be watched in a cinema, on DVD, on TV or downloaded. Many video games include significant film segments to tell stories, and some films have interactive content. The National Broadband Network will increase this ready access to classifiable content.

People, particularly parents, need a system of classification in Australia that allows them to make informed choices about what they wish to read, see and hear.

This important review will look not only at classification categories, but also at the whole classification system to ensure it continues to be effective in the 21st century.
The Attorney-General’s Department is seeking comments on the proposed terms of reference [PDF] for the review, with comments to be provided by the 28th of this month.

As might be expected, the preamble to the 'Review of Censorship and Classification' offers something for everyone, with the Ministers "having regard to" -
• the rapid pace of technological change in media available to, and consumed by, the Australian community
• the needs of the community in this evolving technological environment
• the need to improve classification information available to the community and enhance public understanding of the content that is regulated
• the desirability of a strong content and distribution industry in Australia, and minimising the regulatory burden
• the impact of media on children and the increased exposure of children to a wider variety of media including television, music and advertising as well as films and computer games
• the size of the industries that generate potentially classifiable content and potential for growth
• a communications convergence review, and
• a statutory review of Schedule 7 of the Broadcasting Services Act 1992 and other sections relevant to the classification of content
Moving on from genuflections to the divergent interest groups, the ALRC is to consider -
1. relevant existing Commonwealth, State and Territory laws and practices
2. classification schemes in other jurisdictions
3. the classification categories contained in the Classification Act, National Classification Code and Classification Guidelines
4. any relevant constitutional issues, and
5. any other related matter.

Law students

A colleague has pointed me to results from the US Law School Survey of Student Engagement [PDF].

Highlights include -
What is going well
• Three quarters of 3Ls (73%) reported that they were involved with pro bono or volunteer work during law school.
• Only 7% of 1Ls frequently came to class unprepared. Forty-two percent of first-year students never came to class without completing the readings or assignments.
• The average student spent 27 hours per week reading assigned material and studying.
• More than half of students (57%) frequently worked harder than they thought they could to meet faculty members’standards or expectations.

What needs attention
• The average student found faculty members to be only moderately available, helpful, and sympathetic.
• Half of students never worked with faculty on activities other than coursework, such as committees or student life activities.
• More than a quarter of students (27%) never discussed ideas from readings or classes with faculty members outside of class.
• Female students were less likely than male students to ask questions in class frequently.
• One in four students (24%) said that their coursework placed a strong emphasis on memorizing facts, ideas, or methods from courses and readings so that the student could repeat them in pretty much the same form.

What warrants further investigation
• While half of students felt that their legal education contributed substantially to the development of a personal code of values and ethics, half felt that the law school contributed only some or very little in this regard.
• Forty percent of 3Ls reported spending some time each week working for pay in a legal setting.
• A majority of students (59%) who used career-counseling services at the law school were satisfied with their experience, but more than half of 3Ls (57%) were unsatisfied with job search help
The report goes on to comment that -
The Carnegie Report concluded that law schools do an excellent job of preparing students academically. In its assessment of the status of modern legal education, the authors noted that a primary strength of law school is the focus on the intellectual transformation of students—teaching students to think like lawyers. Data from LSSSE also confirm that students devote significant time and energy to class preparation. Results indicate that law school provides a rigorous academic experience for students.

At the same time, however, Carnegie suggests that law schools are not as effective in facilitating the transformation of law students to lawyers. In this regard, elements of professionalism and ethics are relevant. In part, the failure of law schools to achieve this broader transformation in their students may be due to ambivalence of faculty in teaching and discussing ethical and moral issues, suggesting that this is perhaps due to an assumption that such efforts are futile as students enter law school with well-developed moral sensibilities. Data from the 2010 LSSSE survey corroborate Carnegie’s assertion that professional development of students during law school is largely underemphasized. [The report is based on] responses from 6,839 students attending 22 law schools to a set of experimental items that explore students’ perceptions of how well their law school prepared them to step into the role of professionals.

According to students, law schools provide only moderate preparation for various ethical and professional aspects of their future legal careers. For example, only half of students reported that law school prepared them well (combining response options “very much” and “quite a bit”) to deal with ethical dilemmas that may arise as part of law practice, while only slightly more reported that law school prepared them to serve the public good through their profession. By contrast, more than two-thirds of students reported that law school has prepared them to manage their time effectively. While time management is important for success in school as well as in practice, the data suggest that law schools could do more to nurture the ethical development of their students.

Students with experience in clinics or pro bono work were more likely than other students to report that their law schools provided adequate professional preparation. Specifically, clinical participation and pro bono work correlated with a higher degree of preparation in the following areas:
• Understanding the needs of future clients
• Working cooperatively with colleagues as part of a legal team
• Serving the public good through their profession
• Understanding professional values that will serve them in their legal careers

13 January 2011

Must try harder

Human Rights Watch has released a 67-page report [PDF] titled Promises Unfulfilled: An Assessment of China's National Human Rights Action Plan, arguing that the plan has remained a public relations exercise because China's government has failed to deliver on commitments in its first-ever National Human Rights Action Plan (2009-2010) (NHRAP).

That Plan has been promoted as protecting key civil and political rights. Its goals have been undermined through the tightening of restrictions on rights of expression, association and assembly, thereby exacerbating rather than significantly reducing the human rights abuses specifically identified by the NHRAP.

The NHRAP articulates policy objectives in categories such as social, economic, civil, cultural and political rights. It includes sections on international human rights obligations and China's human rights education initiatives.

HRW notes that in 2009-2010 Beijing -
* continued its practice of sentencing high-profile dissidents such as imprisoned Nobel laureate Liu Xiaobo to lengthy prison terms on spurious state secrets or "subversion" charges;

* expanded restrictions on the media and internet;

* tightened controls on lawyers, human rights defenders and nongovernment organizations;

* broadened controls on Tibetans and Uighurs; and

* engaged in increasing numbers of enforced disappearances and arbitrary detentions, including use of secret, unlawful detention facilities known as "black jails.
Despite an NHRAP pledge that "it is strictly forbidden to extort confessions by torture and to collect evidence by threat, enticement, deceit or other unlawful means," torture of suspects remains routine. Contrary to protestations prohibiting illegal detention by law enforcement personnel and promises that "Those who are responsible for illegal, wrongful or prolonged detention shall be subjected to inquiry and punished if found culpable" illegal detention also remains widespread, with thousands of people held in 'black jails', ie secret illegal detention centers.

China's police use legal powers to routinely impose administrative detention via 're-education through labor' (laojiao) and house arrest (ruanjin). Laojiao allows the police to unilaterally impose custodial sentences of up to three years while depriving detainees of any due process of law and judicial oversight. Ruanjin (which Chinese police can impose arbitrarily and outside of any legal procedure) results in detention with restricted and monitored internet and phone communications, and 24-hour surveillance by unidentified and often aggressive security forces.

Perceptions of prudence differ. The Plan indicates that the death penalty "shall be strictly controlled and prudently applied"; lots of families are paying for the bullets used for prudently executing criminals.

HRW notes that -
The NHRAP committed the government to "fulfill its obligations to the international human rights conventions to which it has acceded, and initiate and actively participate in exchanges and cooperation in the field of international human rights." Yet the Chinese government continued to have a poor record of cooperation with international bodies on issues of human rights. The government has repeatedly rejected requests for an independent international investigation into the March 2008 protests across the Tibetan plateau, refused to approve requests to visit Tibet by the United Nations high commissioner for human rights and six United Nations special rapporteurs, and made false statements during China's first Universal Periodic Review at the UN Human Rights Council in February 2009, including "There is no censorship in the country," and "No individual or press has been penalized for voicing their opinions or views."
The report goes on to note that -
the NHRAP does not address several major human rights issues prioritized by both Chinese and foreign human rights activists: China's hukou, or household registration system; rights abuses related to rising numbers of property disputes; and human rights concerns related to China's increasingly active diplomatic, development, and investment activities in the developing world.

Westboro Hatespeech

The Arizona legislature is reported to have passed legislation to prevent members of the Westboro Baptist church (noted for hatespeech regarding LGBTQI people, Jews, Roman Catholics and sundry others) from disrupting the funeral of the nine-year-old victim of shooting by Jared Loughner.

Given the church's delight in excess - and the readiness with which the statements and activities of its members are relayed by the mass media - it is unsurprising that church founder Fred Phelps has praised Loughner for killing six people and announced that the righteous will picket their funerals. Westboro has attracted attention for disrupting the funerals of soldiers and people who have died of AIDS.

The new law does not stop the picketing. It does however keep the picketers at least 100 metres from the funeral.

Distaste for Westboro's activity is reflected in news that 40 people wearing 3m high angel wings will stand between the funeral and church members. A group of bikers reportedly will also interpose themselves between the fans of Mr Loughner.

The Supreme Court has yet to decided on the constitutionality of restrictions on protests at funerals in a case brought by the father of a soldier killed in Iraq. restrictions have attracted substantial academic literature, including 'A Time to Mourn: Balancing the Right of Free Speech Against the Right of Privacy in Funeral Picketing' by N Rutledge in (2008) 67(2) Maryland Law Review 295-357, 'Balancing Freedom of Speech with the Right to Privacy: How to Legally Cope With the Funeral Protest Problem' by A Messar in (2007) 28(1) Pace Law Review 101-128, 'Freedom of Speech and the Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress Tort' by E Volokh in (2010) Cardozo Law Review, 'Regulating Offensiveness: Snyder v. Phelps, Emotion, and the First Amendment' by C Wells in 1 California Law Review Circuit (2010) 71-86, 'The Incompatibility of Free Speech and Funerals: A Grayned-Based Approach for Funeral Protest Statutes' by R McCarthy in (2007) 68(5) Ohio State Law Journal 1469-1508, 'The Constitutionality of "Let Them Rest in Peace" Bills: Can Governments Say "Not Today, Fred" to Demonstrations at Funeral Ceremonies?' by K Ritts in (2007) 58(1) Syracuse Law Review 137-170 and 'Making Sense of "God Hates Fags" and "Thank God for 9/11": A Thematic Analysis of Milbloggers' Responses to Reverend Fred Phelps and the Westboro Baptist Church' by D Brouwer & A Hess in (2007) 71(1) Western Journal of Communication 69-90.

The latter comments that -
Through codes of religious authority, including scriptural references and common symbols of Christianity, Phelps claims the weight of God. On their protest signs and in their protest slogans, his church and his movement frequently employ the "Thank God for ..." motto, usually inserting the latest national tragedy, whether it be the death of Supreme Court Justice Rehnquist, Hurricane Katrina, or the improvised explosive devices (IEDs) that kill soldiers overseas. Phelps simultaneously defends and attacks through the use of Christianity. As a shield, religion and its constitutionally protected expression defend Phelps and his right of protest. Frequently, he has reverted to his religious rights and freedom of speech as a defense in court. As a weapon, Christianity warrants Phelps’ vexing presence at a sacred location that is particularly meaningful to military-aligned audiences. Phelps' articulations of religion inspire a riotous variety of responses about the values and meanings of Christianity, complicating any sort of ideological closure advocated in the name of Christianity.
The major funeral protest in Australia of which I am aware was at the Sydney Opera House memorial service for the unlovely Kerry Packer, with the arrest of eight protestors. In 2009 Westboro foreshadowed protests at the memorial service for Australian bushfire victims, stating that -
The guilty Australians will not repent of their national sins of the flesh - (ie sodomy, divorce, fornication, adultery, etc) - even after God killed hundreds in the fires and cast them into hotter fire and brimstone in Hell. Therefore we will picket them in their hypocritical grief.
Phelps and associates have been denied entry to Australia, the UK and Canada.

12 January 2011

Smart Meters, Dumb Headlines

Elsewhere - more in sorrow than in anger (of course) - I've critiqued claims about the inevitable and imminent supremacy of broadband over powerline (BPL), aka powerline communication (PLC), as a mechanism for providing broadband to rural/urban consumers using plain old powerlines ... in other words the 'grid' that connects businesses, households and other entities to the power stations.

Those claims have on occasion been driven by commercial opportunism (nothing like good news to pump up a flaccid share price or buff a stodgy corporate profile), incomprehension or indifference on the part of the mass media and the tendency of 'citizen journalists' to drink the digital koolade. The reality is - and will remain - that although broadband (however defined) can be delivered via the conventional electricity grid, such delivery is fraught with difficulty and is not commercially competitive once steps are taken to deal with radio interference and other problems. (I've noted that is also possible to deliver the net via carrier pigeon or bongo drum ... both mechanisms are technically feasible but, how very strange, have not supplanted wireless, fibre or conventional copper.)

I can thus empathise with the following response to reports that a 'smart meter' trial in Liverpool (UK) will lead to householders enjoying broadband over the grid -
Will this minion of the undead ever get a stake in its heart. Please ... silver bullets, garlic, wooden stakes, holy water something! anything!!!
Small scale Australian trials, under the auspices of ACMA, of BPL have gone nowhere - typically distinguished by deliriously upbeat media releases (and equally uncritical reporting) followed by an embarrassing silence as implementation does not eventuate. Across the world BPL solution vendors have packed their kit and slunk away; urban and rural showpiece projects have fizzled (eg here).

BPL continues to be "the technology of the future ... and always will be" - bright forecasts, dim reality.

Trust

Recent posts (here and here) have pointed to claims - unsubstantiated, exaggerated or otherwise - of unauthorised access to Vodafone customer data.

As some readers of those posts have inferred, alongside perceived security inadequacies at Vodafone - and arguably at some of its competitors, given that most telcos rely on similar dealer networks that are often staffed by apparently bored, inexperienced 18-somethings - there are grounds for criticism of the way that the organisation has responded to consumer (and broader public) concern.

Ongoing unhappiness with Vodafone coincides with release by the Brookings Institute of a 17 page paper by Allan Friedman, Patrick Crowley & Darrell West on Online Identity and Consumer Trust: Assessing Online Risk [PDF]. That document is not radical or scintillating and is arguably less incisive than the discussion in recent IPTF and FTC documents noted here.

However, it is a useful reminder - although one I suspect will escape the notice of both Vodafone and the Australian Privacy Commissioner - of the importance of trust in online environments.

Data loss may well be an unpleasant, inevitable fact of life for both consumers and data custodians (we should conceptualise public/private sector organisations as data custodians rather than data owners). However, the relationship between consumers, organisations and third parties needs to be founded on trust. For maintenance of that trust is is imperative that organisations demonstrate that they are aware of sensitivities, are committed to a meaningful response and are committed to proactive effective action that will substantially inhibit future losses.