18 January 2011

God owns the rain

One of the more mordant mediaeval prelates, in commenting on personal ambition and grand plans, noted that "man proposes, God disposes". I was reminded on that quip on reading reports that -
Authorities from Western Mount Lofty Ranges Natural Resource Management Board have told the farmers that the Crown "owns" the rain that falls from the sky and the State Government has the right to manage, organise and sell the resource how it wishes.
God - or nature - provides the rain, the Board gets to commodify it and the voters dispose of the government?

The context is that the trouble-prone South Australian Government (readers of this blog may recall comments on the former Attorney General's stance on bikies and criticism and on the current Attorney General's characterisation of the rights of criminals) apparently aims to meter farm dams - private infrastructure - and thence charge landowners for use of water from those dams.

The the extent to which the Government aims to charge for rain (as distinct from shaping land use and harvesting some dollars through licence fees and charges for consumption of 'surface water') is unclear. The state government, which is not fettered by the tight restrictions on the national government imposed by the fin de siecle straitjacket known as the national Constitution, presumably has the power to devise and impose law covering consumption of water from private dams (and indeed from the domestic rainwater tanks that it has encouraged householders to acquire, with for example "up to $1000 per household in rebates for purchasing a rainwater tank and having it installed"). The usefulness of charging for rainwater, except as a rather messy and deeply unpopular revenue generation measure, is more uncertain.

The same report indicates that -
Acting Water Minister Gail Gago yesterday acknowledged that while "no one owned" the rain, "the Crown reserves the right to manage this important resource".

Mrs Gago also only moved to rule out more wide-spread metering of rainwater tanks supplying water for domestic and stock purposes until March, when the current rules expire.

"Surface water (from roofs) may be taken for any stock and domestic purpose without the requirement for a water licence and there is therefore no requirement to meter household usage of this water," a spokeswoman for Mrs Gago said.

"There is no intention to meter household and commercial operations that collect roof runoff in rainwater tanks and comply with this statewide authorisation," the spokeswoman said.

But all exemptions to the statewide authorisation governing the use of rooftop captured rainfall expire in March. Mrs Gago's office did not offer a response when questioned about any proposed changes.
Times change. In 2007 the Board's Fact Sheet [PDF] indicated that -
Proposed licensing of rainwater storages – The facts.

The Western Mt Lofty Ranges (WMLR) is currently moving through the process of prescription, that is, the development of a management plan to ensure the sustainability of water resources. Following the distribution of information to water users in the WMLR, the Adelaide and Mount Lofty Ranges Natural Resources Management Board seeks to clarify some inaccurate perceptions of the issue:
• There will be no tax or levy on rainwater tanks where the water will be used for stock watering or domestic purposes. This also applies for dams and bores that are used for stock and domestic purposes. Stock and domestic use is specifically excluded from the raising of levies under the Natural Resources Management (NRM) Act 2004.
• This is not a new initiative. Licensed water allocations are already used in a number of prescribed areas including the Barossa Valley and the River Murray.
• Licensing of roof run-off affects only a very small number of very large commercial users. These users (500,000 litres or above) have the potential to negatively impact the environment and other users in the same way as farm dams.
• Feedback is sought from the community to determine what the most appropriate roof run-off threshold is. Once determined, roof run-off that exceeds the agreed threshold and is captured and stored for commercial use will require a license. A threshold license is needed for the Adelaide Hills because capturing large amounts of roof run-off will affect surface water flows to the catchment below, potentially affecting water flows for downstream neighbors and watercourses that rely on these flows for a healthy environment.
• A sustainable water management plan will enable fair and equitable access to water.
Businesses that rely on water will be able to do so with a sense of security well into the future, eliminating any doubt that the resource may not exist the following year.
• This is not about ownership of water, it is about managing the use of water resources so that the needs of all users, including the environment, are met.
The Adelaide and Mount Lofty Ranges NRM Board is committed to effectively managing the region's water resources in a sustainable way. To achieve this, a management system must be implemented, ensuring this precious resource is distributed fairly amongst all users which includes the environment, now and into the future.
The 205 page draft Plan for 2010 [PDF], glossed in a 76 page Guide [PDF] would appear to involve licensing and metering of all substantial private dams in rural areas that are fed by creeks or other watercourses on a sporadic or ongoing basis. It is likely that there are few dams that are fed solely by rain falling into that 'pondage', ie do not rely on rain that falls in the vicinity and is channelled via creeks.

17 January 2011

Get outta dodge

Oh dear, apparently I don't need to wait until 2012 (when quantum mystic and World Futures Ervin Laszlo says the world will end). No, bad luck, need to get out of Dodge now!

A friend has pointed me to the WeCanKnow site, which announces Christ's Return on Judgment Day (21 May 2011) -
This web site serves as an introduction and portal to four faithful ministries which are teaching that WE CAN KNOW from the Bible alone that the date of the rapture of believers will take place on May 21, 2011 and that God will destroy this world on October 21, 2011. Please take your time and browse through the teachings of Harold Camping, President of Family Radio. Visit EBible Fellowship, Bible Ministries International, and The-Latter-Rain to read and listen to many faithful teachers give scriptural insight on the doctrines that God is teaching His people. Learn about the Biblical Timeline of History, the correct method of Bible interpretation, the End of the Church Age and God's command to believers that they must depart out of the churches. Study the proofs that God has so graciously given in His Word showing us that these dates are 100% accurate and beyond dispute. Above all, please READ THE BIBLE and prayerfully ask God to open your spiritual eyes to these truths. May it please Him to have mercy on each of our souls.
Yes folks, "100% accurate and beyond dispute" ... and all coming to an end on 21 October 2011. Alas, no indication of whether it's before lunch or after lunch on the 21st.

The site's decorated with the usual mystification - seven seals, seven plagues, sundry bad people, tribulation - and ignorance of textual analysis ... just praise the lawd and pass the contributions in emulation of a succession of Darbyites, Millerites and other disappointed exponents of the End Times and imminent Rapture. They've put a spin on Archbishop Ussher's date of creation -
We will first establish some rules for interpreting these geneologies [sic] accurately. Then we will use those rules to determine the date of Creation, as well as construct a timeline of events. In the Christian community the earth is commonly thought to be about 6,000 years old, but this is based on inaccurately assuming that the word "begat" always implies an immediate father-son relationship. If we construct a timeline based on this assumption we will run into contradictions in the Bible and some of the pieces just won't fit quite right. We will examine this in detail at the end of this study. We will begin our study with this word "begat".

Through this study we will discover that the earth is a little over 13,000 years old. We will also discover that we can know very accurately when certain events took place. For example, we know the Flood took place in 4990 BC and the Exodus took place in 1447 BC.
Quite so. Unfortunately, parsing the Bible (particularly if you are relying on a translation) can provide wildly different dates for the end of history. Ussher's contemporary John Lightfoot revealed that
heaven and earth, centre and circumference, were created all together, in the same instant, and clouds full of water ... this work took place and man was created by the Trinity on October 23, 4004 B.C., at nine o'clock in the morning.

Vaccination

A friend has pointed me to media coverage of a Family Court order requiring a mother to have her five-year-old daughter immunised for whooping cough. In following up the recent post on the Wakefield article the coverage is interest for how the mass media report science and the law rather than merely for the judicial precedent and notions of possessive individualism.

The child's parents reportedly separated before her birth, with the father (who wishes access to his daughter) going on to remarry and have other children with his new partner. He sought an order regarding vaccination of the daughter against preventable diseases, both for her own wellbeing and for the health of his other children. That rationale is consistent with a recognition that diseases such as whooping cough and measles can kill or maim and that it is not feasible to protect everyone through innoculation (ie give a shot to all babies on delivery, with the consequence that some young children might be placed at serious risk through exposure to an unvaccinated person who is encountered at home, school, in a shopping mall, on a bus or other location).

The father produced medical evidence that immunisation provided no unacceptable risks for his daughter. He reportedly noted that if she remained un-vaccinated she would be forced to withdraw from school during outbreaks of some diseases and that she would also be unable to spend time with any babies in his second family, given that she was not immunised against whooping cough.

The girl's mother reportedly said that her daughter was healthy, that the risk of vaccine-preventable diseases was very small and that vaccination was dangerous. She was criticised in the magistrate's judgment (not yet available on the Family Court site or on AustLII) for submitting evidence from an "immunisation sceptic" who made what were described as "outlandish statements unsupported by any empirical evidence".

As the media circus got underway Professor Robert Booy of the National Centre for Immunisation Research & Surveillance argued that immunisation prevents serious diseases, commenting that -
The only way we can protect the vulnerable - and that may be a newborn, or someone with an immune deficiency - is to ensure other people are vaccinated.
Chiropractor Warren Sipser reportedly denounced the judgment as "dangerous", with reportage indicating that he was "shocked" (being shocked and/or saddened or outraged are presumably inevitable), commenting -
It's a sad situation ....

I think it's dangerous to impose [immunisations] on anyone when there are two opposing viewpoints and when there is credible evidence they may do more harm than good
Much law involves two or more "opposing viewpoints", with courts being asked to decide on what those tribunals hold to be credible evidence. In this instance the court - along with most of the scientific community - held that evidence about the dangers of vaccination is unpersuasive and that non-vaccination wasn't the default.

Other foes of vaccination were less restrained than Sipser. Meryl Dorsey of the Australian Vaccination Network (AVN), vehement opponents of vaccination, commented on that group's Facebook page -
Court orders rape of a child.

Think this is an exaggeration? Think again. This is assault without consent and with full penetration too. If we as a society allow this crime to take place, we are every bit as guilty as the judge who made the order and the doctor who carries it out.
Using that analysis all surgery on children would be illegal.

The NSW Health Care Complaints Commission (an independent body established under the Health Care Complaints Act 1993 (NSW) to protect public health and safety by dealing with complaints about health service providers in NSW) last year issued a public warning about the AVN, noting that the Commission's investigation established that the AVN website -
• provides information that is solely anti-vaccination

• contains information that is incorrect and misleading

• quotes selectively from research to suggest that vaccination may be dangerous
It went on to comment that
The Commission recognises that it is important for there to be debate on the issue of vaccination. However, the AVN provides information that is inaccurate and misleading.

The AVN’s failure to include a notice on its website of the nature recommended by the Commission may result in members of the public making improperly informed decisions about whether or not to vaccinate, and therefore poses a risk to public health and safety.
The Commission is reported to have noted complaints that the AVN harassed the parents of a child who died of whooping cough last year, after those people had advocated the importance of childhood vaccination.

Australian law embodies a balance between the rights of individuals and the community, with restrictions on what individuals can do. Those restrictions reflect a recognition of potential harm to the community and to the individual. We thus impose requirements regarding safety helments while riding motorcycles, wearing seatbelts while driving cars, freedom from hallucinogens or other mind-altering substances while driving forklifts or conducting surgery ... all constraints on an ideal of possessive individualism. Health law - sometimes dubbed 'typhoid mary' provisions - provides for the detention of people who wilfully expose others to highly contagious serious diseases or prevent them from being protected. Compulsory treatment orders - and statutory authorisation for blood transfusion and other action contrary to parental wishes, under for example the Transplantation & Anatomy Act 1978 (ACT) s 23 - are evident in all major Australian jurisdictions, with sanctions against evasion by parent/guardians

Some examples are Director-General, Department of Community Services; Re Jules [2008] NSWSC 1193, S v South Eastern Sydney & Illawarra Area Health Service and anor [2010] NSWSC 178, Re Bernard [2009] NSWSC 11 and Director-General of DOCS v BB [1999] NSWSC 1169.

Magical thinking about the supposed harms of vaccination and the dismissal of hard science is seductive but should be resisted and should not be enshrined in law.

It is conceivable that the decision will be appealed. Readers should note that the decision was made under the Family Law Act 2005 (Cth); it does not provide for enforced vaccination outside that statute.

15 January 2011

deaths in custody

The 103 page Deaths in Custody: National Deaths in Custody program 2008 report [PDF] released last month by the Australian Institute of Criminology (AIC) notes that many of the deaths in custody are attributable to natural causes (in particular the ghastly illness known as old age), in contrast to the 1980s and 1990s when the death often involved younger men dying from self-inflicted injuries such as hanging.

The report analyses of data collected through the National Deaths in Custody Program, established in 1992 following recommendations by the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody.

In 2008 there were 86 deaths in prison and police custody, up from 74 deaths in 2007 but much lower than the numbers in the 1980s and 1990s. No deaths occurred in juvenile justice centres in 2008.

Co-author Laura Beacroft commented that -
Overall deaths in custody have been decreasing since 2000. The slight increase in the numbers of deaths since 2006 are associated with the ageing prison population and resulting health issues such as cancer and heart attacks – 70% of prison deaths were due to natural causes, and 47% of all deaths in custody were due to natural causes.
Beacroft went on to note that the long-term trends for both Indigenous and non-Indigenous deaths in custody have been decreasing over the past decade.
Indigenous people are not more likely to die in custody. The problem lies in the over-representation of Indigenous persons entering custody – Indigenous people comprise less than 2.5 percent of the total Australian population yet account for over a quarter (28%) of young people in juvenile detention, one-third (33%) of people involved in police custody incidents and almost one-quarter (24%) of the total prison population.
Between 1980 and 2005 there were generally more deaths of prisoners aged 25–39 years each year than those aged 55 years and over, a pattern reversed in the past seven years. In 2008 the number of deaths of persons aged 55 years and older was the highest recorded since data collection began in 1980, representing 35% of prison deaths in 2008. The number of 40 to 54 year olds who died in prison custody in 2008 was the second highest ever recorded.

In 2008 some 16 prison deaths occurred in cells, 26 in public hospitals, 10 in prison hospitals and two in other custodial settings. Six Indigenous deaths in 2008 occurred in a public hospital, two occurred in a cell and one in another custodial setting.

The AIC reports that young Indigenous and non-Indigenous prisoners are more likely to hang themselves than older prisoners, with 84% of total hangings involving persons aged under 39 years and 39% involving persons under 25 years. Preliminary analysis indicates that the median age of those dying in police custody (as of 2008) is 29 years, lower than the median age at death of 43 years in prison custody.

It goes on to indicate that -
factor contributing to this rise in the number of natural cause deaths in prison custody may be the poorer health of prisoners compared with the general population. Conclusions from a recent study [PDF] completed by the AIHW on prisoner health indicate that
prisoner populations are acknowledged as having some of the worst health in the community. High rates of chronic disease, blood-borne viruses and sexually transmitted infections, psychiatric illness and injury are found in this population.
Further, research has found that prisoners in Australia had higher rates of schizophrenia and psychotic disorders than the wider community and that the percentage of the prison population with these mental illnesses was much higher in Australia than in New Zealand, Canada or worldwide figures. As a result of these findings, it is concluded that recent rises in natural cause deaths in prison can probably be attributed, in part, to the ageing of the prison population combined with the poorer physical and mental health of prisoners in Australia when compared with the wider community.
In a co-authored article in the December issue of Melbourne University Law Review last month I pointed to indications that the incarcerated have a greater incidence of ADHD and comorbidities, likely to shape the individual's economic circumstances and thus health prior to incarceration.

14 January 2011

Coming thru the rye

The BBC reports - alas with few details - that Fredrik Colting's 60 Years Later: Coming Through the Rye (Windupbird, 2009), the unauthorised sequel to Salinger's The Catcher in the Rye, will not be published in the US or Canada and will be renamed.

Colting (aka John David California) has apparently reached a settlement with the Salinger estate, following decisions by the US federal court and appeals court during 2009 and 2010 in favour of Salinger. The latter described himself as "fiercely protective of his intellectual property" and as someone who "has never allowed any derivative works to be made using either The Catcher in the Rye or his Holden Caulfield character".

In the 2009 decision in the US District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Deborah Batts granted a permanent injunction against Colting and his publisher [PDF]. Batts was unimpressed by the claim that 60 Years Later was a literary commentary rather than a sequel and went on to conclude that Colting's work infringed Salinger's copyright.

Batts held that 60 Years Later was not a commentary and not a parody. She drew attention to Colting's public description (consistent with promo on the novel's jacket) that 60 Years Later was a sequel. Somewhat tartly, she noted that the 'commentary' characterisation was only introducted after Salinger sought an injunction, dismissing Colting's claims as "post hoc rationalizations employed through vague generalizations about the alleged naivete of the original" and tagging the 'transformative' defence as "at most, a tool with which to criticize and comment upon the author, JD Salinger, and his supposed idiosyncracies".

Colting had claimed that his work was not -
designed to satisfy any interest the public might have in learning what happened next to Holden Caulfield or the other characters in Salinger's book. Rather, it is intended to stand on its own as a critical examination of the character Holden Caulfield, the relationship between author and his creation, and the life of a particular author as he grows old but seems imprisoned by the literary character he created.
That claim would seem problematical, particularly given the experience related by Ian Hamilton in In Search Of J D Salinger (Heinemann, 1988).

Colting's publisher characterised his work as a "speculative psychological mystery"; the Salinger estate described it as "a rip-off, pure and simple".

Colting and publisher filed an appeal to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, supported in an amicus brief by the New York Times, Associated Press, the Gannett Company and the Tribune Company. Publisher support reflected their traditional disquiet about prior restraint, ie the Court's willingness to issue a ban in anticipation of publication rather than providing remedies after publication.

The brief thus describes Salinger's injunction and Batt's decision as -
the most offensive and least tolerable prohibition on speech. ... [I]n this case, where the only harm appears to be to the pride of a reclusive author in not having his desires fulfilled barring commentary about his iconic book and character, without any actual financial harm, the lower court saw fit to ban publication of a new book. Such a result defies common sense, and is not — and cannot be — the law.
A separate amicus brief was filed by The Organization for Transformative Works (of interest to fanfic and slash enthusiasts), the Association of College & Research Libraries, the American Library Association and the Association of Research Libraries [PDF].

Under the terms of the settlement Colting has reportedly agreed not to dedicate the book to Salinger, is prohibited from referring to The Catcher in the Rye or Salinger and is "prevented from using the copyright claim or Salinger's so-called 'ban' to promote the work". No details, alas: "We've come to an agreement with the Salinger trust but I'm afraid I can't go into any specifics".

Colting's novel apparently features an incontinent 76-year-old named "Mr C" escaping from a retirement home and heading to New York before stalking Salinger. One friend - having given up on Alice Randall's The Wind Done Gone: A Novel (Houghton Mifflin), dismissed as much much longer than the Civil War and more tasteless than Margaret Mitchell's Ashley-Wilkes-&-hominy-grits epic - commented tonight that he had hoped for something wildly postmodern, for example a fanfic parody in which Mr C watches American Psycho, buys a chainsaw, heads to NY in a limo and despatches the undead HLA Hart, Andy Warhol and a truckload of other zombies before being eaten by emo Catcher In The Rye kids.

A visit by Mr C, with chainsaw and flamethrower, to the Australian cricket team might be more useful.

Spam and Fax DNC

The Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA) has accepted an 11 page enforceable undertaking [PDF] from Virgin Blue Airlines under the Spam Act 2003 (Cth).

The undertaking follows an ACMA investigation into complaints alleging that the airline continued to send commercial email despite multiple attempts by recipients to unsubscribe from its mailing list. The Act, as noted in past posts on this blogs, requires commercial email to include a functional unsubscribe facility. Undertakings have been received in the past by enterprises such as Virgin Mobile (Australia) Pty Ltd, Commonwealth Securities Ltd and Vodafone Hutchison Australia Pty Ltd. They are a gentler regulatory mechanism than the penalties imposed by the Federal Court under the Spam Act, eg the $22 million penalties noted in December and August last year over egregious misbehaviour.

The enforceable undertaking - which includes payment of $110,000 - commits Virgin Blue to "a thorough overhaul and independent assessment of its email marketing practices". Virgin Blue acknowledged that it had "experienced problems" with its email marketing systems, leading to receipt by some previously unsubscribed consumers of new (and undesired) email.

ACMA Chair Chris Chapman commented that -
Businesses which market by email need to regularly test that the unsubscribe function in their messages is working properly. The Spam Act requires that a request from a consumer to be unsubscribed from commercial emails must be addressed. No further commercial electronic messages are allowed to be sent to the consumer five working days after an unsubscribe request is made.
Announcement - sound the trumpets, beat the drums - aside, the undertaking does not provide much to write home about (ACMA's guide to undertakings is online [PDF]). It was more than a year in the making. It features standard wording in 'sorry but no admission' mode and promises to try harder in future. Virgin Blue will engage an independent third party to "thoroughly assess its email marketing processes" and to implement any recommended changes. It will also provide training to relevant employees, establish a complaints handling policy, and audit 10 per cent of its email marketing campaigns monthly for a year.

Readers are reminded that closing date for submissions in response to ACMA's call for comment on the draft national standard for the fax marketing industry is 4 February 2011.

ACMA is seeking views on the proposal to require a destination sending number (a 'header line') on all marketing faxes as part of the fax marketing industry standard. Submissions in previous consultations proposed inclusion of the additional information to assist in reducing the number of complaints arising from faxes that were originally sent to numbers not on the Do Not Call Register being redirected automatically to numbers that are on the register.

Ask not for whom the bell tolls

Andrew Jacobs in the New York Times notes claims that Chinese farmer Shi Jianfeng evaded over US$550,000 in road tolls during eight months of driving, being punished by the Pingdingshan Intermediate People's Court in Henan province with a US$300,000 fine and life imprisonment.
There seems to be little dispute that Mr. Shi, who had turned to hauling sand and gravel to make a living, behaved egregiously. He purchased two fake military license plates and other documentation that allowed him and his hired drivers to escape paying tolls on his two trucks during 2,300 trips between May 2008 and January 2009. In announcing the verdict this week, The Dahe Daily suggested that the defendant had accepted his guilt because he declined to appeal. He also did not have a lawyer.

But the financial details of the violations for which Mr. Shi was convicted only served to feed suspicions that he had been railroaded. The toll per truck trip averages more than $200 — a high figure, though truck tolls can go by weight.

But many people noted that his profit during those toll-free days amounted to $30,000. If he had truly evaded $556,000 in road fees, as the police charge, he would have lost more than $520,000 from his trucking business.
Criticism of the sentence has reportedly included comments such as -
Rape and murder will earn you 15 years in prison but evading road charges will get you life. Ours is a miraculous country with peculiar laws.
The Times comments that -
Popular aversion to such fees has been inflamed by media reports of freeloading government motorcades and inflated tolls that end up in the pockets of local officials. In 2008, the country’s National Audit Office said that motorists had handed over $2.3 billion at illegally erected tollbooths.
The China Daily offered a more nuanced account, highlighting identity offences -
A man who used fake military documents to evade 3.68 million yuan ($557,000) in highway toll fees in a Central China city has been sentenced to life in prison for fraud. ... Shi Jianfeng, from Yuzhou city, bought two fake military car license plates, military driver's licenses, military ID cards and other documents.

Tollgate records showed that Shi avoided toll payment 2,362 times from May 2008 to January 2009, the court said.

Shi said in court that he hired people to drive two trucks to transport sand and stone and had earned more than 200,000 yuan during that period.

He was fined 2 million yuan and his illegal revenue was confiscated, according to the court verdict.

Shi did not hire a lawyer and does not plan to appeal, the court said.

An employee, surnamed Li, at Xiatang tollgate on Zhengzhou-Yaoshan Highway where Shi's trucks went through every day, said Shi claimed he was a soldier with Xuchang city's Armed Police division and came to apply for toll-free passes for two trucks in May 2008, saying there was a construction project going on for the division, the local Dahe Daily reported.

The documents were complete, but there was no way to identify if they were authentic, according to Li.

Shi Jianfeng admitted that he used fake military documents to evade toll fees in order to earn more money.

Fearing that tollgate employees would notice flaws in the documents, he regularly changed his drivers, the report said.
'Some socio-economic impacts of toll roads in rural China' by Him Chung in 10(2) Journal of Transport Geography (2002) 145-156 notes that China's Roadway Law of 1998
authorises local governments at county levels or above to establish toll stations and collect fees within their administrative jurisdiction. Generally, toll stations are allowed every 40 km in the plains and 20 km in hilly areas. Thus, China's toll roads are found in both city and countryside – a case that is different from Malaysia, Indonesia and Thailand, where toll roads are mainly established in urban areas. Also, the toll road is often the only connection between two places.

The idea of “maintain road by road” also entails the establishment of illegal toll stations. Huge revenues generated by tolls attracted a variety of government authorities to join this "gold rush" since the 1990s. Tollbooths have been established by Ministries of Police, Forestry, Taxation, Industry and Commerce, Urban Construction, Family Planning and Public Health, and different levels of local government. Illegal tolls have become a serious problem in China, and are regularly found along county, township and village roads. In 1993, a study showed that a local freight transport company in Shangdong province was fined a total of 275,732 yuan within 10 months. Among the total, 5% were contributed to transport departments, 89% to police departments and 6% to environmental, industry and commerce, and tax departments.

Illegal tolls were levied under various rubrics including vehicle washing, vehicle entrance, commodity delivery, border crossing and road user fees. Car washing was one of the most common levies. A car-washing booth was illegally established on a busy highway linking Guangzhou and Shenzhen SEZ. Drivers were stopped and forced to pay to have their vehicle washed. This 24 hr operated illegal booth occupied two of the three lanes and created serious traffic congestion at the eastern border of Guangzhou city. Also, according to the Ministry of Transport, there were illegal checkpoints and roadblocks. Road users were forced to pay separate fines to irrelevant authorities under the pretext of speeding, overloading and dangerous driving. A Guangdong newspaper disclosed that tickets for traffic infringements were given by agricultural officers at illegal checkpoints in Dongguan and Yunan). Another case showed that a farmer's utility truck was stopped at a roadblock in Weicheng and received a ticket of 190 yuan. No reasons were given from the uniformed officials who issued the infringement. Also, the receipt given was a fake with incorrect date and amount of fine. The situation worsened when legal tollbooths levied unauthorised charges so that the officers could profit personally. These "three illegals" (san lun)” – illegal tollbooths, illegal fines and illegal levies – jeopardised normal economic activities and transport development.

There are no statistics on the number of illegal stations, but the situation can be projected from sundry sources. Early in 1993, the Ministry of Transport abolished 467 toll stations and 292 levies were cancelled nationally. In Guangdong, a special team was established in 1995 to investigate the "three illegals". Within six months, over 1000 complaints were received. This led to the abolition of 14 illegal tollbooths in the province – six of them were located in rural areas. However, despite this achievement, many of the illegal toll stations have metamorphosed and now appear in mobile forms. Some mobile tollbooths are primitive and comprised only a rope, a torch, a "stop" sign, and several motorcycles. These mobile manifestations are difficult to check and close down. A survey in 1996 demonstrated that there were 2582 teams (excluding police departments) – 46 950 people in 15 different government uniforms – involved in collecting illegal tolls in Guangdong province. According to the Guangdong government, another 13 illegal toll stations, including 10 in the countryside, were abolished in 1998. However, these official figures underestimate the real number. A typical example of this was two illegal booths in Zhongshan persisted in tolling after they had been officially abolished.