01 July 2021

Conservation and Personhood

'A critical review of the compassionate conservation debate' by Simon Coghlan and Adam P A Cardilini in (2021) Conservation Biology comments
 
Compassionate conservation holds that compassion should transform conservation. It has prompted heated debate and has been criticized strongly. We reviewed the debate to characterize compassionate conservation and to philosophically analyze critiques that are recurring and that warrant further critical attention. The necessary elements of compassionate conservation relate to the moral value of sentient animals and conservation and to science and conservation practice. Although compassionate conservation has several nontraditional necessary conditions, it also importantly allows a degree of pluralism in values and scientific judgment regarding animals and conservation practice. We identified 52 specific criticisms from 11 articles that directly critique compassionate conservation. We closely examined 33 of these because they recurred regularly or included substantial questions that required further response. Critics criticized compassionate conservation's ethical foundations, scientific credentials, clarity of application, understanding of compassion, its alleged threat to conservation and biodiversity. Some criticisms, we found, are question begging, confused, or overlook conceptual complexity. These criticisms raise questions for critics and proponents, regarding, for example, equal versus differential intrinsic moral value of different sentient animals (including humans), problems of natural and human-caused suffering of wild animals and predation, and the acceptability of specific conservation practices within compassionate conservation. By addressing recurring and faulty critiques of compassionate conservation and identifying issues for compassionate conservation to address, this review provides a clearer basis for crucial ongoing interdisciplinary dialogue about ethics, values, and conservation.

'Recognizing animal personhood in compassionate conservation' by Arian D. Wallach, Chelsea Batavia, Marc Bekoff, Shelley Alexander, Liv Baker, Dror Ben-Ami, Louise Boronyak, Adam P. A. Cardilin, Yohay Carmel, Danielle Celermajer, Simon Coghlan, Yara Dahdal, Jonatan J. Gomez, Gisela Kaplan, Oded Keynan, Anton Khalilieh, Helen Kopnina, William S. Lynn, Yamini Narayanan, Sophie Riley, Francisco J. Santiago-Ávila, Esty Yanco, Miriam A. Zemanova and Daniel Ramp in (2020) Conservation Biology comments 

Compassionate conservation is based on the ethical position that actions taken to protect biodiversity should be guided by compassion for all sentient beings. Critics argue that there are 3 core reasons harming animals is acceptable in conservation programs: the primary purpose of conservation is biodiversity protection; conservation is already compassionate to animals; and conservation should prioritize compassion to humans. We used argument analysis to clarify the values and logics underlying the debate around compassionate conservation. We found that objections to compassionate conservation are expressions of human exceptionalism, the view that humans are of a categorically separate and higher moral status than all other species. In contrast, compassionate conservationists believe that conservation should expand its moral community by recognizing all sentient beings as persons. Personhood, in an ethical sense, implies the individual is owed respect and should not be treated merely as a means to other ends. On scientific and ethical grounds, there are good reasons to extend personhood to sentient animals, particularly in conservation. The moral exclusion or subordination of members of other species legitimates the ongoing manipulation and exploitation of the living worlds, the very reason conservation was needed in the first place. Embracing compassion can help dismantle human exceptionalism, recognize nonhuman personhood, and navigate a more expansive moral space.

The authors argue 

Western culture traditionally regarded humans as exceptional among all animals (Rose 2011). This belief was challenged by scientific and philosophical breakthroughs confirming Charles Darwin's view that “there is no fundamental difference” between humans and other animals (Darwin 1871). Today, it is beyond dispute that many animals are sentient beings (Low et al. 2012; Bekoff & Pierce 2017). Much has changed since the 1960s, when primatologist Jane Goodall was castigated for ascribing chimpanzees with personalities and feelings (Goodall 1998). Despite this, even those nonhuman animals with recognized mental, emotional, and social sophistication (such as mammals, birds, and cephalopods) are still readily treated as means to human ends (Midgley 1985). Conservation is no exception (Wallach et al. 2018). 

Although conservation was founded on a uniquely expansive ethic that recognizes the intrinsic value of the living world (Batavia & Nelson 2017), nonhuman animals do not necessarily meet a better fate in the hands of conservationists than in any other hands (Ramp & Bekoff 2015; Wallach et al. 2018). Conservationists often embody deep concern, even love, for wildlife and nature. Yet, this can be a “violent love” (Srinivasan & Kasturirangan 2017). Systemic harm of sentient animals in conservation is enabled by 3 ethical orientations: collectivism (or holism)—the belief that species matter more than individuals; instrumentalism—the treatment of an entity as a means to an end; and nativism—the view that populations established by humans are unnatural (Wallach et al. 2018). These orientations drive conservation practices that use “authoritarian management and control measures” (Bhattacharyya & Larson 2014) and that regard nonhuman animals as “instances of their type” (Vucetich & Nelson 2007) and as “killable” (Haraway 2013) “objects” (Nussbaum 1995). 

Compassionate conservation, in contrast, recognizes that the interests and agency of all sentient beings should be protected in conservation practice (Ramp & Bekoff 2015; Wallach et al. 2018). In other words, sentient beings are persons. Personhood, in an ethical sense, implies an entity is owed respect and should not be treated as a means to other ends (Midgley 1985; Dayan 2018). Many traditions (including hunting-based cultures) have long understood the world as animated with multitudes of persons with whom humans form kinship relations (e.g., Rose 2011; Hill 2013; Robinson 2014). Western tradition, however, has largely restricted the notion of personhood to humans, an expression of human exceptionalism that maintains humans as a categorically separate and inherently superior class of being (Plumwood 1993). It is not our purpose to dispute this view, per se, but to offer an alternative; namely, all sentient beings are persons when viewed through the lens of compassion. 

The proposition that compassion for sentient beings should inform and where necessary redirect conservation goals and practices has generated intense debate. Recently, a series of critiques of compassionate conservation unfolded in Conservation Biology and included a Conservation Focus “Debating Compassion in Conservation Science” (2019, Volume 33, Issue 4). We considered the main statements made in opposition to compassionate conservation in 5 essays that responded to Wallach et al. (2015) and Wallach et al. (2018): Russell et al. (2016), Driscoll and Watson (2019), Hampton et al. (2019), Hayward et al. (2019), and Oommen et al. (2019) (hereafter critiques or critics). We condensed the critiques into 3 core reasons to reject compassionate conservation and support lethal and invasive conservation practices: the primary purpose (raison d'être) of conservation is biodiversity protection; conservation is already compassionate to animals; and conservation should prioritize compassion to humans (Table 1). We developed these reasons into formal arguments, which allowed us to clarify the values and logic underlying the debate around compassionate conservation. Formal arguments are composed of a set of premises (P) leading to a conclusion (C). An argument is sound when it meets 2 conditions: it is valid, meaning its conclusion necessarily follows from its premises, and its premises are true or appropriate, meaning the empirical premises are factually accurate and the ethical premises are consistently defensible (Hughes et al. 2010).

30 June 2021

Insecurity

The recommendations of the first Interim Report (on On-demand platform work in Australia) by the Senate Select Committee on Job Security are 

 R 1  The committee recommends that the Australian Bureau of Statistics expands its Labour Force Survey to capture quarterly estimates in relation to the number of workers engaged in the on-demand platform sector. These estimates could include the industries and occupations in which they work, the hours they work, their visa status, the nature of their working arrangements relative to other workers, earnings and other demographic characteristics. 

R 2  The committee recommends that the Australian Bureau of Statistics enhances its Work-Related Injuries Survey to capture specific information on the number, and types, of injuries and fatalities for workers engaged in the on‑demand platform sector. 

R 3  The committee recommends that Safe Work Australia enhances its national data collection process to capture specific information on the number, and types, of injuries and fatalities for workers engaged in the on‑demand platform sector. The committee further recommends that all road crashes involving on-demand workers be officially recognised as workplace incidents and are recorded and investigated as such. 

R 4  The committee recommends that, as a matter of priority, Safe Work Australia develops meaningful, high-level guidelines on the application of the model Work Health and Safety Laws to the on-demand platform (or 'gig') sector. The guidance should be aimed at addressing practices that incentivise unsafe behaviour, as well as enforcing compliance with safety rules and obligations. The guidance should not seek to unreasonably circumvent the obligations of on-demand companies through novel interpretations of workers as being a 'person conducting a business or undertaking' (PCBU), particularly when such workers in the on-demand sector are engaged in highly dependent or low-leverage work arrangements. 

R 5  The committee recommends that the Australian Government urgently clarifies, by way of regulation, which persons or entities owe a duty of care as a person conducting a business or undertaking (PCBU) under the Model Work Health and Safety laws in relation to individual support workers engaged through on‑demand platforms like Mable. The law should dictate that: a platform that engages individual workers to provide support work under the NDIS or similar schemes, and makes money from the arrangement, is a PCBU and owes a duty of care to that worker, regardless of that worker's work status (employee or contractor), or their visa status; and that individual care recipients, such as NDIS participants, are not a PCBU in relation to that worker. 

R 6  The committee recommends that the Australian Government works with state and territory governments to lead the reform of state-based workers' compensation schemes so that they extend to platform workers, regardless of their visa or work status, and require platform companies to pay workers' compensation premiums for these workers. 

R 7  The committee recommends that the Australian Government expands the definitions of 'employment' and 'employee' in the Fair Work Act 2009 to capture new and evolving forms of work. In addition to an expanded definition of 'employment' and 'employee' under the Fair Work Act, there should be a mechanism by which the Fair Work Commission can extend coverage of those rights when necessary to workers falling outside the expanded definition of employment, including low-leveraged and highly dependent workers so they can be provided with standards and protections under the Act. 

R 8  The Committee recommends that the Australian Government investigates options for a Federal regulator to be empowered to request data from platforms that employ and contract workers, including: pay rates; hours worked; other conditions governing that work; and other relevant information needed to appropriately monitor safety, competition and labour rights. 

R 9  The committee recommends that the Australian Government gives the Fair Work Commission (FWC) broad powers to resolve disputes and make orders for minimum standards and conditions in relation to all forms of work. The expanded remit of the FWC would include: adjudicating in cases where there is a dispute in relation to the appropriate status of workers; setting binding minimum standards and conditions in relation to non‑standard forms of work, regardless of employment status; and the capacity to resolve disputes (including where necessary through binding decisions) in a low-cost and effective manner. The FWC should be empowered to make determinations and orders for groups and categories of workers, not just individuals. 

R 10  The committee recommends that the Australian Government empowers the Fair Work Commission (FWC) to provide pathways to permanency via arbitrations for casual conversion. Any disputes with regards to work status, contractual arrangements, or casual conversion should be able to be arbitrated via a low‑cost, accessible process, whether via the FWC or another body, to ensure workers are able to practically enforce their rights, and both workers and employers can have matters adjudicated quickly. 

R 11  The committee recommends that the Australian Government provide greater protections for independent contractors who are sole traders by establishing an accessible low-cost national tribunal to advise on, oversee, and make rulings relating to employment relationships involving low‑leveraged independent contractors, such as those in the rideshare and other platform sectors. 

R 12  The committee recommends that the Joint Standing Committee on the National Disability Insurance Scheme give specific consideration to the following matters related to platform-based work in the disability sector as part of its current inquiry into the NDIS Workforce and its ongoing examination of the operation and performance of the NDIS: the prevalence of platform-based work in the sector, and the growing and evolving nature of this business model; the prevalence of independent contracting through platforms; the characteristics of independent contractors providing support work through platforms like Mable; the extent to which workers rely on this income, or have other sources of income; the typical earnings, insurance coverage, superannuation and access to leave and other entitlements available to these workers; the adequacy of training and support provided to workers; issues associated with safety, risk, and liability under Work Health and Safety laws; and issues relating to the potential for NDIS recipients to be classified as persons conducting a business or undertaking (PCBUs) under existing Work Health and Safety laws. 

R 13  Taking into account the findings of any relevant inquiries, the committee recommends that the Australian Government considers regulatory options that would ensure support workers engaged to provide services funded through the National Disability Insurance Scheme are provided with fair pay and conditions, including those engaged through on‑demand platforms. 

R 14  The committee recommends that the Australian Government considers working with states and territories to design a national scheme that connects and extends the current state and territory schemes to provide portable long service leave, sick leave and other leave entitlements, and portable training entitlements, to all workers delivering services under the National Disability Insurance Scheme. 

R 15  The committee recommends that the Australian Government works through the Council on Federal Financial Relations to achieve an intergovernmental agreement that government procurements must require companies engaged by the Federal and state and territory governments to provide minimum standards of pay, safety and insurance, workers' compensation and basic protections for workers.

A perspective is provided by the 2018 ACT Legislative Assembly report on the Standing Committee on Education, Employment and Youth Affairs inquiry regarding the Extent, Nature and Consewquences of Insecure Work in the ACT.

27 June 2021

Biometrics

'Changing perceptions of biometric technologies' (Australian Institute of Criminology Research Report no. 20) by Christie Franks and Russell Smith - oriented to the Department of Home Affairs and heavily dependent on work by the biometrics industry body - comments 

 Identity crime and misuse cost the Australian economy an estimated $3.1b in 2018–19 (Smith & Franks 2020). Protecting individuals’ personal identification information and finding secure ways to verify identities has become an increased priority as the impact of identity crime continues to grow in Australia and worldwide. Biometric technologies for identity verification provide an enhanced security solution, although implementation of biometric systems within Australian society has met with varying degrees of acceptance. Since 2013, the Australian Institute of Criminology (AIC) has conducted online surveys to gain a greater understanding of identity crime and misuse in Australia. These surveys have asked about respondents’ experience of identity crime and also their previous use of, and future willingness to use, biometric technologies to safeguard their personal information. This report presents both qualitative and quantitative research findings obtained from a sample of respondents in the most recent surveys concerning their experiences of biometrics and perceptions as to its role in identity security.

 The authors state 

Annually since 2013 (with the exception of 2015), the AIC has administered online questionnaires to a research panel of Australians drawn from all states and territories. A sampling frame of more than 300,000 individuals was provided by the market research company i-Link Research Solutions, which also hosted the online questionnaire and provided raw, de-identified data for the AIC to analyse. Sampling was completed once a quota of 10,000 respondents had been satisfied. No other quotas were employed as the sample was sufficiently large to ensure good representation from urban and regional areas across Australia. 

Survey results were weighted by age and gender to represent the spread of the population in Australia. Australian Bureau of Statistics data from the 2016 Census were used to develop the weighting matrix for the sample. Questions on biometrics were asked of all respondents, not only those who had reported previous misuse of personal information. All respondents answered questions about their prior use of biometrics and their willingness to use biometrics for specified purposes. 

Extended online interviews were conducted with 99 individuals who had participated in the AIC’s online survey in 2018 and who had agreed to participate in further research. These interviews were moderated by Footprints Market Research using the i-Discuss online platform provided by i-Link Research Services. Interviews canvassed four selected topics that enabled responses of the original survey respondents to be examined in greater depth. These qualitative results are the focus of the present report. In order to provide data on certain other aspects of biometrics, the findings of two other surveys were presented. One was conducted for the Ada Lovelace Institute in the United Kingdom on public attitudes to facial recognition technology and the other was conducted for the Biometrics Institute to ascertain the views of its membership regarding the biometrics market globally. These are presented by way of comparison with the AIC’s quantitative survey and qualitative interview research findings. ... 

Results of the AIC 2019 identity crime survey, AIC 2018 identity crime survey and online interviews, and consulted international publications, demonstrate a generally high level of previous exposure to biometrics, with an increasing willingness to use biometric technologies in the future, especially among previous victims of identity crime. Simple username and password combinations are becoming obsolete as offenders have become more adept at compromising these user authentication processes. The constant requirement of network security to reset these combinations has made it challenging for users to manage access to devices without resorting to insecure ways of remembering passwords. Biometrics offer a more secure solution by enabling individuals to use their biological attributes as a means of identifying themselves. 

The AIC’s research has shown that previous use of specified biological biometrics is strong, with three out of four respondents stating they have used at least one form of the technology in the past (Franks & Smith 2020). Franks and Smith (2020) also reported that future willingness to use biometrics as a security solution remains consistently strong, with at least 71 percent of all respondents willing to use some form of biometric for identification purposes, increasing to 76 percent for recent victims of identity theft. Recent victims were also more than twice as willing as non-victims to try having a computer chip implanted under their skin as a future security option (42% vs 20% respectively; Franks & Smith 2020). Generally, recent victims of identity crime were more willing than non-victims to use all of the biometric technologies mentioned; however, recent victims were four percentage points less willing than non-victims to continue using the less secure option of passwords (Franks & Smith 2020). The top three preferred biometrics among the cohort interviewed by the AIC in 2018 were fingerprint scans, facial recognition and voice recognition. 

Respondents to the AIC surveys have shown a general approval of the use of biometric technologies by government authorities for law enforcement and national security reasons and as a means of obtaining access to government services. Feelings towards the use of biometric technologies for public surveillance, personal reasons and by private industry are mixed. Privacy, ethical use, data access and storage security were some of the main concerns expressed by both AIC and comparison survey participants. Results of the Biometrics Institute (2019) survey of industry experts were consistent with 2018 in predicting facial recognition technology as the area of greatest potential growth by 55 percent of Biometrics Institute respondents. AIC and Ada Lovelace Institute (2019) survey respondents stated their acceptance of the use of this technology in the form of crowd surveillance for national security and community safety but were less willing when considering it for commercial use. Survey participants were generally willing to use all biometric systems monitored by government entities and far less willing to use those issued by private organisations. 

Most of the survey cohort had limited knowledge of how their personal information was being used, stored and protected, and expressed disappointment in the degree of information provided by both government and industry. The Biometrics Institute (2019) cohort ranked ‘data sharing concerns’ as the second highest key market restraint, with ‘privacy/data protection concerns’ ranked at number one. 

Respondents from both the AIC and Ada Lovelace Institute surveys and the AIC online interviews were concerned about privacy issues and the ethical use of biometrics data—these included concerns about inaccurate matching leading to false identification/prosecution by law enforcement. Individuals were most comfortable with biometrics when they were afforded freedom of choice but accepted enforced use in situations where their security was at risk; however, support was not unconditional. The capture and storage of information without user consent was not justifiable for most. 

Identity crime and misuse of personal information remain ongoing concerns for those in the Australian community. Despite advances in verification of credentials and improvements in online authentication procedures, victimisation continues to increase. Financial losses also continue to rise, along with the equally harmful non-financial consequences including damage to credit ratings, being wrongly accused of crime, and a range of psychological and emotional harms. 

This report presents the findings obtained in online interviews with selected AIC 2018 survey participants as well as the results of the latest AIC identity crime survey, conducted in 2019. The results of relevant international publications that demonstrate previous exposure to biometrics in Australia and overseas are also presented by way of comparison. This report also examines the increasing willingness of individuals to use biometric technologies in the future, advantages, challenges, future developments and the restraints of implementation including expense, privacy and ethics considerations.

26 June 2021

Lobbying

The NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) Investigation into the regulation of lobbying, access and influence in NSW (Operation Eclipse) report released 22 June finds that new legislation or significant reform of the current Lobbying of Government Officials Act 2011 (NSW) - aka the LOGO Act - is required to safeguard the public interest against the inherent lobbying risks of corruption and undue influence. 

The report states 

Operation Eclipse is an investigation by the Independent Commission Against Corruption (“the Commission”) into the regulation of lobbying, access and influence in NSW. Unlike most investigations conducted by the Commission, Operation Eclipse was not concerned with whether any individual had engaged in corrupt conduct. Instead, it examined factors that could either allow, encourage or cause corrupt conduct or detract from the integrity and good repute of public administration. The Commission has power to make findings, form and state opinions, and make recommendations, even if the relevant conduct is not corrupt conduct for the purposes of the ICAC Act but is otherwise a matter within the Commission’s statutory functions. Lobbying, although widely accepted as an integral and legitimate activity for the functioning of a democratic system, carries inherent risks of corruption, undue influence, unfair access and biased decision-making that are detrimental to the public interest and effective public policies. An examination of lobbying practices in NSW was first undertaken by the Commission in an investigation known as Operation Halifax. A number, but not all the 17 recommendations made in its 2010 report, Investigation into corruption risks involved in lobbying, were adopted. Consequently, many of the inherent risks referred to above continued to prevail and the activities of a great many lobbyists were not made subject to robust regulation. The catalysts provided for Operation Eclipse were a minimalist legislative approach to the regulation of lobbying in NSW, in particular in relation to lobbying in a transparent and accountable way, combined with declining levels of public trust in government officials to conduct their duties and obligations. 

In this investigation, the Commission considered to what extent the regulation of lobbying under the existing statutory regime, found in the LOGO Act, is working in practice. Or, whether enhancements were needed to ensure both the actuality and the perception that access and influence in government and public administration are in accord with accepted standards of transparency and accountability. In line with evidence submitted during the investigation, the Commission has made nine key findings and 29 recommendations for lobbying reform. The recommendations made in this report emphasise the importance of lobbying regulation that promotes transparency of process and accountability in decision-making. They are directed to reassuring the community that lobbying practices are not conducted in unaccountable secrecy.

ICAC's  key findings are 

1 New legislation, or significant reform of the LOGO Act, is required to safeguard the public interest against the inherent lobbying risks of corruption and undue influence. 

A key finding of the Commission is that the LOGO Act fails to provide a proper and sufficiently robust framework to manage corruption risks. It does not provide the required level of assurance to the general public that democratic principles of transparency, accountability, integrity and fairness are being met. The enactment of new legislation for the regulation of lobbying is necessary to ensure accountability in the exercise of public office and public power. Strengthening transparency and accountability in lobbying will only be achieved through legislation that ensures such transparency and accountability. The LOGO Act falls well-short in these respects. The Commission is of the view that lobbying regulation in NSW can be readily strengthened by drawing on best practice standards. The recommendations in this report include proposals to adopt, as appropriate, specific concepts and mechanisms operating in other jurisdictions, including Scotland, Ireland and Canada. 

2 Oversight of improper lobbying and compliance with the LOGO Act could be improved. 

A dedicated lobbying commissioner should be appointed to focus on regulating lobbying activity and take on the new and expanded functions recommended by the Commission in this report. The regulation of lobbying currently falls within the remit of the NSWEC. However, the NSWEC operates under a statutory framework that was designed for the regulation of elections, not lobbying. Regulatory oversight of lobbying in NSW can be expected to be improved by creating a dedicated office. The Commission sees the need for expanded regulatory functions, which an appointed lobbying commissioner would be well-suited to perform, such as: 

  • • oversight of an expanded Lobbyists Register 

  • greater oversight of government officials, including through the use of investigative powers 

  • additional scope to publish regulatory findings 

  • duties to prevent undue influence and other forms of improper lobbying conduct. A related function would include the provision of guidance and education on integrity standards. 

3 The existing regulatory regime does not address or set out the ethical obligations for government officials who are lobbied. 

The LOGO Act makes provision for a Lobbyists Code of Conduct that is applicable to all lobbyists. A key finding of the Commission is that a robust lobbying regime must additionally address the obligations and conduct of government officials in processing and determining lobbying proposals. A statutory codification of common law and ethical obligations and standards in the form of a new “Lobbying Code of Conduct” should be formulated to apply to both lobbyists and those government officials being lobbied. 

4 There is insufficient information available to the public, civil society groups and the media about lobbying activities. 

The Commission notes that the current NSW Lobbyists Register only covers a small amount of the lobbying activity that takes place in NSW. As a result, it can be difficult to determine which groups or individuals have influenced key government decision-makers. A revised online NSW Lobbyists Register should be designed to make information available to the public about who is lobbying whom and about what. Those required to register should extend beyond third-party lobbyists, subject to exemptions for lower risk lobbying activities. While online lobbying registers in Canada, Ireland and Scotland differ in the range of information that regulated lobbyists are required to disclose, some elements of transparency are common to them all, including:  

  • • the identity of those on whose behalf lobbying is being carried out 

  • the designated public official being lobbied 

  • the purpose of the lobbying 

  • intended results of the lobbying. 

5 The local government sector faces considerable risk of undue influence and should be regulated by the LOGO Act. 

Investigations conducted by the Commission and interstate anti-corruption commissions indicate that local councils are often the target of improper lobbying. However, local government officials are not “government officials” as defined by, and for the purposes of, the LOGO Act. The Model Code of Conduct for Local Councils in NSW does not explicitly refer to lobbying; however, it does contain general obligations in relation to ethical and honest conduct, as well as more detailed material covering:

  • improper and undue influence 

  • inappropriate interactions 

  • use and security of confidential information 

  • recordkeeping.

Extending the provisions of the LOGO Act to local government would, among other matters, allow the lobbying regulator to provide guidance about the appropriate policies and procedures that would best suit the circumstances of local councils, particularly regarding matters about planning, land use, the environment and community amenities. 

6 The movement of certain former public officials between the government sector and lobbying roles is currently unregulated, presenting a risk of undue influence over government. 

In NSW, post-employment cooling-off periods are generally confined to ministers and parliamentary secretaries. Other classes of public official, including members of Parliament, ministerial staff and senior public sector executives, do not face the same restrictions. The Commission’s view is that post-employment restrictions should be considered for a broader range of officials in high-risk categories. Greater transparency about the movement in, and out of, key government roles is also recommended and could be achieved by establishing a “Former Public Officials” list. This list would contain the names of relevant former public officials who have moved into lobbying roles. 

7 The published summaries of ministerial diary disclosures are not sufficiently detailed or meaningful for the public to understand who is meeting whom and why. 

Since 2014, extracts from ministerial diaries have been published that record scheduled meetings held with external parties, including lobbyists. In their current format, these ministerial diary disclosures are not easily accessible or searchable, making scrutiny and analysis difficult. Importantly, the published descriptions are usually too short and too vague to adequately explain what the meetings are about. To ensure accountability, members of the community should be able to know which ministers have met with lobbyists and the purpose of such meetings. For this to happen, the publication of ministerial diary disclosures must be strengthened in terms of content, format and timeliness. The Commission recommends that the oversight of diary disclosures should fall to the regulator of the LOGO Act. 

8 Lobbyists are not explicitly prohibited from giving gifts to government officials. 

The LOGO Act and Lobbyists Code do not place specific obligations or restrictions on lobbyists in relation to gift-giving. Although gift-giving by lobbyists is not commonplace, this anomaly should be corrected. 

9 Recordkeeping practices in relation to lobbying activities are inadequate. 

NSW Government agencies should be required to adopt minimum standards and a model policy on recordkeeping, the disclosure of records, and protocols around scheduling and conducting meetings with lobbyists. Numerous acts, regulations and procedures require NSW public officials to validate or give an account of their decisions or record information. Open government initiatives, such as the State Records Act 1998, the GIPA Act, and Standing Order 52 of the Legislative Council are mechanisms used to acquire information, usually in relation to a government decision, that has become a matter of broad public interest. A key finding of the Commission is that greater accountability can be achieved by strengthening recordkeeping provisions and their oversight.

ICAC's recommendations are 

 R 1 That the Lobbyists Code of Conduct be renamed the “Lobbying Code of Conduct” and imposes standards and obligations on public officials with regard to how lobbying proposals are received, considered and determined. These standards and obligations will be consistent with the obligations at law that apply to the discharge of public functions and the exercise of public powers. 

R 2 That the “Lobbying Code of Conduct” includes general principles that a public official must adhere to when receiving, considering and determining a lobbying proposal, including the obligations: • to act honestly, impartially and disinterestedly • to act in the public interest and not for any extraneous purpose • not to act improperly, including by improper preferencing or favouritism. 

R 3 That the “Lobbying Code of Conduct” also sets out some detailed standards and obligations including:

a) a prohibition on undocumented or secret meetings and communications with lobbyists, which entails obligations to:

i. document all communications with lobbyists, including those held away from government premises, apart from immaterial or ephemeral communications 

ii. avoid discussing substantive matters with lobbyists in social settings

b) an expectation that a public official makes all reasonable efforts to seek the views of all parties whose interests are likely to be affected by the adoption of a lobbying proposal 

c) a prohibition on improper preferential treatment of a lobbyist on the basis of any existing or former relationship (for example, a conflict of interest situation) 

d) that a public official should discourage lobbying representations relating to proposals in situations where there are formal assessment procedures in place for determining the merits of the proposal, and that these procedures (for example, those relating to development applications, tenders, grants and unsolicited proposals) offer a more suitable channel through which representations can be made 

e) that a public official must not divulge information to lobbyists that would provide them with an unfair advantage over other interested parties, including other lobbyists 

f) a requirement to report any reasonably suspected breach of the “Lobbying Code of Conduct” to the lobbying regulator. 

R 4 That, with respect to the proposed “Lobbying Code of Conduct”, the obligations on, and oversight of, government officials should extend to circumstances where an official is “lobbied” by a person or entity acting in their/its own interests; that is, not “representing the interests of others ”. 

R 5 That the lobbying regulator be empowered and resourced to:

  • develop minimum standards and a model policy relating to interactions with lobbyists and others making representations to government, which should: – address recordkeeping, disclosure of records and protocols for organising and conducting meetings – prohibit undocumented or secret interactions with lobbyists or other persons making representations to government 

  • ssess and report on agencies’ compliance with minimum standards 

  • give advice to agencies and individual government officials about compliance with minimum requirements and better practice 

  • liaise with organisations such as the State Archives and Records Authority and the Information and Privacy Commission 

  • direct an agency or public official to provide any lobbying-related documents or records.

Such a direction would operate in a manner similar to the power in s 15 of the State Records Act 1998. In addition, the lobbying regulator should, subject to a public interest test, have the power to direct an agency to make public any document or record concerning lobbying communications. 

R 6 That all public sector agencies subject to the LOGO Act be required to adopt policies and procedures that conform to minimum established standards issued by the lobbying regulator. 

R 7 That all professional lobbyists (third-party lobbyists and in-house lobbyists) be required to register with the lobbying regulator and make entries into the NSW Lobbyists Register. 

Exemptions for organisations that are small or lobby infrequently should apply (based on the Scottish or Canadian systems). As is currently the case with third-party lobbyists, all lobbyists should:

  • provide relevant details about their organisation and staff that engage in lobbying activities 

  • complete mandatory training 

  • disclose if they represent a foreign principal 

  • file statutory declarations with the lobbying regulator. 

R 8 That all regulated lobbyists on the Lobbyists Register should disclose:

  • date and location where face-to-face lobbying communications took place 

  • the name and role of the government official(s) being lobbied 

  • a description of their lobbying communications 

  • a description of the purpose and intended outcome of their lobbying communications 

  • whether lobbying was undertaken on behalf of another party.

Exemptions, similar to those in Scotland and Ireland, should be introduced. 

R 9 That lobbyists should file information electronically that is then automatically published on the Lobbyists Register. 

The register should allow any person to alert the lobbying regulator of any information that is considered missing or inaccurate. 

R 10 That the lobbying regulator should have powers to determine whether a person or entity is required to register and whether the information required for the Lobbyists Register is accurate and up-to-date. 

This could include issuing information notices and making use of the Lobbyists Watch List. Failure to register may require the lobbying regulator to provide an adequate opportunity to comply, as there is with third-party lobbyists. 

R 11 That, in order to reduce the administrative burden, lobbyists required to be registered in NSW should be permitted to provide or rely on registration documentation filed with other jurisdictions, such as a jurisdiction under the Commonwealth. 

This could include relevant statutory declarations made in order to satisfy fit and proper person requirements. 

R 12 That the diary and overseas travel information of ministers and parliamentary secretaries should be published:

  • monthly, not quarterly 

  • in a single, searchable document or database formatted for easy access to enable public scrutiny 

  • displaying each minister’s name against his/her portfolio. 

R 13 That the NSW Government creates a pre-set menu of options that must be used to indicate the purpose of each meeting disclosed in the diary summaries of ministers. 

These options could be based on the categories of lobbying set out in s 4(1) of the LOGO Act or another classification that adequately covers the types of disclosable meetings held by ministers. The individual ministers ultimately should be responsible for supplementing the indicated entry by adding a clear description of the specific purpose of the meeting. 

R 14 That the LOGO Act be amended to improve oversight of post-separation employment provisions by providing that the lobbying regulator may require any relevant former public official during the cooling-off period, who has a role in an organisation that employs lobbyists (whether or not a lobbyist themselves), to provide it with information concerning:

a) the terms and conditions of any employment or engagements undertaken by former public officials in the cooling-off period 

b) the nature of any employment or engagement referred to in (a) 

c) whether any employment or engagement undertaken in the cooling-off period has or does involve information obtained during his/her period as a public official 

d) whether any employment or engagement undertaken in the cooling-off period involves or relates to any former portfolio functions or responsibilities pertaining to his/her former position as a public official. 

R 15 That the LOGO Act be amended to restrict ministerial and parliamentary secretary advisers of sufficient seniority from engaging in any lobbying activity relating to any matter that they had official dealings with in their last 12 months in office, for a period of 12 months after leaving office, except with the approval of the lobbying regulator. 

Based on criteria published by the lobbying regulator, the restriction period could be removed, modified or made subject to conditions. 

R 16 That the LOGO Act be amended to mirror the provisions of s 16 of the Gaming and Liquor Administration Act 2007. 

This would provide secretaries and agency heads with authority to designate high-risk roles and associated “key officials” where appropriate. Officials in such roles would be subject to a six-month restriction on employment in certain areas related to their public duties. Based on criteria published by the lobbying regulator, the restriction period could be removed, modified or made subject to conditions. 

R 17 That, in the absence of any other new measures to reduce the risks associated with lobbying by former public officials, the LOGO Act be amended to introduce a “Former Public Officials” list, to be managed by the lobbying regulator. 

For a period of four years after leaving office, all former public officials involved in lobbying activities would be required to ensure they are named on this list, including those working for third-party lobbyists. 

R 18 That the NSW Government: 

  • creates a dedicated NSW lobbying commissioner whose primary purpose is to regulate the LOGO Act. The lobbying commissioner could head a standalone lobbying commission, or serve within an existing oversight agency 

  • provides the lobbying regulator with additional resources and powers to carry out the expanded functions set out in this report. 

19 That the role of the lobbying regulator be clarified by creating clear legislative provisions that allow it to:

  • oversee the conduct of both public officials and lobbyists under the “Lobbying Code of Conduct” and LOGO Act, including the criminal, administrative and ethical aspects of the regulation 

  • establish formal processes for accepting complaints and referrals in relation to lobbying matters 

  • have powers with respect to auditing compliance 

  • investigate suspected breaches (including of its own initiative) and make referrals for further investigation or sanction (if required) 

  • publish and disseminate any relevant findings 

  • have an advice-giving and standard-setting function. 

R 20 That the LOGO Act be amended to give the lobbying regulator responsibility for setting the conditions of the Lobbyists Watch List. 

R 21 That the requirement for ministers and parliamentary secretaries to publish summaries from their diaries should be set out in the regulation to the LOGO Act rather than a Premier’s Memorandum. 

The lobbying regulator should be responsible for compliance. 

R 22 That the NSW Government gives the lobbying regulator power to investigate and report on indirect lobbying that involves alleged unlawful and/or dishonest conduct. 

R 23 That the NSW Parliament ensures that induction training for new members of Parliament is extended to existing members and addresses the administrative and ethical requirements of public officials in relation to lobbying. Such training should also be mandatory for parliamentary and ministerial staff. 

R 24 That the Lobbyists Code of Conduct be amended to prohibit lobbyists (as defined in the LOGO Act) from offering, promising or giving gifts or other benefits to a public official who is, has been, or is likely to be lobbied. 

R 25 That any fundraising event, where an attendee pays for any form of exclusive or private access to a minister, should be classified as a “scheduled meeting” for the purposes of Premier’s Memorandum M2015-05 and consequently be disclosed in published summaries of ministerial diaries – along with the fact that it was paid access. This information should be published irrespective of whether any lobbying takes place. 

R 26 That clause 13 of the Lobbyists Code of Conduct applies to all classes of lobbyist. However, this should not prevent members and supporters of a political party from lobbying in relation to policy issues. 

R 27 That the prohibition on paid advocacy – as outlined in clause 2(a) of the Members’ Code of Conduct (Legislative Assembly) and the Members’ Code of Conduct (Legislative Council) – be extended beyond the promotion of matters in the NSW Parliament or its committees, to any communication with any other public officials, and that clause 7A of the Constitution (Disclosure by Members) Regulation 1983 (relating to disclosure) be amended accordingly. 

R 28 That the NSW Government establishes a “Lobbying Reform Panel” comprising appropriately qualified persons to examine and formulate proposed legislative reforms. Appropriate secretariat services for the panel should be provided. 

R 29 That, over a 12-month period, the “Lobbying Reform Panel” undertakes the required work under recommendation 28 and, by the end of the 12-month period, the panel provides a report setting out the provisions it recommends be incorporated into revised legislation. .

Identification

'From Knowing by Name to Personalisation: Meaning of Identification Under the GDPR' by Nadezhda Purtova comments 

Despite its core role in the EU system of data protection, the meaning of identification remains unclear in the data protection law and scholarship with a spotlight focused on the legally relevant chance of identification, i.e. identifiability. 

While Article 29 Working Party interpreted identification broadly, as distinguishing one in a group, this interpretation has been questioned in light of the EUCJ decision in Breyer. This paper tackles this uncertainty. 

This paper offers an integrated socio-technical typology of identification where, in addition to the known identification types (look-up-, recognition-, session- and classification identification), personalisation is added as a new identification type, meaning a relatively unique characterisation where one is individualized by being mapped in relation to multiple dimensions within a multidimensional space. 

The paper clarifies the legal meaning of identification under the GDPR. It proposes a contextual interpretation of Breyer, which negates Breyer’s restrictive potential and brings all identification types within the GDPR. 

The paper concludes with a discussion of the implications of this reading of identification for data protection in terms the applicability of the GDPR to new data technologies and practices such as facial detection and non-tracking based targeted advertising, effects of certain privacy preserving technologies such as federated learning of cohorts, consequences for invoking data protection rights when identification is not possible, but also in terms of the need to clearly define the objectives of the data protection law.

25 June 2021

Clouds

'Privacy in the Clouds, Revisited: An Analysis of the Privacy Policies of 40 Cloud Computing Services' (Queen Mary Law Research Paper No. 354/2021) by Felicity Turton, Dimitra Kamarinou, Johan David Michels and Christopher Millard comments 

In this paper, we analyse the results of a detailed survey of the privacy policies, and data protection terms more broadly, of 40 major cloud computing services, including Amazon Web Services, Google Cloud, and Microsoft Azure. We review terms relating to controller and processor designations; purposes and legal bases for data processing; individuals’ rights of access, rectification, and erasure of personal data; the right to data portability; security and data breach notification; monitoring; transfers of personal data outside of the EEA; and appointment of a Data Protection Officer. Where relevant, we compare the results to those of previous surveys conducted in 2010, 2013, and 2015 to show how cloud privacy policies have developed over time, including changes that appear to have been made in response to the General Data Protection Regulation. 

 'Contracts for Clouds, Revisited: An Analysis of the Standard Contracts for 40 Cloud Computing Services' by Michels, Millard and Turton offered a related survey of the standard contracts of 40 cloud services: 

In this paper, we report the results of a detailed survey of the standard contracts for 40 major cloud computing services, including Amazon Web Services, Google Cloud, and Microsoft Azure. We cover a broad range of contractual issues, including clauses dealing with choice of law, termination, data retention, liability, and intellectual property. We compare the results to those of previous surveys conducted in 2010, 2013, and 2015 to show how cloud contracts have developed over time. In particular, we identify changes with regard to choice of law and of forum, and warranty and liability provisions. We conclude that over the past ten years, standard cloud contracts have become more tailored to customer location, for instance by having distinct terms for US and European customers, and more in line with European consumer protection law, including by having distinct terms for businesses and consumers.

24 June 2021

Privacy

'The New Privacy Law' by Ari Ezra Waldman in (2021) 55 UC Davis Law Review comments 

We are in a second wave of privacy law. The first wave was characterized by privacy policies, self-regulation, and notice and choice. But in the last three years, nine proposals for comprehensive privacy legislation have been introduced in the United States Congress and 42 have been introduced in the states. From the perspective of practice, almost all of these proposals are roughly the same – they require individuals to exercise control rights and rely on internal corporate compliance for ongoing monitoring. This second wave of privacy law is undoubtedly different from the first, but how? This essay provides a new taxonomy to understand changes in US privacy law, distinguishing between two ‘waves’ along three metrics: their practices, theories of governance, and underlying ideologies. A first wave was characterized by privacy policies, self-regulation, and limited regulatory enforcement. Its practices were focused on notice, its governance was self-regulatory, and its ideology was laissez faire. A second wave almost uniformly relies on internal corporate compliance structures to manage data collection, processing, and use. Its practices are focused on compliance, its governance is managerial, and its underlying ideology is neoliberal. This taxonomy offers privacy law scholars a new way to understand and critique the current state of the field. The essay concludes with four research questions for scholars to pursue.

In Western Australia, following statutes in the ACT, Victoria and elsewhere (and Kathleen Clubb v Alyce Edwards and Anor; John Graham Preston v Elizabeth Avery and Anor [2019] HCA 11 noted here), the Attorney-General has introduced the Public Health Amendment (Safe Access Zones) Bill 2021 (WA) which amends the Public Health Act 2016 (WA) to 

create safe access zones around premises at which abortions are provided. These zones will ensure that those who want to access abortion services can do so in a safe and private manner. The Bill also prohibits publication and distribution of certain recordings to protect the privacy and dignity of those who access abortion services.