05 December 2009

Asylum-seeker biometrics

A we head towards Christmas it is 'slow news season', evident in an announcement by The Age of 'Biometric tests for asylum seekers'.
A scheme to gather biometric data from asylum seekers is being introduced in an effort to crack down on fraud and help identify those with overseas criminal records.

Starting this week asylum seekers in Melbourne and Sydney are being asked to provide an image of their face and a scan of their fingerprints as part of a six-month voluntary trial. The data will be checked against records in the United States, Britain, Canada and New Zealand in a search for multiple identities and criminal backgrounds.

The scheme has been criticised by refugee and privacy advocates.
The defences and criticisms use the trusty Casablanca Model (ie "round up the usual suspects").

David Vaile of the Australian Privacy Foundation is quoted as worrying about the potential for biometric data to fall into the wrong hands when it is sent overseas: "The people who are implementing it are basically outsourcing the risks to the data subjects while retaining the benefits for themselves". Quite; that's usually what offshoring is about.

Refugee advocate Pamela Curr of the Asylum Seeker Resource Centre is reported as attacking the program, saying - to use the Age's phrase - that "overwhelmingly people who arrived in Australia were honest in identifying themselves and posed no security risk".

Immigration minister Chris Evans claims that "This initiative will improve our current processes for identity-checking and assessing people's claims for protection under the Refugees Convention". Use of biometrics has "already yielded results": "in one case, a fingerprint match revealed an asylum seeker was known by several different names in another country, and had numerous criminal convictions".

There's more subtlety and more bite in Blackstone's Guide to The Identity Cards Act 2006 (Oxford: Oxford Uni Press 2006) by John Wadham, Caoifhionn Gallagher & Nichole Chrolavicius, which I'm reading at the moment after returning from the law conference in Brisbane.

Interventions

The Australian Institute of Criminology (AIC) has released an 86 page Technical & Background Paper(PDF) by Colleen Bryant & Matthew Willis on Pornography awareness: A process of engagement with Northern Territory Indigenous communities.

The Paper reports on a review by the AIC for the Northern Territory Justice department of the latter's 'campaign strategy' regarding a "media classification awareness and education campaign for Indigenous communities". The campaign dates from 2007, following strong expressions of concern regarding sexual abuse of children in Indigenous communities within the Territory, the exposure of Indigenous children to adult content and suggestions that there were links between consumption of pornography and sexual abuse of children. The Justice Department undertook a series of "consultations", in particular with Indigenous men, that were envisaged as providing -
input into the messages to be delivered through the campaign, the appropriate target audiences, critical success factors, risks and sensitivities, and the development of a communications strategy.
The campaign? It featured "workshops, flipcharts and facilitated discussions" - fortunately people seem to have resisted lingo such as "iterative discourse" - to communicate three key messages to Indigenous communities -
• It is important to know and understand the classification system that operates in Australia for film and literature and responsibilities under that system.
• It is illegal for persons under 18 years to have access to or view any R18+ or X18+ rated film or printed material that has a restricted classification and there are penalties for illegal access. This material is considered harmful for people under the age of 18 years.
• X18+ rated material and Category 1 and Category 2 Restricted publications are banned in proscribed communities (as declared by the Federal Minister for Family & Community Services).
Workshops also sought to raise parental awareness of responsibility to protect children from exposure to pornography, "empower participants to enact these responsibilities through information and awareness", provide an opportunity for discussion of "issues regarding access to pornography and its potential harms, including problematic sexual behaviours that might occur in communities as a result of children’s exposure to pornography" and share strategies regarding exposure of children to adult content.

When read between the lines the Paper is deeply depressing. The authors note that its principal purpose is -
to examine the process through which NT Justice developed the education campaign, engaged with Indigenous communities and to consider whether the campaign had the capacity to meet its objectives and was in accordance with existing good practice guidelines. The review does not evaluate the effectiveness of the program to achieve educational outcomes, or attempt to explain if this program has contributed to behavioural changes with respect to the regulation of pornography or other sexual behaviours. Rather it provides an opportunity to examine how an education campaign might be developed and delivered in the context of remote Indigenous communities and how future community-oriented campaigns might benefit from the NT Justice experience.
Changing behaviour in Indigenous communities will be more difficult than appraising NT Justice's methodology for creation of an education campaign.

We make money the old-fashioned way

The BBC site reports another example of people making money the old-fashioned (ie DIY) way.

"Thousands of pounds" - actually not that many - "of fake £1 coins were uncovered at a counterfeiting factory during a raid on a farm in Kent", with "coin-making paraphernalia" being found hidden in a concealed room behind wooden panelling at Tonge Corner Farm, Tonge. The "concealed room" - one wonders whether concealment was more elaborate than a cupboard pushed in front of a door - is a nice change from the colour photocopier in the attic, coin press in the basement or stencil on the kitchen table.

Alleged coiners Michael Silk (70) and brother-in-law Paul Bart (65) are reported as denying production of "fake coins"; Silk's son Stephen (49) has pleaded guilty to the charge of counterfeiting and having counterfeiting materials. The elder Silk and Bart also deny having counterfeiting materials (including a hydraulic machine press) and possessing counterfeit coins with a view to distributing them as genuine.

Thinking about Australian and UK law regarding counterfeiting has taken me back to cases such as R v Kokkinos [1998] VSC 351; [1998] VICSC 131, R v Institoris [2002] NSWCCA 8, Williams v R (No 1) [1933] HCA 54; (1933) 50 CLR 536, the Crimes (Currency) Act 1981 (Cth) and the 1929 International Convention for the Suppression of Counterfeiting Currency.

The latter was signed for no less than -
His Majesty the King of Albania; the President of the German Reich; the President of the United States of America; the Federal President of the Austrian Republic; His Majesty the King of the Belgians; His Majesty the King of Great Britain, Ireland and the British Dominions beyond the Seas, Emperor of India; His Majesty the King of the Bulgarians; the President of the National Government of the Republic of China; the President of the Colombian Republic; the President of the Republic of Cuba; His Majesty the King of Denmark; the President of the Polish Republic, for the Free City of Danzig; His Majesty the King of Spain; the President of the French Republic; the President of the Hellenic Republic; His Serene Highness the Regent of the Kingdom of Hungary; His Majesty the King of Italy; His Majesty the Emperor of Japan; Her Royal Highness the Grand Duchess of Luxemburg; His Serene Highness the Prince of Monaco; His Majesty the King of Norway; the President of the Republic of Panama; Her Majesty the Queen of the Netherlands; the President of the Polish Republic; the President of the Portuguese Republic; His Majesty the King of Roumania; His Majesty the King of the Serbs, Croats and Slovenes; the Central Executive Committee of the Union of the Soviet Socialist Republics; the Swiss Federal Council; the President of the Czechoslovak Republic
His Serene Highness the Regent of the Kingdom of Hungary? The King of Albania? Thou thy worldly task hast done, Home art gone, and ta'en thy wages; Golden lads and girls all must, As chimney-sweepers, come to dust.

The Act, as one might expect after several centuries of state preoccupation, is polished and systematic. Section 6 provides that "A person shall not make, or begin to make, counterfeit money or a counterfeit prescribed security" (Penalty: imprisonment for 14 years). Knowingly uttering counterfeit money attracts a penalty of 12 years (s 7); possessing counterfeit money without a reasonable excuse attracts a penalty of 10 years (s 9).

Section 11 provides that a person shall not make or mend, or begin or prepare to make or mend; buy, sell, receive or dispose of, or offer to buy, sell, procure or dispose of; or have in his or her possession; a machine, engine, tool, plate, die or other instrument that, to his or her knowledge, has been used, has been adapted for use, or is intended for use, in, or in connection with, the making of counterfeit money.

R v Bradley [1935] HCA 72; (1935) 54 CLR 12 - also chimneysweep territory - notes that
Since the passing of 5 & 6 Vict. c. 38, which first excluded from the jurisdiction of Courts of Quarter Sessions offences against the Sovereign's title, prerogative, person or government, or against either House of Parliament, it appears to have been taken for granted that coinage offences were triable at Quarter Sessions, subject to any particular exclusion depending upon the nature of the penalty imposed. It may be conceded that the nature of the power to coin money, as well as the history of coinage offences, gives ground for the contention that they are all offences against the prerogative in this sense that, although offences provided by statute, the statutory provisions creating them are designed to protect the prerogative.

To coin money and use it as currency was an exercise of the prerogative power of the Crown. From early times the making of counterfeit money was considered treason at common law. Such offences were regarded, "not as mere frauds fraught with grave harm to the community, but also and chiefly as the invasion of a specially royal right which our Kings had jealously guarded, and any tampering with the King's image and superscription on seal or coin was assimilated to an attack upon his person" (Pollock and Maitland, History of English Law (1895), vol. 2, p. 503). Counterfeiting the King's money was expressly included in the statute of Edward III., 25 Edw. III., stat. 5, c. 2.
Fortunately we've moved on from Edward Rex and don't chop off the hands of coiners or pour boiling lead down their throats.

Parental Intellectual Disability

'Parental Intellectual Disability and Child Protection' (Issues Paper 31, Australian Institute of Family Studies) by Alister Lamont & Leah Bromfield considers parental intellectual disability and the common risk factors associated with child abuse and neglect in order to understand if and why parents with intellectual disability are at heightened risk of abusing or neglecting their children.

The authors note that parents with intellectual disabilities (aka "mental retardation", "developmental disabilities", "learning disabilities" and "learning difficulties") represent 1-2% of all parents in Australia. However, they are over-represented in child protection and legal proceedings, with parental intellectual disability a characteristic in 12.5% of cases reviewed by the Victorian Child Death Review Committee in 2007-08 and Victorian child protection cases in which a parent had an intellectual disability being "almost twice as likely to be substantiated, and more than three times more likely to be re-substantiated than cases where parents did not have an intellectual disability". A 2000 review of 285 court files in two children's courts in New South Wales found that 8.8% of cases featured a parent with an intellectual disability. That over-representation is evident in other jurisdictions, with a UK study in 2000 for example finding that 15.1% of child protection cases before two English family courts featured a parent with learning difficulties.

Research suggests factors contributing to over-representation of parents with intellectual disability in child protection include discrimination, prejudice and a lack of support services.

The Lamont & Bromfield paper discusses key issues associated with parental intellectual disability and child protection, including definitions of intellectual disability; whether there is a link between parental competence and intellectual disability; risk factors for abuse and neglect (and whether or not parents with an intellectual disability experience higher rates of these problems); and the role of support services in assisting parents with intellectual disability.

Mythologies

'Rape mythology and the criminal justice system', a new study by Jessica Kennedy, Patricia Easteal & Caroline Taylor examines sexual assault sentencing and judicial comments from a sample of judgments in Victoria (mostly in 2008).

It explores differences in sentencing, focusing on the relationship between the perpetrator and the victim. The analysis suggests that although judges are demonstrating a better understanding of the reality of sexual assault in their discussion of mitigating and aggravating variables, that awareness is not translating into sentences.

That research is significant because although there has been substantial reform to Victorian sexual assault law and legal processes, the only way to ensure the reform is as effective and progressive as claimed is to test implementation through an empirical analysis.

The authors conclude that -
This study provides preliminary support for previous findings that show a relationship between dominant negative stereotypes and sentencing that is a consequence of the process and decision-making behind sentencing that is subject to judicial discretion. This relationship is further compounded by research that suggests judges are subject to influence by rape and sexual assault mythology. This study considered a small sample with preliminary analyses to test if the relationship between the offender and victim appears to affect sentencing. While it is evident that judges have an increased awareness of the severe and enduring effects of rape by a known assailant, they remain reluctant to apply this to sentencing, resulting in sentences that contradict accompanying judicial commentary. As predicted, longer sentences are given where the offender is unknown to the victim and where some level of violence accompanies the rape. While a prior sexual relationship between victim and offender is no longer viewed as a mitigating variable in sentencing, neither is relationship seen to aggravate the crime. Further, while breach of trust appears to be given significant weight when sentencing cases of intrafamilial sexual assault, it is not applied in incidents of partner or ex-partner rape.

... While judges may articulate an increased awareness of the effects of various types of sexual assault, and acknowledge aggravating factors such as breach of trust, this awareness is either not translating into sentences or it is being balanced by the emphasis of other mitigating factors.
Note that the author of this blog is a colleague of Dr Easteal and Ms Kennedy.

The Commonwealth has meanwhile released reports regarding the 'National Community Attitudes towards Violence against Women Survey 2009'.

The reports include findings regarding community attitudes towards violence against women, notably
+ perceptions of what constitutes domestic violence, sexual violence and sexual harassment;
+ the relationship between attitudes towards violence against women and attitudes towards gender equality;
+ understanding of the consequences and harms caused by violence;
+ beliefs regarding whether violence against women is justifiable or excusable;
+ myths and beliefs about victims and offenders;
+ and awareness of community education and the impact of campaign advertising.

22 November 2009

Contraband

A recurrent question in intellectual property tutorials is how many bogus items - brand-name clothes, perfume, CDs, bling - get into Australia.

It was thus interesting to see a media release from the Minister for Home Affairs boasting that Customs & Border Protection officers in Fremantle "stopped more than 10,000 counterfeit Tiffany and Company items from reaching the local market and being sold to unsuspecting consumers." Alas, no pictures of the very cute Customs dogs sniffing at the suspect containers and being rewarded with a treat for their excellent work.

The Minister commented that -
It is vital that we stop these goods at the border as they threaten the profitability and reputation of legitimate businesses and are potentially a risk to consumer safety.

Tiffany & Company is a prestigious company and Customs & Border Protection's work in stopping these counterfeit goods ensures there is no negative impact on the famous Tiffany brand.
Ministerial experience of the Holly Golightlys aside, the mechanics of the bust are more engaging.

It appears that the goods were originally referred to Customs and Border Protection on 3 August by the air freight forwarder who thought the consignment, made up of eight boxes, was "suspiciously labelled". The nature of that labelling or the origin of the boxes (China, Vietnam, south of the border down Mexico way?) has not been revealed.

A second shipment of one box was stopped and examined by Customs and Border Protection Compliance Assurance officers on 5 August 2009.

Both consignments were confirmed by Compliance Assurance officers as containing thousands of counterfeit Tiffany products along with associated packaging and care instructions. ("The attention to detail in the packaging makes it especially difficult for consumers to spot a fake.") The goods were formally seized and Tiffany was notified.

Some "10,778 counterfeit items (jewellery and packaging)" were seized, including 476 necklaces, 597 bracelets and 177 rings.

Subsequent investigation by Compliance Assurance officers has identified the supplier of the goods and a website used by the importers to "sell them on a commercial basis".

Holograms, hocus pocus and humbugs

Looking at another instance of recurrent re-invention in Victoria, where former plumber Peter de Angelis became Sioux Lakota Indian shaman Thunder Eagle and then Shamir Shalom. As the Age rather naughtily commented, he -
is not a shaman. He's not even American, native Indian or otherwise ...
and he's in trouble over alleged inappropriate sexual contact with up to six women who paid him several thousand dollars for healing services.

Victorian Health Services Commissioner (HSC) Beth Wilson appears to have been unimpressed, consistent with reporting by the Age that in one "ritual" last year - presumably as part of sessions that included "smoking ceremonies, chanting, drumming and tantric dance" - the ingenious Mr de Angelis (later known as Shamir Narra Avorham Djuwani Kiefa Israel Marlon Wati Dakota Jessie Malakhi-Zion-Angel-Shalom) pressed his body against a client to "absorb the toxins". Uh huh.

Things moved on to the Supreme Court, where Kaye J in Shalom v Health Services Commissioner [2009] VSC 514 found in favour of Wilson.

Shalom had sought an injunction to restrain the Commissioner from presenting the Victorian Parliament with a report naming him, pursuant to subsection 11(5) of the Health Services (Conciliation and Review) Act 1987 (Vic). He had also sought a declaration that his naming through that report is ultra vires.

Subsection 11(2) of the Act offers a 'naming & shaming' mechanism. It provides that the Commissioner may report in the public interest, a provision that enables community awareness of the practice of someone who is providing health services. A report made by the Commissioner under subsection 11(5) may name a person if –
the Commissioner believes on reasonable grounds that naming the person is reasonably necessary to prevent or lessen the risk of a serious threat to –
(i) the life, health, safety or welfare of any person; or
(ii) the health, safety or welfare of the public.
The Court noted that the plaintiff advertised as "Shaman Psychic Spiritualist, Healer, Counsellor" and described himself to his clients as "Shamir Zion Thunder Eagle", claiming to clients that "he was a North American Indian by birth, and that he was an American Indian Shaman Initiate".

The Commissioner alleged that de Angelis/Eagle/Shalom "had acted unreasonably in the manner of providing health services": he had "falsely represented himself as a North American Shaman healer" and in the course of treatment had "breached professional boundaries, by initiating sexual relationships". He responded through two fax messages, denying that he was a health service provider (ie the Commissioner lacked jurisdiction to investigate him). The Commissioner indicated that she did indeed have jurisdiction, because each of the complainants had consulted him for the purpose of healing, his advertisements described him as a "healer" and "counsellor", and his registered business name stated that the nature of his business was "Educative and Healing".

The draft report from her consequent investigation featured three recommendations: that he undergo a psychiatric assessment, only practise in the field of Shamanic Education and Healing in accordance with the Practice Code of Ethics developed by the Australian Shamanic Practitioners Association, and revise his advertising material so as to only make claims regarding his cultural background and qualifications which could be supported by documentary evidence.

Correspondence moved backwards and forwards. The Commissioner noted that his suggestion of a "short course" in Shamanism was inadequate to enable him to comply with the practice code. The plaintiff indicated that he intended to continue to practise in activities which he considered to be outside the Commissioner's jurisdiction, such as teaching meditation. The Commissioner advised that he should not practise at all until he was qualified, and that if he did not comply with the recommendations contained in the report he would be named. The Commissioner appears be underwhelmed by a comment from Mr Shalom that he was now acting as a "psychic detective" rather than a health service provider.

The Court found that Shalom was covered by the Act and that the Commissioner had not denied him natural justice. She is thus in a position to name him in Parliament. The proceedings were open to the public and we are now able to read about "karmic consciousness" and other treats. A more rigorous regime might quarantine "Shamanic Education and Healing" in the entertainment sector, along with tea-leaf reading and scrutiny of chicken entrails. (Reports that Shalom told one of the complainants that he loved her and had been her husband and wife in a past life, that he asked clients to drink their own urine as part of a purification ritual, offered to cure breast cancer by sucking out the "serpents" and danced naked in front of them are surely just made for late night television.)

The Age offers other examples of hocus pocus, including reports that the Australian Competition & Consumer Commission has formally warned vendors of a $400 vibration treatment claimed to cure swine flu with a 100% success rate (apparently even if the healer and client lived on opposite sides of the world). One practitioner offers "quantum bioenergetic balancing", apparently useful for treating cancer, depression, chronic fatigue, cerebral palsy and autism. No indication, alas, of whether it cures mange in cats, keeps the rabbits and possums away from your carrots or will get you a HD in the Legal Systems exam. The Age notes that -
While Ms Hocking does not claim to cure people, she said she had seen a wheelchair-bound multiple sclerosis sufferer walk again and a deaf three-year-old hear after receiving her treatment. "What we do is we put them in the environment where the system actually heals itself ... There's an elevation in the cellular vibration which causes the DNA to communicate more clearly" she said.
Another provider of what is advertised as "health services" deals with flu viruses. For a mere $400 a hologram is "placed in one's psyche" -
If the virus is already established Virus Buster will knock it out in 24 – 48 hrs. If you do not have a virus then the Virus Buster Session will provide you with optimal protection from most flu viruses. ...

All of our sessions can be achieved successfully and with 100% accuracy without needing to come to our Practice. We have the ability to energetically connect with your loved one ANYWHERE IN THE WORLD and fully transfer the vibrational energies of the session to them without them needing to come to us.
Quite.

What do you need to become a shaman? Ignoring paraphernalia such as knucklebone of rat, feather of crow, and crystals of chutzpah, there's the Shamanic Practice Code of Ethics.

In identifying training and qualification requirements it indicates that -
1. It is expected that shamanic practitioners will have received essential training in core practices through their participation in and graduation from an appropriate training regime;

2.Appropriate training regimes are as follows:
1. A formal training course at the diploma, advanced diploma, or degree level in shamanic practice, or

2. A traditional form of apprenticeship to a shaman in an indigenous culture or a form of cultural-spiritual practice which is socially recognised and legitimised [e.g., Condomble in Brazil, or Vodun in West Africa or Haiti] and of at least three years in duration and 1500 hours of training contact.

3. The training shall have covered a range of healing methods which includes one-on-one, group, family and community modalities over at least 100 hours of practical work.

4. The training must be adequately documented.

5. The training program must have covered, in detail, aspects of ethico-legal dimensions of practice, articulation with other healing professions, professional insurances, and relevant state and federal legislation which applies to helping professions.
I particularly like item 3 of the Association's professional conduct code -
Integrity: SP's should not offer services for which they are not qualified to deliver. They should act with honesty, without deception, and not use any form of persuasion or undue influence in securing and delivering services. The services which SP's deliver should be of a kind which preserve the dignity and autonomy of the client and in no way sully the privacy, physical, sexual, financial or psychological integrity of the client. Communication about SP sessions should be clear and concise and offer clients an adequate description of what SP sessions involve and especially with respect to details of techniques used, possible effects [focal and side effects] and professional fees.
That pretty much cuts out anything other than entertainment and general feelgood stuff.

Item 6 in the code specifies that
Parameters of competence: SP's may not diagnose medically or psychologically nor prescribe medications or supplements, nor shall they engage in physical manipulation of the body unless they are appropriately qualified and registered with relevant professional Associations [e.g., the Medical Board and Psychologists' Board in each state, Naturopathic Association, Physiotherapists Board]. SP's should be prepared to show clients copies of their qualifications and training if required by clients, as a matter of establishing bona fides. In this respect, SP's shall not make any misleading or dishonest statements concerning their training, qualifications and abilities to heal or effect therapeutic changes verbally or in writing.
Taken strictly, they can't say much at all ... but presumably that doesn't deter many consumers, especially those whose scepticism isn't associated with perusal of studies such as The Beauty of the Primitive: Shamanism and Western Imagination (Oxford: Oxford University Press 2007) by Andrei Znamenski, a sobering account of cultural appropriation and flimflam.