05 September 2025

Flameout

In Hepburn SC v Coward [2025] VCAT 784 the Tribunal - following up Hepburn SC v Coward [2024] VCAT 517 - states 

Maureen Coward alleges that the Tribunal has no jurisdiction over her to hear and determine a prosecution for contempt because: 

She contends that the State of Victoria, VCAT and the Hepburn Shire Council are the incorrect jurisdictions – see her submissions para 219 – 223; 

She submits that she has the right to correct due process and jurisdiction – see her submissions para 224 – 225; 

She submits that correct due process and jurisdiction – over what she calls ‘subjects of the Imperial crown’ accused of a crime – is governed by Imperial Law including all Imperial Acts, including the Commonwealth of Australia Constitution and Bill of Rights 1688 – see her submissions para 229 – 238; and 

She submits that the Authority of Australian Governments is subject to the right to self-determination of whom she calls ‘the people’ who, she says, are ‘known in the title of the United Kingdom of Australia’ represented in title by the ‘Australian Privy Council’ and in title by the ‘Most Noble Order of the Desert Flame’ – see her submissions para 116 – 210. ... 

In short, Maureen Coward submits she is not an Australian subject, that Victorian law does not apply (or that it does not apply to her), and that the State of Victoria, the Tribunal and the Shire have no jurisdiction over her for various reasons. 

Maureen Coward also asserts that ‘all courts, police and government departments of every state who are now incorporated under ABN numbers’ are somehow invalid. She also asserts that their ‘acts statutes rules and regulations are governed by the Australia Act 1986’ which she says is somehow invalid. She also asserts she is being ‘coerced to joinder into a contract with the Hepburn Shire Council’ which she alleges has an ABN and she says is trying to extort who she calls ‘the people’ on trespass without following the ‘proper line of authority against we the people’. 

She says she does not wish to partake in or against her ancestors’ lineage, or she says ‘take part in the foreign occupied administration government the State of Victoria’ which she alleges (along with the Treasury Corporation of Victoria) are both registered to the US SEC and that she does not have any contracts with what she calls these ‘entity corporations’. Maureen Coward, in an email to the Tribunal dated 17 May 2024, stated that the proceeding should be taken to a ‘higher court either county court or the high court’.

In response the Tribunal comments 

... the legal issue for determination at this Preliminary Hearing is whether the Tribunal has jurisdiction to hear and determine an application for contempt of the Tribunal. 

It clearly does. 

Mrs Coward’s written and oral submissions are incorrect and misguided and have no foundation in law. She candidly states in her written submissions that she is ‘a little familiar with the legal world’. If her submissions have been prepared by her, she is legally mistaken. 

Section 137 of the VCAT Act confers statutory jurisdiction on VCAT to hear and determine a prosecution for contempt of the Tribunal. That jurisdiction is well established by law. 

It is also well established that the categories of contempt include where there has been non-compliance with an order made by VCAT: see s 137(1)(ea). 

The Court of Appeal has expressly held that VCAT has the jurisdiction under s 137 of the VCAT Act to deal with contempt in accordance with that statutory provision. The power to deal with contempt extends to punishing the disobedience of an order of the Tribunal and to enforce compliance with it, including by issuing a fine or imposing a sentence of imprisonment. 

Accordingly, Maureen Coward – being the person against whom the Tribunal has made its Enforcement Orders – is bound by those orders and the Tribunal has undoubted contempt jurisdiction over her. 

Maureen Coward’s arguments are what have been categorised in decisions of superior courts in Australia and overseas as belonging to a collection of erroneous beliefs or arguments sometimes called ‘pseudo-legal commercial arguments’. Such arguments have been rejected in common law courts and legal systems around the world as having no legal foundation. 

Maureen Coward referred to various irrelevant Australian court decisions in support of her arguments and an out-of-context discussion in a transcript of hearing from a case before another court in another Australian state. 

There is no legal basis for any contention in this case for Mrs Coward to assert that the laws of the Victorian Parliament do not apply to her and bind her. I also accept the Council’s submission that there is no inconsistency between s 137 of the VCAT Act and any Commonwealth law. 

Maureen Coward is a person who, like all ordinary human beings, in accordance with the rule of law is amenable to and answerable to the laws applicable to ordinary persons. She is equal under the law, not exceptional. 

Maureen Coward’s assertion of some citizen or other status giving her immunity from the law is legally flawed. The rights, freedoms and privileges people enjoy with others in society also carry responsibility to adhere to its laws, and the legal obligations they place on people, whether or not a person believes they do. Society’s laws apply to people who may or may not be citizens and apply with equal effect whether or not a person believes they are a citizen or subject to the law. 

Maureen Coward’s assertions of invalidity about Victorian law, and her assertions about orders of the Tribunal or actions of the Shire Council in seeking to enforce the Enforcement Order against her as somehow being invalid or somehow not applying to her, are also erroneous and have no legal foundation. 

Her arguments amount to legal nonsense and are incapable of coherent legal argument.

The Tribunal in its commendably clear 2014 decision explained

... private ownership rights need to be considered in the situation where (as part of having a functioning and workable community) we can all own certain things, but still need to comply with relevant laws and regulations prescribing how each such thing is used. 

To use two simple examples: A person who owns a plane still needs to fly the plane in accordance with extensive Federal aviation safety laws and regulations. Without this ‘safety regime’, it would become inherently unsafe for any of us to travel by air. 

To promote safer driving on our Victorian roads, a person who owns a car is legally required by State laws to wear a seat belt and only drive a road-registered car. Hence whether you own a car or are hiring one, either way, there are some real restrictions to how the car must be used on public roads. Surely none of us want to be driving on unregulated public roads where you might encounter/have a crash with unroadworthy cars and/or unlicensed dangerous drivers. 

In the same manner, the private ownership of land confers certain rights, but still operating within the broader framework of those relevant Victorian laws and regulations that apply day-to-day. These two features of ‘the private rights of a landowner’ and ‘complying with relevant laws and regulations’ are not mutually exclusive, but work alongside each other. 

These basic concepts and parameters are reinforced by the Queensland Supreme Court decision Bone v Mothershaw [2002] QCA 120. The key feature of this case for our purposes was it involved a dispute whether certain Queensland laws regulating ‘tree removal’ were valid. In upholding the validity of these contested laws, it is very on point and significant that Justice McPherson states at [19] that “In addition to historical considerations like these, a mere reference in a statute to an interest in land that is recognised at common law, such as an estate in fee simple, does not have the effect of transforming that interest, or the rights incidental to it, into statutory interests and rights”. 

Similarly His Honour at [25] says in relation to the private landowner in question who was affected by the ‘tree removal’ laws – “He retains unimpaired, for what it is worth, his estate in fee simple absolute of the land”. 

The key point here is that Bone v Mothershaw reinforces the fundamental feature of our modern society that where tension arises, our private interests (including the notion of ‘fee simple’) are constrained by those relevant laws and regulations that provide a legal framework for all of us to together live a workable and civilised life (not the other way around).

28 August 2025

Prediction

'Predictive privacy: Collective data protection in the context of artificial intelligence and big data' by Rainer Mühlhoff in (2012) Big Data And Society comments 

Big data and artificial intelligence pose a new challenge for data protection as these techniques allow predictions to be made about third parties based on the anonymous data of many people. Examples of predicted information include purchasing power, gender, age, health, sexual orientation, ethnicity, etc. The basis for such applications of “predictive analytics” is the comparison between behavioral data (e.g. usage, tracking, or activity data) of the individual in question and the potentially anonymously processed data of many others using machine learning models or simpler statistical methods. The article starts by noting that predictive analytics has a significant potential to be abused, which manifests itself in the form of social inequality, discrimination, and exclusion. These potentials are not regulated by current data protection law in the EU; indeed, the use of anonymized mass data takes place in a largely unregulated space. Under the term “predictive privacy,” a data protection approach is presented that counters the risks of abuse of predictive analytics. A person's predictive privacy is violated when personal information about them is predicted without their knowledge and against their will based on the data of many other people. Predictive privacy is then formulated as a protected good and improvements to data protection with regard to the regulation of predictive analytics are proposed. Finally, the article points out that the goal of data protection in the context of predictive analytics is the regulation of “prediction power,” which is a new manifestation of informational power asymmetry between platform companies and society. 

One of the today's most important applications of artificial intelligence (AI) technology is so-called predictive analytics. I use this term to describe data-based predictive models that make predictions about any individual based on available data. These predictions can relate to future behavior (e.g. what is someone likely to buy?), to unknown personal attributes (e.g. sexual identity, ethnicity, wealth, education level), to momentary vulnerabilities (vulnerable conditions such as frustration, depression, loneliness, financial difficulties, pregnancy, etc.), or to personal risk factors (e.g. mental or physical disease predispositions, addictive behavior, or credit risk). Predictive analytics is controversial because, although it has socially beneficial applications, the technology has an enormous potential for abuse and is currently scarcely regulated by law. Predictive analytics makes it possible to automate and, therefore, significantly scale the exploitation of individual vulnerabilities, as well as fostering unequal treatment of individuals in terms of access to economic and social resources such as employment, education, knowledge, healthcare, and law enforcement. Specifically, in the context of data protection and anti-discrimination, the application of predictive AI models needs to be analyzed as a new form of data power large IT companies wield and which relates to the stabilization and production of discriminatory structures, patterns of exploitation, and data-based societal inequalities. 

Against the backdrop of the enormous societal impact of predictive analytics, I will argue (as others have argued before me, cf. Hildebrandt, 2009; Hildebrandt and Gutwirth, 2008; Mittelstadt, 2017; Taylor et al., 2016; Taylor, 2016; Vedder, 1999) that we need new approaches to data protection in the context of big data and AI. In my approach, I will use the concept of predictive privacy to normatively capture this novel form of privacy violation through inferred or predicted information. That is, applying predictive models to individuals in order to support decisions is a violation of privacy, yet it is one which does not come about either through “data theft” or a breach of anonymization. Predictive analytics proceeds according to the principle of “pattern matching” by learning algorithms that compare auxiliary data known about a target individual (e.g. usage data on social media, browsing history, geolocation data) against the data of many thousands of other users. This pattern matching is at the core of predictive privacy violations and is possible wherever there is a sufficiently large group of users disclosing their sensitive attributes alongside behavioral and auxiliary data—usually, because they are unaware that this data can be exploited using big data-based methods, or because they think they personally “have nothing to hide.” As I will argue, the problem of predictive privacy denotes a limit to the liberalism inherent in contemporary views of data privacy as the individual's right to control what data is shared about them. The issue of predictive privacy thus strengthens the case for anchoring collectivist protective goods and collectivist defensive rights in data protection. 

In the philosophical theories of privacy, collectivist perspectives have long taken into account that one's own data can potentially have negative effects on other people as well, and have therefore posited that individuals should not be free to decide in every respect what data they disclose about themselves to modern data companies (Hildebrandt, 2009; Hildebrandt and Gutwirth, 2008; Loi, Christen, 2020; Mantelero, 2016; Mittelstadt, 2017; cf. Regan, 2002; Taylor et al., 2016). I will also argue that large collections of anonymized data relating to many individuals should not be freely processable by data processors because predictive capacities can be extracted from anonymous data sets. This is in contrast to the current legal situation under the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), which does not restrict the processing and storage of anonymized data and the predictive models (or “profiles,” to use the terminology of Hildebrandt, 2009) derived from them. Finally, I will call for the rights of data subjects as outlined by the GDPR (right of access, rectification, deletion, and so on) to be reformulated in a collectivist manner, so that affected groups and the community as a whole would be empowered, for the sake of the common good, to exercise such rights against data-processing organizations and thereby prevent the misuse of predictive capacities.

27 August 2025

Rights

'In the name of nature: Making the League of Nations, the International Rights of Nature Tribunal and international law' by Tim Lindgren in Leiden Journal of International Law comments 

In 1919, the League of Nations and the Mandate System were established through the Treaty of Versailles. Shy of 100 years later, the International Rights of Nature Tribunal gathered in the same city to establish itself as an international peoples’ tribunal, taking form outside the international legal order. For all their differences, these institutions shared some commonalities. Both institutions claimed to be concerned with the ‘wellbeing’ of ‘peoples’ through international law. Both also claimed to represent some kind of international legal community. For the League, this was a community of states. For the Tribunal, it was a community of peoples. 

This article reads these institutional moments together and considers what they tell us about the discipline of international law. It traces how both institutions constituted and authorized themselves as if speaking for an already given international legal community – and how they did so precisely by mobilizing competing ideas of ‘nature’, ‘peoples’, and ‘statehood’. The article argues that the institutions deployed similar legal techniques and narratives that limited what the international legal domain might, and might not, look like. Namely, they presented their ideas of ‘nature’ and ‘peoples’ as part of a natural order of things, authorizing themselves as vanguards for whatever form of international legal order they saw as ‘natural’. Ultimately, the piece complicates our understanding of the international legal domain and peoples’ tribunal in it, inviting a reflexivity over what it means to speak law in the name of an international community – be it as ‘states’, ‘peoples’ or ‘nature’ itself.

14 August 2025

Medical Device Regulation

The TGA report Clarifying and strengthening the regulation of Medical Device Software including Artificial Intelligence states 

In the 2024-25 federal Budget, the Australian Government provided $39.9 million over 5 years for the development of policy and capability across government to support Safe and Responsible AI. The measure includes work to clarify and strengthen existing laws and address risks and harms from Artificial Intelligence (AI) through an immediate review of priority areas, including health and aged care sector regulation, Australian consumer law, and copyright law. 

As part of the Australian Government’s Department of Health, Disability and Ageing (the Department), the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) regulates therapeutic goods, including software and AI models and systems when they meet the definition of a medical device under the Therapeutic Goods Act 1989. Software-based medical devices (including AI models and systems) have been regulated by the TGA for many years. In 2021, we clarified the classification levels of software to account for the potential and emerging risks of harm associated with software, and introduced a number of “carve-outs” for very low risk products or products that had oversight from other regulators. With input from relevant industry stakeholders, we published guidance about our refined regulatory framework, setting out how regulatory requirements apply to these kinds of devices. Since that time, the TGA has monitored the refinements to identify when further review and adjustment was required, including to address emerging risks as technology like AI is rapidly adopted and deployed in healthcare settings. 

In 2024, the TGA conducted a review in tandem with the Department’s broader review of health and aged care legislation, to: • determine whether our existing legislation, regulations and guidance are appropriate to meet the challenges associated with an increasing use of medical software and AI across the healthcare sector, and • identify measures to clarify and strengthen existing regulation to mitigate risks and leverage opportunities associated with medical software and AI use in the therapeutic goods sector. 

Extensive targeted engagement with stakeholders from cohorts including the medical device industry, consumers and clinicians has been conducted, followed by a public consultation process seeking more information and feedback about strengths of the system, opportunities for improvements and identified issues and areas of concern. Our review also included mapping the existing medical device legislative framework against the mandatory guardrails for use in high-risk settings proposed by the Department of Industry, Science and Resources (DISR) in their consultation: Introducing mandatory guardrails for AI in high-risk settings: proposals paper.

The TGA goes on to comment

It is likely that the time and costs associated with regulatory requirements appear to developers to be disproportionate when compared to the time and costs associated with the development of a software product. A further cultural issue is the pervading belief among some developers that software products don’t present a meaningful risk to consumers and users, particularly when they are integrated with the provision of healthcare, where a human is in the loop, or where outputs are information only. 

Stakeholders, including clinicians and consumers who use these kinds of products, have identified that the absence of humans, lack of transparency and failure to engage with existing regulatory requirements represent a combination of circumstances that may lead to patient harm. In many instances, users are not aware that AI or machine learning has been used in the development of software, or is used operationally within the clinical workflow. 

Further  

Regulatory requirements for medical devices, including software, are principles-based and apply regardless of whether the product incorporates components like AI, chatbots, cloud, mobile apps or other technologies. As such, software that incorporates generative AI such as large language models (LLMs), text generators, and multimodal generative AI are all regulated as a medical device if they meet the definition under the Act. As a component of the review, we mapped the existing legislative framework, including regulations and guidance, against the mandatory guardrails proposed for use in high-risk settings under the proposal put forward by DISR in their consultation: Introducing mandatory guardrails for AI in high-risk settings: proposals paper. A summary is at Attachment A. 

This section documents key features of the existing framework for the regulation of medical devices including: • Technology agnostic regulation • Risk based classification • Principles based regulation • International harmonisation 

Technology-agnostic regulation 

Australia’s regulatory approach to medical devices is technology-agnostic, with legislative requirements centred on risk and principles rather than linking specific requirements to explicit features or technologies. A technology-agnostic approach requires those responsible for manufacturing a medical device to: • identify the specific and potential risks associated with the device throughout its lifecycle • institute measures to mitigate both identified and residual risks • have measures in place for ongoing review and monitoring of the device’s performance after it has been deployed, and • engage in ongoing review and refinement of the device once deployed. 

This approach provides flexibility and responsiveness to emerging technologies, allowing lower risk devices to enter the market expeditiously while subjecting higher risk devices to greater regulatory scrutiny to ensure quality, safety, and performance throughout the device life cycle. The continuation of a technology-agnostic approach will provide flexibility to ensure appropriate regulation is capable of being applied to emerging technologies without the need for continual review and refinement of legislation. Moving away from a technology-agnostic approach where the onus for demonstrating safety, quality and performance rests with the manufacturer or deployer may lead to the introduction of risks as developers adopt a “tick-box” mentality to regulation rather than a proactive engagement and assessment of the risks posed by their products. 

Development of specific regulatory requirements for individual technologies is also likely to become a limiting factor with respect to the development of innovative devices in the long term, as devices that don’t easily fit within specified parameters struggle to meet requirements that were never intended for devices of their nature. 

Risk based classification 

In Australia, devices are classified using classification rules set out in Schedule 2 of the Therapeutic Goods (Medical Devices) Regulations 2002. 

The classification of a medical device is determined by factors including how long the device will be continuously used for and how invasive the device is. For software-based medical devices, classification may also be impacted by whether the device is intended for use by a clinician or a consumer, and the seriousness of the illness or condition for which it is intended to be used. The classification of a device will determine the level of scrutiny and pre-market assessment applied to the device before it can be deployed/supplied. 

Principles based regulation 

In Australia, manufacturers are required to demonstrate that medical devices comply with the essential principles. These are legislative requirements that are further set out in Schedule 1 of the Regulations, and relate to specific characteristics of medical devices including design, construction, evidence supporting the use of the device and information to be provided with the device. 

Manufacturers must ensure their devices meet all relevant principles and sponsors must either hold or be able to obtain this evidence from their manufacturer on request. Principles-based regulation, as opposed to prescriptive or rules-based regulation, provides flexibility. This approach accommodates the broad complexity and diversity of medical devices regulated, including as new technologies like AI emerge. A rules-based approach may, for example, require compliance with prescribed requirements including international standards such as ISO or IEC standards. 

Demonstrating compliance with the essential principles may include compliance with relevant international standards, but for emerging technologies where an appropriate standard may not yet exist, other approaches may be used. The flexibility to adapt the principles to the unique circumstances of a medical device, particularly those incorporating emerging technologies, allows approaches to evolve over time without continuous review and updating of legislative frameworks. 

International harmonisation 

Our current approach and commitment to international harmonisation allows sponsors of medicines and medical devices to use international assessment and approvals from comparable overseas regulators to support applications for inclusion of their therapeutic goods on the ARTG. 

The TGA is also a member of the IMDRF, which seeks to “strategically accelerate international medical device regulatory convergence to promote an efficient and effective regulatory model for medical devices that is responsive to emerging challenges while protecting and maximizing public health and safety.” 

The IMDRF has published a significant number of regulatory guidance documents for adoption by jurisdictions globally. Guidance documents are developed through specialised Working Groups and involve global public consultation processes. The TGA is an active member of both the IMDRF Software as a Medical Device (SaMD) Working Group and the IMDRF Artificial Intelligence/Machine Learning Working Group, which have both published a range of guidance documents. The AI Working Group is currently focused on finalising additional guidance on good machine learning practices and new guidance on AI lifecycle management, while the SaMD Working Group is developing an approach to pre-approved change control plans (PCCPs). 

Software regulation and reforms 

The TGA regulates AI when it meets the legislative definition of a medical device in Section 41BD of the Act. AI products likely to meet this definition include those intended to be used for the diagnosis, prevention, monitoring, prediction, prognosis, treatment, or alleviation of a disease, injury or disability. 

In recent years, software has become increasingly important in medical devices and digital adoption more broadly. It is also becoming more important as a medical device in its own right. Rapid innovation in technology has driven significant changes to software function and adoption, giving rise to a larger number of devices able to inform, drive or replace clinical decisions, or directly provide therapy to an individual. 

Advances in computing technology and software production have led to a large increase in the number of software-based medical devices available on the market, requiring the implementation of reforms to ensure patient safety. Software-based medical devices are medical devices that incorporate software or are software, including software as a medical device, or software that relies on hardware to function as intended, and are regulated in Australia by the TGA. 

These kinds of devices may be integrated within electronic health records systems, used by clinicians or health professionals in the provision of care, or used to determine how or when patients will receive care. Their increasing use, integration in healthcare systems, and complexity have given rise to new regulatory challenges. In 2021, the TGA introduced a number of regulatory refinements aimed at ensuring the regulation of software-based medical devices, including software that functions as a medical device, remains appropriate and targets the risks associated with these kinds of devices appropriately. Refinements included: • amendments to the essential principles include the addition of Essential Principle 12.1, which details specific requirements for programmed or programmable medical devices or software that is a medical device • new classification rules for software based medical devices used for diagnostic or screening purposes to capture their potential to cause harm through the provision of incorrect information • introduction of an exemption from TGA regulation for certain clinical decision support software, and • exclusion of certain software products for the sake of clarity, or where existing oversight measures were available through other regulatory frameworks to ensure these products were safe and fit for their intended purpose.  

11 August 2025

Deaths

'The Law of Digital Resurrection' by Victoria Haneman in (2025) 66(5) Boston College Law Review 1569-1626 comments 

The digital right to be dead has yet to be recognized as an important legal right. Artificial intelligence, augmented reality, and nanotechnology have progressed to the point that personal data can be used to resurrect the deceased in digital form with appearance, voice, emotion, and memory recreated to allow interaction with a digital app, chat bot, or avatar that may be indistinguishable from that with a living person. Users may now have a completely immersive experience simply by loading the personal data of the deceased into a neural network to create a chatbot that inherits features and idiosyncrasies of the deceased and dynamically learns with increased communication. There is no legal or regulatory landscape against which to estate plan to protect those who would avoid digital resurrection, and few privacy rights for the deceased. This intersection of death, technology, and privacy law has remained relatively ignored until recently. This Article is the first to respect death as an important and distinguishing part of the conversation about regulating digital resurrection. Death has long had a strained relationship with the law, giving rise to dramatically different needs and idiosyncratic legal rules. The law of the dead reflects the careful balance between the power of the state and an individual’s wishes, and it may be the only doctrinal space in which we legally protect remembrance. This Article frames the importance of almost half of a millennium of policy undergirding the law of the deceased, and proposes a paradigm focused upon a right of deletion for the deceased over source material (data), rather than testamentary control over the outcome (digital resurrection), with the suggestion that existing protections are likely sufficient to protect against unauthorized commercial resurrections.

06 August 2025

(Un)Harnessing AI

The interim report by the Productivity Commission on Harnessing Data and Digital Technology - consistent with the national government's enthusiasm for AI - can be read as proposing a looser regulatory framework. 

The report states 

Data and digital technologies are the modern engines of economic growth. Emerging technologies like artificial intelligence (AI), which can extract useful insights from massive datasets in a fraction of a second, could transform the global economy and speed up productivity growth. 
 
Australia needs to harness the consumer and productivity benefits of data and digital technology while managing and mitigating the downside risks. There is a role for government in setting the rules of the game to foster innovation and ensure that Australians reap the benefits of the data and digital opportunity. 
 
The economic potential of AI is clear, and we are still in the early stages of its development and adoption. Early studies provide a broad range of estimates for the impact of AI on productivity. The Productivity Commission considers that multifactor productivity gains above 2.3% are likely over the next decade, though there is considerable uncertainty. This would translate into about 4.3% labour productivity growth over the same period. But poorly designed regulation could stifle the adoption and development of AI and limit its benefits. Australian governments should take an outcomes based approach to AI regulation – one that uses our existing laws and regulatory structures to minimise harms and introduces technology specific regulations as a last resort. 
 
Data access and use can fuel productivity growth: insights from data can help reduce costs, increase the quality of products and services and lead to the creation of entirely new products. But some requirements in the Privacy Act, the main piece of legislation for protecting privacy, are constraining innovation without providing meaningful protection to individuals. For example, complying with the controls and processes baked into the Act can make consent and notification a ‘tick box’ exercise – where businesses comply with the letter of the law but not the spirit of it. The Australian Government should amend the Privacy Act to introduce an alternative compliance pathway that enables firms to fulfil their privacy obligations by meeting outcomes based criteria. 
 
Data about individuals and businesses underpins growth and value in the digital economy. But often those same individuals and businesses cannot easily access and use this data themselves. Under the right conditions, giving people and businesses better access to data that relates to them can stimulate competition and allow businesses to develop innovative products and services. A mature data sharing regime could add up to $10 billion to Australia’s annual economic output. 
 
Experience shows that we need a flexible approach to facilitating data access across the economy, where obligations placed on data holders and the level of government involvement can match the needs and digital maturity of different sectors. New lower cost and flexible regulatory pathways would help to guide expanded data access throughout the digital economy, focusing first on sectors where the gains can be significant and relatively easy to achieve. 
 
Financial reports provide essential information about a company’s financial performance, ensuring transparency and accountability while informing the decisions of investors, businesses and regulators. Government can further spark productivity by making digital financial reporting the default – that is, mandatory lodgement of financial reports in machine readable form. At the same time, the Australian Government should remove the outdated requirement that financial reports be submitted in hard copy or PDF format. This change would increase the efficiency and accuracy with which information is extracted and analysed.

The  draft recommendations are

 Artificial intelligence 

Draft recommendation 1.1 Productivity growth from AI will be built on existing legal foundations. 

Gap analyses of current rules need to be expanded and completed. Australian governments play a key role in promoting investment in digital technology, including AI, by providing a stable regulatory environment. Any regulatory responses to potential harms from using AI must be proportionate, risk based, outcomes based and technology neutral where possible. 

The Australian Government should continue, complete, publish and act on ongoing reviews into the potential gaps in the regulatory framework posed by AI as soon as possible. 

Where relevant gap analyses have not begun, they should begin immediately. 

All reviews of the regulatory gaps posed by AI should consider: • the uses of AI • the additional risk of harm posed by AI (compared to the status quo) in a specific use case • whether existing regulatory frameworks cover these risks potentially with improved guidance and enforcement; and if not how to modify existing regulatory frameworks to mitigate the additional risks. 

Draft recommendation 1.2 AI specific regulation should be a last resort 

AI specific regulations should only be considered as a last resort for the use cases of AI that meet two criteria. These are: • where existing regulatory frameworks cannot be sufficiently adapted to handle the issue • where technology neutral regulations are not feasible.   

Draft recommendation 1.3 Pause steps to implement mandatory guardrails for high risk AI 

The Australian Government should only apply the proposed ‘mandatory guardrails for high risk AI’ in circumstances that lead to harms that cannot be mitigated by existing regulatory frameworks and where new technology neutral regulation is not possible. Until the reviews of the gaps posed by AI to existing regulatory structures are completed, steps to mandate the guardrails should be paused. 

Data access 

Draft recommendation 2.1 Establish lower cost and more flexible regulatory pathways to expand basic data access for individuals and businesses 

The Australian Government should support new pathways to allow individuals and businesses to access and share data that relates to them. These regulatory pathways will differ by sector recognising that the benefits (and the implementation costs) from data access and sharing are different by sector. This could include approaches such as: • industry led data access codes that support basic use cases by enabling consumers to export relatively non sensitive data on a periodic (snapshot) basis • standardised data transfers with government helping to formalise minimum technical standards to support use cases requiring high frequency data transfers and interoperability. 

These pathways should be developed alongside efforts that are already underway to improve the Consumer Data Right (which will continue to provide for use cases that warrant its additional safeguards and technical infrastructure) and the My Health Record system. 

The new pathways should begin in sectors where better data access could generate large benefits for relatively low cost; and there is clear value to consumers. Potential examples include: • enabling farmers to combine real time data feeds from their machinery and equipment to optimise their operations and easily switch between different manufacturers • giving tenants on demand access to their rental ledgers which they can share to prove on‑time payments to new landlords or lenders • allowing retail loyalty card holders to export an itemised copy of their purchase history to budgeting and price comparison tools that can analyse spending and suggest cheaper alternatives. The scope of the data access pathways should expand over time based on industry and consumer consultation, where new technology, overseas experience or domestic developments show that there are clear net benefits to Australia.   

Privacy regulation 

Draft recommendation 3.1 An alternative compliance pathway for privacy 

The Australian Government should amend the Privacy Act 1988 (Cth) to provide an alternative compliance pathway that enables regulated entities to fulfil their privacy obligations by meeting criteria that are targeted at outcomes, rather than controls based rules. 

Draft recommendation 3.2 Do not implement a right to erasure 

The Australian Government should not amend the Privacy Act 1988 (Cth) to introduce a ‘right to erasure’, as this would impose a high compliance burden on regulated entities, with uncertain privacy benefits for individuals. 

Digital financial reporting 

Draft recommendation 4.1 Make digital financial reporting the default 

The Australian Government should make the necessary amendments to the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and the Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth) to make digital financial reporting mandatory for disclosing entities. The requirement for financial reports to be submitted in hard copy or PDF format should also be removed for those entities.

It goes on

AI specific regulation should be a last resort 

AI specific regulations should only be considered as a last resort for the use cases of AI that meet two criteria. These are: • where existing regulatory frameworks cannot be sufficiently adapted to handle the issue • where technology neutral regulations are not feasible. 

Economy wide efforts to regulate AI should be paused until all gap analyses are complete and implemented 

In August 2024 Australian Government Department of Industry, Science and Resources released a set of 10 voluntary AI safety standards, or guardrails, based on risk management standards such as ISO/IEC 42001:2023 (Information technology – Artificial intelligence – Management system) and the National Institute of Standards and Technology’s Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework (AI RMF 1.0) (DISR 2024b, p. 5). The guardrails cover aspects of AI development and application. They require several risk-management processes. These include testing of models, developing a risk plan and providing transparency to users of AI tools and owners of copyrighted materials used in the training of models. The guardrails outline reasonable risk-management practices for many organisations. In this way they have served a very important and useful step in AI governance in Australia by equipping businesses with voluntary, structured and internationally recognised standards to support and guide their adoption of AI. 

The guidelines are very useful for smaller businesses without comprehensive risk-management procedures in place. Indeed, submissions from participants to this inquiry (and submissions to the mandatory guardrails – discussed below – consultation process ) showed that many larger organisations have implemented risk management protocols that are similar in spirit to these guardrails. 

Mandating the guardrails is not necessary 

In September 2024 (DISR 2024a) a proposals paper for a set of mandatory guardrails for AI in high risk settings was released by the Australian Government. The proposal is to turn the voluntary guidelines into mandatory regulations for AI development and application. 

The PC is concerned with two aspects of the guardrails being made mandatory. First, the proposals paper argued that the mandatory guardrails would apply to all high risk uses of AI – regardless of whether risks can be better mitigated through outcomes based regulations. Second, the proposals paper argued that General Purpose AIs – which would include many generative AI tools – above a certain threshold of capability be classified as high risk by default. The proposals paper did not argue for any particular measure or threshold for technical capability, though it could include aspects like FLOPS (DISR 2024a, p. 18). It was argued that these models can perform so many functions that their risks cannot be adequately foreseen. This could result in the guardrails being applied to common generative AI tools such as ChatGPT, Claude and Grok, depending on what is chosen as the threshold and measure of technical capability. 

In general, high risk uses of AI can be split into three broad types. 

1. High risk uses that can be adequately controlled by existing regulatory frameworks (potentially with some modification) – this could include issues with privacy law (which the PC thinks can be resolved within existing frameworks with modification to make the regulations more outcomes focused, chapter 2). 

2. High risk uses that can be adequately controlled with new technology neutral regulations – this could include (non consensual) sexually explicit deepfake images which the Australian Government has recently banned (through the Criminal Code Amendment (Deepfake Sexual Material) Act 2024). 

3. High risk use cases that require technology specific regulations – these would be use cases identified in the various gap analyses as having no technology neutral solution. 

The PC’s concern with the guardrails is that they would not distinguish between these categories. This in our view raises significant issues, as the first two cases can already, by definition, be dealt with adequately by other regulatory mechanisms. It might also result in most commercial chatbots being classified as high risk regardless of the efficacy of existing regulations. The result of this approach is that many AI models would be complying with two different sets of regulation to achieve the same outcome. 

For example, the TGA’s review noted that with respect to medical devices, all ten proposed guardrails had close parallels in existing regulations (2025, pp. 27–30). That is, it is likely that firms providing AI based medical devices in Australia would already be fulfilling the objectives of the guardrails if they are operating legally under the TGA’s existing regulations. But if the guardrails are mandated, then the provider of the medical device would need to demonstrate compliance with the TGA regulations and the guardrails, raising the regulatory burden with no change in outcomes. 

The mandating of the guardrails is only appropriate in circumstances where existing regulatory frameworks or new technology-neutral regulations are not able to adequately mitigate the risk of harm. Once the Australian Government has completed and acted on all gap analyses of its existing policy framework, it will know what regulatory holes cannot be plugged by existing frameworks or new technology neutral legislation. Consideration of economy wide efforts to mandate the guardrails should be paused until these gap analyses are complete. 

Pause steps to implement mandatory guardrails for high risk AI The Australian Government should only apply the proposed ‘mandatory guardrails for high risk AI’ in circumstances that lead to harms that cannot be mitigated by existing regulatory frameworks and where new technology neutral regulation is not possible. Until the reviews of the gaps posed by AI to existing regulatory structures are completed, steps to mandate the guardrails should be paused.

In dealing with copyright the PC states 

 Copyright violation is an example of a harm that AI could exacerbate by changing economic incentives. Previous waves of innovation in information and communication technology have made the sharing of copyrighted materials much cheaper and easier, creating challenges for copyright. In most instances, copyright law was able to be adapted (or better enforced) to mitigate the harm. This made it unnecessary to directly regulate technology by, for example, regulating computer software or hardware to prevent copyright breach. It is the PC’s view that the copyright issues posed by AI can also similarly be resolved through adapting existing copyright law frameworks rather than introducing AI specific regulation. 

What is copyright? 

Copyright law prohibits a person from using original works without the permission of the copyright holder – usually the author (AGD 2022a). The types of works that are protected include text, artistic works, music, computer code, sound recordings and films (ACC 2024a). It does not protect the underlying ideas or information (AGD 2022a). In some cases, data and datasets may be protected, ‘largely depend[ing] on how the data has been arranged, structured or presented’ (Allens 2020, p. 3).  

The rise of AI technology has led to new challenges for copyright law. 

The emergence of AI also raises some additional, principle based questions about how the copyright framework (as part of Australia’s broader intellectual property regime) works to benefit society by encouraging creation and innovation, rewarding intellectual effort and achievement, and supporting the dissemination of knowledge and ideas. (AGD 2023c, p. 12) 

In 2023, the Attorney General established the Copyright and Artificial Intelligence Reference Group, which acts as ‘a standing mechanism to engage with stakeholders across a wide range of sectors on issues at the intersection of AI and copyright’ (AGD 2023a). Since then, the group has met on several occasions to discuss issues relating to AI technology and copyright law (AGD 2023a). 

This section explores one issue particularly relevant to productivity: whether current Australian copyright law is a barrier to building and training AI models. There are other legal issues relating to the outputs of AI models that are less relevant to productivity – such as whether those outputs attract copyright protection and what happens when AI outputs infringe a third party’s copyright (Evans et al. 2024). 

Training AI models 

Building and refining AI models requires the use of large amounts of data. 

The term ‘AI model training’ refers to this process: feeding the algorithm data, examining the results, and tweaking the model output to increase accuracy and efficacy. To do this, algorithms need massive amounts of data that capture the full range of incoming data. (Chen 2023) The datasets used to train AI models often contain digital copies of media such as web pages, books, videos, images and music. These media are often the subject of copyright protection, which means that their use to train AI models requires permission from the copyright holder. 

Permission is required because AI models must ‘copy’ the protected material at least temporarily to undertake the training process. The use of copyrighted materials to train an AI model is a separate issue to the copyright status of anything the model produces. As discussed above, AI outputs may have their own copyright challenges. 

A survey of the Copyright and Artificial Intelligence Reference Group indicated that, in practice, a range of copyrighted materials are used to train AI models – including literary and artistic works, sound recordings, films and musical works (AGD 2024, p. 12). 

There is evidence to suggest that large AI models are already being trained on copyrighted materials without consent or compensation (APA and ASA, qr. 39, pp. 3–4; APDG, qr. 6, p. 4; APRA AMCOS, qr. 58, p. 4; ARIA and PPCA, qr. 65, p. 5, Creative Australia, qr. 62, p. 3). It should be noted that Australian copyright law only applies to copying that occurs within Australia’s boundaries – in other words, the training of AI models overseas is subject to the relevant laws of the jurisdiction in which it occurs. Lawsuits have been brought against technology companies – including Meta, Microsoft and OpenAI – in some overseas jurisdictions about the unlicensed use of copyrighted works to train AI models (Ryan 2023). 

There are concerns that the Australian copyright regime is not keeping pace with the rise of AI technology – whether because it does not adequately facilitate the use of copyrighted works or because AI developers can too easily sidestep existing licensing and enforcement mechanisms. There are several policy options, including: • no policy change – that is, copyright owners would continue to enforce their rights under the existing copyright framework, including through the court system • policy measures to better facilitate the licensing of copyrighted materials, such as through collecting societies • amending the Copyright Act to include a fair dealing exception that would cover text and data mining. 

The PC is seeking feedback on what reforms are needed to bring the copyright regime up to date. 

Is there a need to bolster the licensing or enforcement regime? 

Several participants expressed concern about the unauthorised use of copyrighted materials to train AI models. For example, Creative Australia said: Much of the data has been used reportedly without consent from the original creator, and without acknowledgement or remuneration. The global nature of the technology industry has made it difficult for the owners of creative work to enforce their intellectual property rights and be remunerated for the use of their work. (qr. 62, p. 3) 

There are two points at which concerns of this type could be addressed. First, they could be addressed before the fact, through copyright licensing. Licensing is the key mechanism through which a copyright holder grants permission for others to use their work and often involves some form of payment. In Australia, licensing is often done through collecting societies, which are organisations that represent copyright holders. This can streamline the licensing process, because the collecting society can negotiate licences on behalf of multiple copyright holders at once. As the Copyright Agency said: We can help these sectors use third party content for AI related activities. Our annual licence for businesses now allows staff to use news media content in prompts for AI tools (e.g. for summarisation or analysis). We are extending this to other third party content later in the year. We are also in discussions with our members and licensees about other collective licensing solutions, including the use of datasets for AI related activities. (qr. 7, pp. 2–3) 

The issue of unauthorised use of copyrighted materials could also be addressed after the fact, through enforcement. This encompasses a range of possible measures, including take down notices, alternative dispute resolution and court action. In 2022 23, the Attorney General’s Department undertook a Copyright Enforcement Review to assess ‘whether existing copyright enforcement mechanisms remain effective and proportionate’ (AGD 2022b). That review found that additional regulatory measures are needed to achieve an effective copyright enforcement regime, and work is currently underway to identify options for: • reducing barriers for Australians to use of the legal system to enforce copyright, including examining simple options to resolve ‘small value’ copyright infringements • improving understanding and awareness about copyright. (AGD 2023b) 

In light of this ongoing work, the issue of copyright enforcement is not in scope for this inquiry. 

Is there a case for a text and data mining exception? 

Another option is to expand the existing ‘fair dealing’ regime, which provides certain exceptions to the requirement to obtain permission from the copyright holder (box 1.6). Currently, there is no exception that covers AI model training per se (The University of Notre Dame Australia 2024). However, depending on the case, a different exception could apply. For example, AI models built as part of research could fall within the scope of the ‘research or study’ exception. 

Box 1.6 – What are fair dealing exceptions? 

Fair dealing exceptions allow for the use of copyright material without permission from the copyright owner, so long as it is used for one of several specified purposes and is considered fair. What are the specified purposes? The Copyright Act specifies several purposes where the exception may apply. These include: research or study, criticism or review, parody or satire, reporting news, and enabling a person with a disability to access the material (Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), Part III, Div 3; Part VIA, Div 2). 

What counts as ‘fair’? 

Fairness is determined with regard to all the relevant circumstances – that is, it depends on the facts. Some purposes have specified criteria that must be taken into account. For example, where the use is for research or study, the following considerations apply: • the purpose and character of the dealing • the nature of the work • whether the work can be obtained within a reasonable time at an ordinary commercial price • the effect of the dealing upon the potential market for, or value of, the work • how amount and substantiality of the work that was copied (Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), s 40(2)). 

The ‘fair use’ doctrine – an alternative approach 

Some overseas jurisdictions (notably the United States) take a ‘fair use’ approach to copyright exceptions. Under this doctrine, any types of use can be considered non infringing, provided that it is considered ‘fair’ – in other words, the use need not fall within one of several defined categories. Several reviews have recommended the adoption of the fair use doctrine in Australia (including by the Australian Law Reform Commission and the Productivity Commission), but this has not occurred. Source: ACC (2024b); ALRC (2013); Copyright Act 1968 (Cth); PC (2021, p. 187). 

In its report on Copyright and the Digital Economy, the Australian Law Reform Commission recommended amendments to enable text and data mining by adopting a fair use approach to copyright exceptions (box 1.6) – or, failing that, through a new fair dealing exception. It explained: There has been growing recognition that data and text mining should not be infringement because it is a ‘non expressive’ use. Non expressive use leans on the fundamental principle that copyright law protects the expression of ideas and information and not the information or data itself (2013, p. 261)  

The Australian Government has since indicated that it is not inclined to introduce a fair use regime (Australian Government 2017, p. 7). Therefore, the PC is considering whether there is a case for a new fair dealing exception that explicitly covers text and data mining (a ‘TDM exception’). TDM exceptions exist in several comparable overseas jurisdictions (box 1.7). 

Such an exception would cover not just AI model training, but all forms of analytical techniques that use machine read material to identify patterns, trends and other useful information. For example, the use of text and data mining techniques is common in research sectors to produce large datasets that can be interrogated through statistical analysis. 

Box 1.7 – Text and data mining around the world 

European Union: There are two text and data mining (TDM) exceptions embedded in the Digital Single Market Directive (EU 2019/790) – one for scientific research (article 3) and another for general use (article 4). The Artificial Intelligence Act (Regulation (EU) 2024/1689) specifically characterises the training of AI models as involving ‘text and data mining techniques’ (recital 105) and refers to the TDM exception (article 53). The recent case of Kneschke v. LAION [2024] endorsed the view that the TDM exception extends to cover AI training (Goldstein et al. 2024a, 2024b). 

United States: It has been argued that training AI models falls within the scope of the fair use doctrine (Khan 2024; Klosek and Blumenthal 2024). However, the case Thomson Reuters v. Ross [2023] 694 F.Supp.3d 467 highlights that whether AI training is covered by the doctrine depends on whether the fair use factors are met in the circumstances (ReedSmith 2025). 

United Kingdom: There is a TDM exception for that applies to non commercial research (UK Intellectual Property Office 2014). There have been proposals to expand the exception to cover all uses, though these are still under consideration (Pinsent Masons 2023; UK Government 2024). 

Japan: The Japanese Copyright Act includes broad statutory exemptions for TDM (article 30 4(ii)), provided the work is used for ‘non enjoyment’ purposes (Senftleben 2022, p. 1494). In essence, the requirement for ‘non enjoyment’ distinguishes between whether the work is being consumed as a work or as data, and is broadly equivalent to the distinction between expressive and non expressive uses. 

Singapore: The Singaporean Copyright Act includes a specific TDM exception, as well as a broader fair use exception (Ng-Loy 2024). 

To assist its consideration of this option, the PC is seeking feedback about the likely effects of a TDM exception on the AI market, the creative sector and productivity in general – particularly in light of the following considerations. • At present, large AI models (including generative AI and large language models) are generally available to be used in Australia. The introduction (or not) of a TDM exception is unlikely to affect whether AI models continue to be available and used in Australia (PC 2024c, p. 13). • At present, large AI models are trained overseas, not in Australia. It is unclear whether the introduction of a TDM exception would change this trend. • As discussed above, large AI models are already being trained on unlicensed copyrighted materials. • A TDM exception could make a difference to whether smaller, low compute models (such as task specific models) can be built and trained in Australia, such as by Australian research institutions, medical technology firms, and research service providers. It should also be noted that a TDM exception would not be a ‘blank cheque’ for all copyrighted materials to be used as inputs into all AI models. As discussed in box 1.4, the use must also be considered ‘fair’ in the circumstances – this requirement would act as a check on copyrighted works being used unfairly, preserving the integrity of the copyright holder’s legal and commercial interests in the work. There may be a need for legislative criteria or regulatory guidance about what types of uses are likely to be considered fair. 

Information request 1.1 

The PC is seeking feedback on the issue of copyrighted materials being used to train AI models. • Are reforms to the copyright regime (including licensing arrangements) required? If so, what are they and why? The PC is also seeking feedback on the proposal to amend the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) to include a fair dealing exception for text and data mining. • How would an exception covering text and data mining affect the development and use of AI in Australia? What are the costs, benefits and risks of a text and data mining exception likely to be? • How should the exception be implemented in the Copyright Act – for example, should it be through a broad text and data mining exception or one that covers non commercial uses only? • Is there a need for legislative criteria or regulatory guidance to help provide clarity about what types of uses are fair?

03 August 2025

Pseudolaw and GenAI

'Pseudolaw and the illusion of legal meaning' by Joe McIntyre in (2025) Alternative Law Journal states 

This article is an overview of the contemporary phenomenon of pseudolaw and argues that, at its heart, it involves a mistaking of the form of legal argumentation for its substance. Essentially, through the use of legalistic language, archaic sources and strange rituals, an illusion of legal meaning is created which tricks users into believing their actions are legally meaningful. This article argues that it shares common features with generative AI, in that it produces an illusion of meaning which users mistake for actual meaning. It then explores this juxtaposition and its implications for responses to pseudolaw. 

Anyone who has spent extended time in Australian courts in the last five years will be familiar with the very strange phenomenon that is pseudolaw. A confident, assertive, self-represented litigant will rise to make their appearance only to argue the judge has no authority as the court is displaying the wrong coat of arms; or they will assert they are a ‘natural person’ not subject to the law; or they argue that the judge has somehow committed treason. A vivid illustration is provided in the case of Georganas v Georganas, when a pseudolaw ‘guru’ interceded from the public gallery:

Unknown Speaker: Stand down … Judge [X], you are concealing treason against the King of England … you are now charged, you are under arrest … You are trading in necromancy, you are treating dead people in this courtroom. You are in treason. You are in treason, you must stand down under the Bill of Rights now.

These types of arguments are, of course, without any legal merit. They do not work, and are rightly regarded as ‘obvious nonsense’, ‘pseudo-legal gibberish’, or ‘gobbledygook’. Yet these forms of argument continue to proliferate, with a significant growth seen in the years since the COVID-19 pandemic. This is no longer a fringe concern: such matters are now occurring on a daily basis in Australian courts, and in some jurisdictions is already being seen to profoundly reshape litigation. 

Courts are busy places, and pseudolaw can be particularly disruptive, not least because of the disproportionate impact of each pseudolaw case compared to other cases. The case law involving pseudolaw matters commonly includes statements of judicial concern about the systemic impact of such cases. For example, in Rossiter v Adelaide City Council, Livesey J observed that pseudolegal arguments have ‘without reservation been rejected as involving both legal nonsense and an unnecessary waste of scarce public and judicial resources.’ The burden of dealing with pseudolaw matters is having a profound impact on the courts. As one judicial officer put it:

It uses up so much court resources because every time they want to file something they end up making the lives of the Registry staff miserable. [The clerk’s] email inbox … [is] full of emails from them. They have changed the whole face of the civil justice system.

In this article, I provide an overview of the contemporary phenomenon of pseudolaw and argue that – at its heart – it involves a mistaking of the form of legal argumentation for its substance. Essentially, through the use of legalistic language, archaic sources and strange rituals, an illusion of legal of meaning is created which tricks users into believing their actions are legally meaningful. That these users lack legal literacy, are largely alienated from the law, and desperately want to believe in the promise of pseudolaw means that this illusion is difficult to displace. I argue, however, that it is critical the scale and nature of this threat to the good administration of justice is recognised and countered – not least because it is quickly merging with another emerging phenomenon, the use of generative AI (‘GenAI’), which shares many of these same characteristics. 

This article briefly draws out the similarities between GenAI and pseudolaw, with the goal of helping the reader better understand both phenomena. Unfortunately, the collision between GenAI and pseudolaw is already beginning to disrupt our courts, and it is increasingly necessary that we are all familiar with the contours of both the overlap between them and their impact upon the administration of justice. 

Ultimately, I argue that – as amusing as some of the examples may be – pseudolaw itself is no laughing matter. It is, as I have written elsewhere, ‘disrupting our courts … threatening our judicial officers and administrators [and] harming all who come into contact with it.’ The same is true on the increasing use of GenAI in litigation – it can appear humorous, but is increasingly problematic. As these two phenomena collide, it is critical we stop laughing and start learning.

'The Impact of Pseudolaw on Local Government' by Stephen Young and Harry Hobbs in (2025) 36(4) Public Law Review comments 

The COVID-19 pandemic saw a significant rise in the number of people making pseudolegal arguments in an effort to avoid public health measures. Legal scholarship exploring this phenomenon has largely focused on its impact on the administration of justice. However, as the level of government closest to the community, local governments have also faced a growing strain from pseudolegal adherents and conspiracy theorists. In this article, we explore their (misuse) of law and its impact on local government in Australia and New Zealand. We find three main impacts. Pseudolegal adherents have: attempted to construct parallel governance institutions as a means to exert power and control; intimidated and harassed local government authorities by issuing threats and disrupting public meetings; and, imposed a substantial administrative burden on staff by inundating offices with baseless correspondence. While pseudolaw may seem like obscure or picayune legal quirkiness, its impact on local government is anything but minor—it constitutes a growing threat to governance, public safety, and the rule of law. ... 

In May 2024, Lance Vervoort, Chief Executive Officer of the Hamilton City Council, received a letter submitted as part of a Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act 1987 (NZ) (‘LGOIMA’) request. The letter contained excerpts from the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 (NZ), the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (‘ICCPR’), and the 1947 Nuremberg Code. The excerpts were liberally annotated with explanations such as, ‘New Zealand became a member of the ICCPR 1978 and being INTERNATIONAL LAW, it supersedes all Legislation’. The letter explained further that these ‘are VERYY [sic] IMPORTANT DOCUMENTS which all peoples should be aware of, but most people aren’t’. The author of the letter asserted that Hamilton City Council is breaching international law because it is illegally conducting medical experiments on the people of Hamilton by fluoridating drinking water. The author declared that the obligation to follow the law is based on consent freely given. As he had not consented to fluoridation, the Council is operating criminally. 

Almost every legal claim in the letter is wrong. In New Zealand (and Australia), international law does not automatically supersede domestic legislation; the relationship between the state and its citizens is not based on contract; and a duly enacted law applies regardless of whether a person consents to its operation. The veracity of the factual claims is no better. Fluoride is a naturally occurring compound that is found in almost all fresh water. Fluoridation is the addition of fluoride to drinking water to protect against tooth decay, a well-established public health measure with decades of evidence demonstrating that it effectively improves oral health. The legal basis for fluoridation in New Zealand is also sound. Prior to 2021, the judiciary consistently found that local governments possessed the legal authority to fluoridate water. Since 2021, amendments to the Public Health Act 1956 (NZ) have made the position even clearer. Under s 116E of the Act, the Director-General may direct a local authority to add fluoride to its drinking water. Even if Mr Vervoort agreed with the author of the letter, he has no power to counteract a direction and remove fluoride. In any event, as this example demonstrates, concerns around fluoridation are often mixed with conspiracy theory and pseudolaw, such as the claim that it ‘removes freedom of choice by consumers’. The result is that any potentially meritorious legal questions are buried among voluminous and incoherent claims. 

The letter did not clearly ask a question of the council. Nonetheless, because it was filed as a LGOIMA request, the Hamilton City Council was required by law to respond. While the Council’s response was short, merely explaining that it was following the laws and regulations of New Zealand, it necessitated time, attention and resources that might have been better placed elsewhere. One strange letter is not a problem. However, this is just one of many conspiracy and pseudolaw-inflected LGOIMAs that the Council has responded to in the last few years. Hamilton is not alone. Local governments across New Zealand and Australia increasingly face administrative burdens derived from pseudolegal conspiracies. In some cases, they also face intimidation, threats and a real risk of physical harm. 

This is not new to those working in local government. The growing legal literature on pseudolaw and sovereign citizens, however, largely focuses on the origins, spread and manifestation of pseudolegal beliefs worldwide and their impact on law and the administration of justice rather than on the burdens it imposes on local government authorities. Similarly, while scholars in other disciplines examine pseudolaw through the lens of conspiracy theorising, extremism, criminal justice, and linguistics, there remains a dearth of study of pseudolegal adherents’ impact on local government. This is especially concerning now that pseudolaw has a ‘global reach’, having ‘migrated across the common law world and appear[ing] also in arrange of civil law countries’. We address this lacuna in this article. We focus specifically on its impact on local governments in Australia and New Zealand. Our study allows us to identify that pseudolaw is affecting local government in several significant ways. Furthermore, it reveals that although the impact is felt similarly across jurisdictions, the conduct of adherents manifests itself in diverse styles as pseudolaw evolves and adapts as it migrates. Pseudolaw in Australia and New Zealand has latched onto local legal, political and moral issues and arguments, including those based on the rights of Indigenous peoples. 

Our article is divided into two substantive parts. Recognising that pseudolaw remains an understudied phenomenon, in Part II, we contextualise our subject. We explain what pseudolaw is, orient our article in the wider legal literature, and provide background to understand what is occurring in New Zealand and Australia. In Part III, we explore the three primary impacts pseudolaw and sovereign citizens have on local government in Australia and New Zealand. First, adherents are establishing alternative and parallel governance institutions, including ‘Common Law Courts’ to enforce their vision of society. Second, members of these groups threaten and intimidate elected councillors and council staff by serving warrants and judgments issued from their fake courts and disrupting public meetings. Third, members waste the time and resources of local government by abusing local government obligations and by refusing to pay for services. Ultimately, the costs of responding to pseudolegal claims are more than financial — they represent a broader erosion of public institutions and a challenge to democratic governance.